Login for full access to ABQJournal.com

New Users: Subscribe here


Pioneer in field of deaf studies dies

Robert Panara, a leading educator of the deaf, is shown in 2006 at a vintage baseball game between two all-deaf teams in Mumford, N.Y. (AP Photo/Democrat and Chronicle, Will Yurman)

Robert Panara, a leading educator of the deaf, is shown in 2006 at a vintage baseball game between two all-deaf teams in Mumford, N.Y. (AP Photo/Democrat and Chronicle, Will Yurman)

Robert Panara could not hear the noise in Yankee Stadium the day in 1931 when Babe Ruth emerged from the dugout, strode toward him and extended his hand.

Panara, then 10 years old, was deaf. He had lost his hearing several months earlier – a casualty of spinal meningitis – and his father had organized the ballpark encounter hoping that the thrill might bring it back.

“Shaking hands with the Bambino was a dream come true,” Panara told an interviewer years later. “But I still remained as deaf as a post.”

Panara grew up to become a preeminent scholar in the field of deaf studies, a writer and poet and a noted professor at institutions including Gallaudet University in Washington and the National Technical Institute for the Deaf (NTID) in Rochester, N.Y.

Panara died July 20 at a nursing home in Rochester. He was 94 and had heart ailments, said his son, John Panara.

Growing up in Depression-era New York, Panara received few of the services or accommodations available today for deaf or hearing-impaired students.

Because he had post-lingual deafness – the loss of hearing after the acquisition of language – he was able to communicate through lip-reading and spoken English and continued his education in mainstream public classrooms.

He learned sign language after high school and pursued higher education at what was then Gallaudet College. Literature – his passion since he lost his hearing – became the focus of his study.

Panara taught for nearly two decades at Gallaudet before becoming the first deaf professor at NTID, which was established by an act of Congress in 1965 and is part of the Rochester Institute of Technology. A Shakespearean scholar, Panara started the institute’s drama program and taught classes on literature and creative interpretation through sign language.

“His style in teaching was always appreciated by students – both deaf and hearing,” Gallaudet President T. Alan Hurwitz, who previously led NTID, wrote in an e-mail.

Beginning in the 1970s, Panara wrote articles and books that helped establish deaf studies as a formal line of academic inquiry.

The field “helped to open doors and open minds,” his biographer and friend, Harry G. Lang, wrote in an e-mail. “People realized that deaf persons had been contributing in meaningful ways for centuries, and young deaf people should be given the chance.”

In 1957, Panara figured in an episode that joined the “lore of the American deaf community,” according to Lang. That year, Elizabeth II of England made her first official visit to the United States as queen. She was scheduled to attend a football game at the University of Maryland – with no reporters to be seated near her.

In pursuit of full coverage of the event, Life magazine enlisted Panara and a Gallaudet student as lip readers. Equipped with binoculars, they observed the queen from afar.

“How many men are on the team?” she wished to know. “Why do they gather that way?” she asked, observing a huddle.

Based on the translation, Life reported that the queen was “a remarkably savvy spectator with a quick eye to pick out and a ready tongue to ask about the pertinent points of the game.”


Note: Readers can use their Facebook identity for online comments or can use Hotmail, Yahoo or AOL accounts via the "Comment using" pulldown menu. You may send a news tip or an anonymous comment directly to the reporter, click here.

Read previous post:
Fish found in NM on ‘endangered’ list

Environmentalists are welcoming the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's decision to list a rare fish found near the Arizona-New Mexico...