Driver in fatal cyclist crash gets 10½ years - Albuquerque Journal

Driver in fatal cyclist crash gets 10½ years

The driver of a roofing company truck accused of killing a Santa Fe woman and another person when he plowed the truck into a group of bicyclists in Tucson, Ariz., has been sentenced to 10½ years in prison.

Brian Lynch

Pima County Superior Court records show that 30-year-old Brian Lynch had changed his plea to guilty on Aug. 1.

Last week, he pleaded guilty to two counts of manslaughter, two counts of aggravated assault and one count of endangerment, and was sentenced.

According to authorities and toxicology reports, Lynch had methamphetamine in his system when he ran a red light in March 2016 and fatally struck five cyclists who were all in a bike lane.

Clare Rhoades

Clare Rhoades, 72, of Santa Fe, a retired nurse practitioner and avid outdoor adventurer, and Tucson resident Kenneth Vieira, 68, were killed.

Judy Costlow of Santa Fe was also among the injured.

The Santa Fe riders were part of a group on a Tucson biking trip with Santa Fe Seniors on Bikes. The bicyclists had stopped at an intersection to wait for a green light when Lynch, a driver for Scott Roofing, ran into the group with his work truck.

Costlow, Vieira’s spouse, and Rhoades’ spouse, Santa Fe attorney Richard Hughes, all filed civil suits against Lynch and Scott Roofing, headquartered in Phoenix. All three suits were settled for undisclosed terms over the past week or so.

The insurers of Scott Roofing said in court documents filed before the settlements were reached that they were “ready and willing” to pay $11 million – which the insurance companies say is the limit under their policies – to claimants “entitled to receive them.” The companies also said the claims against the roofing company “may exceed” the policy limits.

In late July, a judge ordered one of the companies to post $10 million with the court. A settlement would not necessarily be limited to what the insurance companies would pay.

In February, Tucson television station KVOA reported that Lynch’s former live-in girlfriend said in a court affidavit that Lynch used cocaine and that she had suspected he was using meth.

The TV station also says that, in an interview, the same woman said that Lynch would “drink and drive all the time.”

When he needed to get a commercial drivers license, the woman said, he was given a box of “synthetic urine” and that “his boss bought it for him so he could pass his drug test.” The woman said she was “positive” Lynch had made those statements.

Scott Roofing gave KVOA a statement that didn’t address the drug test matter. “Scott Roofing grieves with the victims’ families and the entire Tucson community,” the statement said. “Scott Roofing is committed to learning all the facts.”

Costlow said Thursday she couldn’t discuss the civil litigation. And she said she has “no memory of the crash or the next seven days.”

On Lynch’s criminal case, Costlow said,”I’m just glad it’s over and I didn’t have to go to a trial.”

“By the time he gets out of jail, he’ll probably be in his 40s, and hopefully he’ll have had time to get rehabilitated.” She said she was not out for revenge.

Costlow said she has mostly recovered from her injuries. “I have some residual stuff, and you never know what will happened down the line,” she said, adding, “I have a lot of metal in me.

“Basically, he took a year out of my life,” she said of Lynch.

But Costlow said she’s back to biking and hiking, and is the current president and ride director of Seniors on Bikes.

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop


Exhaustion in the ICU: Doctors reflect on state's nearly ...
From the newspaper
New Mexicans urged to get vaccinated, ... New Mexicans urged to get vaccinated, wear masks indoors
Half of city voters favor Keller's job performance
2021 city election
60% approval rating a year ago ... 60% approval rating a year ago likely due to pandemic response
TOP OF MIND: Should schoolchildren be required to be ...
From the newspaper
This week's question: Should children 5 ... This week's question: Should children 5 and older be required to have COVID-19 vaccinations, along with other required immunizations, to attend public schools in ...
Taos hosts its 38th micro balloon event
From the newspaper
Views of the 'spectacular' Rio Grande ... Views of the 'spectacular' Rio Grande Gorge and nearby mountains are a draw
'Nova' series tells the story of the universe from ...
Chris Schmidt is no stranger to ... Chris Schmidt is no stranger to making films about science and space.He's made a caree ...
Tarantulas: Listening for love
Dozens join guided tour seeking much-maligned ... Dozens join guided tour seeking much-maligned arachnids
Anita Hill urges us all to battle gender violence
Anita Hill didn't care if President ... Anita Hill didn't care if President Joe Biden apologized or not, but she found his aversion to doing ...
North Sports: Week in Review
Boys' Soccer
A look back at the top ... A look back at the top sporting stories, and scores, in northern New Mexico
Xeric Garden Club to host event
Xeric Garden Club of Albuquerque will ... Xeric Garden Club of Albuquerque will host a presentation by George Duda, a founding member of Think ...