Family of woman shot by APD cop says vital evidence was not preserved

The family of a young woman shot and killed by Albuquerque police in 2014 is asking for a default judgment against the city in a wrongful death suit, arguing that vital evidence in the case was not properly preserved.

Mary Hawkes

The argument centers on a series of videos recorded that April night, along with the various malfunctions that some officers said prevented their cameras from taping the deadly encounter between then-officer Jeremy Dear and Mary Hawkes.

Attorneys for the Hawkes family argue, among other things, that some videos the city has provided were altered and that the faulty cameras some officers were wearing should have been preserved as evidence.

In a hearing Wednesday, plaintiffs’ attorneys argued that the city police department had a duty to maintain that evidence and that breaching that duty should lead to sanctions.

They point to 10 specific items of evidence that were improperly preserved. The lack of that evidence, they said, would benefit the city at trial.

The city argued that default judgment is a “drastic sanction” that should be used only in extreme circumstances. They said the city had an obligation to preserve evidence only when it was put on notice that a lawsuit would be filed.

“Without such notice, city defendant cannot be expected to speculate about what conspiracy theories that plaintiffs would create concerning the cameras and the videos,” attorneys for the city wrote in a response to the Hawkes’ motion.

Judge Nan Nash is expected to decide in coming weeks whether sanctions are appropriate.

At Wednesday’s hearing, attorney Laura Schauer Ives argued that the city has turned over only altered versions of the original lapel camera recordings. An on-body camera expert said in an affidavit that the files had been edited before they were saved as evidence.

But the city holds that those files have been forensically examined and “have not been altered since they were initially recorded by the assigned cameras.”

Former Albuquerque Police Department officer Jeremy Dear

Dear has said that his camera was unplugged at the time of the shooting. In his and other cases where a camera failed to record the incident, attorneys argue that the device should have been preserved as evidence.

The city said that while the video recorded is pertinent evidence, the camera itself is not. And as to Dear’s camera specifically, they said it was sent to the manufacturer for analysis.

The company found that the camera was turned off and on during the Hawkes incident, but the reason it powered down couldn’t be determined.

Dear was fired months after shooting 19-year-old Hawkes, who was suspected of stealing a truck. The police chief has said Dear was terminated after he repeatedly failed to use his lapel camera, despite being instructed to do so following several complaints.

Share Your Story

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


Direct ABQ-Hollywood flight to begin in January
ABQnews Seeker
A new daily direct flight between ... A new daily direct flight between Albuquerque and Hollywood Burbank Airport ...
Santa Fe deputies shoot, injure person in Santa Fe
ABQnews Seeker
Santa Fe County deputies shot and ... Santa Fe County deputies shot and injured a person Thursday evening in Santa Fe. New Mexico State Police, on Twitter, said no deputies were ...
Atrisco Acequia event this Saturday
ABQnews Seeker
Many Albuquerque acequias have supported regional ... Many Albuquerque acequias have supported regional farming for more than 300 years. Local water and government groups will kick off the Atrisco Acequia Madre ...
State reports 13 more COVID deaths
ABQnews Seeker
The state reported 882 new cases ... The state reported 882 new cases of COVID-19 and 13 additional deaths in an update Thursday afternoon. The numbers brought the total to 243,962 ...
Intel to partner with NM colleges on hiring push
ABQnews Seeker
Intel Corp. is partnering with five ... Intel Corp. is partnering with five prominent New Mexico colleges and universities on a student hiri ...
APD still looking for suspect in fatal bar shooting
ABQnews Seeker
The man accused in a quadruple ... The man accused in a quadruple shooting that left one man dead outside an Albuquerque sports bar is still on the loose. Gilbert Gallegos, ...
Rio Rancho workers get pandemic hazard pay, vaccination incentives
ABQnews Seeker
City hopes move will help to ... City hopes move will help to reduce employee turnover
Lobos look 'Inland' once again for latest hoops recruit
ABQnews Seeker
Maps tell us Southern California's 'Inland ... Maps tell us Southern California's 'Inland Empire' region doesn't reach New Mexico. Lobo basketball plans to bring it to the Pit next year anyway. ...
Honoring the service of military veterans with a ride ...
ABQnews Seeker
'There are no distractions, not a ... 'There are no distractions, not a lot of people talking' up in a small plane