Law says inmate consent to sex is nonexistent - Albuquerque Journal

Law says inmate consent to sex is nonexistent

When is consent for sex not really consent? This question is the crux in the retrial of Enock Arvizo, a correctional officer charged with criminal sexual penetration of a Bernalillo County Metropolitan Detention Center inmate. Arvizo was acquitted on one charge in May, and the jury was split on a second charge. In this retrial for that second charge, the prosecutors have submitted documents arguing that inmates cannot consent to sex with correctional officers. In the first trial, Judge Zamora instructed the jurors to consider whether Arvizo’s sexual act was “done without consent.” The prosecution is asking that the jurors not be given this instruction in the retrial because it will confuse a jury.

At issue is the legitimacy of inmates to consent to sex. Is the power difference between inmates and guards so large that inmates are incapable of consenting to sexual advances by guards? The power difference between inmates and correctional officers is so extreme that it negates any ability for an inmate to consent to sex with a guard or other prison staff, the New Mexico Supreme Court stated in a 2016 ruling:

“[T]he control that a prison guard exerts over an inmate extends into virtually every facet of the inmate’s life … The prison guard-inmate relationship is an irreducibly unpleasant one, oriented around captivity and control. For two decades the New Mexico Legislature has recognized the potential for abuse inherent in this relationship, specifically in the form of sexual assault.”

The N.M. Supreme Court’s description of inmate/officer power dynamics is an apt one in our experience at the Rape Crisis Center. The very nature of incarceration is that inmates cannot make the minutest of decisions, like when or if to take a shower, what or when to eat, whether the lights are on or off, and when or whom they can call. If an inmate isn’t even allowed to make these basic decisions for him/herself, how can he/she possibly consent to sex with the persons in charge of making all these decisions?

The Supreme Court continues by quoting the specific statute and concluding: ” ‘Criminal sexual penetration in the second degree consists of all criminal sexual penetration perpetrated on an inmate confined in a correctional facility or jail when the perpetrator is in a position of authority over the inmate.’ The essential elements of [this law] are a legislative acknowledgment of the power disparity between the inmate and the corrections officer and a recognition that this disparity not only facilitates sexual assault of the vulnerable party but makes meaningful voluntary consent to sexual intercourse an unrealistic inquiry.”

Arvizo’s position is that there is no N.M. statute that specifically states that inmates cannot consent to sex. On the contrary, the New Mexico state law the Supreme Court quoted above makes it clear that a correctional officer having sex with an inmate is illegal, and that an inmate’s “consenting” to sex with an officer is invalid.

In the end, an inmate’s “consent” is a moot point. The 2003 Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA), a civil law enacted unanimously in Congress and still in effect nationwide, defines sexual abuse of an inmate by staff member, contractor or volunteer as sexual acts with or without the consent of the inmate. If a correctional officer pursues sex with an inmate and the inmate “consents” to it, it is still considered sexual abuse under PREA. While sexual abuse under PREA may not meet the criteria for criminal sexual penetration, it does open up possibilities of civil liability, such as the $2.1 million Bernalillo County paid to three of Arvizo’s victims in November 2016. As long as we in New Mexico and in society as a whole continue to believe that an inmate can consent to sex with a guard and acquit the guard, we taxpayers will continue to pay for the perpetrator’s crime.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Law says inmate consent to sex is nonexistent


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
In an effort to raise awareness of Native language ...
Entertainment
'A Fistful of Dollars' will be ... 'A Fistful of Dollars' will be a special premiere screening at 7 p.m. Aug. 16, at the KiMo Theatre, 423 Central NW.
2
With a wildly-diverse menu, Luminaria is a shining star
Dining Reviews
Luminaria Restaurant features classic Italian staples ... Luminaria Restaurant features classic Italian staples made special with a New Mexico twist.
3
Happy Accidents named Best New U.S. Cocktail Bar
Blogs
The 2022 Spirited Awards are presented ... The 2022 Spirited Awards are presented by the Tales of the Cocktail Foundation.
4
Florist coming to Meow Wolf for first NM performance
Entertainment
It takes time to create a ... It takes time to create a body of work in music.For the members of Florist, they weren ...
5
Artist finds inspiration in fantasy, mythology and steampunk
Entertainment
George Hayes III is currently showing ... George Hayes III is currently showing at The Gallery ABQ and East Mountain Public Library
6
Phantoms to make tour stop at Salt Yard West
Entertainment
Phantoms will make a stop in ... Phantoms will make a stop in Albuquerque at Salt Yard West on Friday, Aug. 12.
7
‘Bodies Bodies Bodies’ delivers razor-sharp satire
Entertainment
"Bodies Bodies Bodies " might just ... "Bodies Bodies Bodies " might just be the first great Gen Z thriller. In director Halina Reijn's fil ...
8
Cody Canada and The Departed coming to Red River ...
Entertainment
Cody Canada and The Departed are ... Cody Canada and The Departed are taking part in the 8750' BBQ and Music Festival in Red River.
9
Pint's baseball return brings former top pick to 'Topes
Featured Sports
From 2016 first round draft pick ... From 2016 first round draft pick to 2021 MLB retiree, Riley Pint is back in the game with the Isotopes and loving baseball again.