Bail reform needed to fight crime surge - Albuquerque Journal

Bail reform needed to fight crime surge

New Mexico is besieged by crime.

This is painfully old news to New Mexicans. Albuquerque and cities and towns across the state are suffering from a crime-rate spike. Residents are understandably alarmed, and businesses are even threatening to relocate to safer destinations.

When I was U.S. Attorney, I spent much of my time trying to lock up violent offenders, sexual predators and drug kingpins. But I became frustrated that our system kept sweeping up so many low-level, non-violent offenders, and we were turning them into better criminals rather than better citizens. That was certainly true with respect to our money bail system. That’s why I was so pleased to see New Mexico cast off the status quo and take steps to reduce the number of repeat offenders and keep the most high-risk individuals behind bars.

A constitutional amendment passed by New Mexico voters and new procedural rules issued by the New Mexico Supreme Court are helping to overhaul the traditional cash bail system, in which a judge sets a dollar amount and the defendant must pay up or wait behind bars for their trial to commence. In cash bail systems, bail is often set based on the charges rather than the risk a defendant poses. This means that violent offenders and sexual predators who can pony up the cash go free.

The cash bail system also creates a distinct disadvantage for people who can’t pay. These individuals, often accused of low-level, non-violent offenses, are forced to stay in jail because they are unable to post bond. This has serious consequences for the defendants themselves as well as society as a whole. Research shows that defendants who are detained during the pretrial period are more likely to become unemployed and commit future crimes – and detaining these largely non-violent defendants costs taxpayers billions of dollars each year.

Constitutional Amendment 1, placed on the ballot by the state Legislature and approved by voters last November, does two things. First, it allows judges to detain people who are a flight risk and/or a danger to the community. Second, it prohibits courts from detaining people solely because they are too poor to post bail. The Supreme Court followed with new rules requiring that all release and detention decisions by courts be based on evidence of individual risk posed by defendants. Yet the bail bondsmen have become so desperate to preserve their ability to line their pockets, they are funding lawsuits aimed at derailing common-sense reforms, including the use of data-driven tools that judges can use to help gauge the risk a defendant poses. Thankfully, a federal judge in New Mexico has already rejected their claims as meritless at the preliminary stage, and the public is getting wise to their perverse profit motivation.

Despite these important advances, no system will ever be perfect. And recent news stories have highlighted opportunities to improve the new pre-trial release measures, particularly with respect to prosecutors’ input on why certain defendants should qualify as high-risk. But in the long run, risk assessment tools are far superior to a system predicated entirely on money.

Similar reform measures are already working in other states. In New Jersey, the pre-trial jail population is down 15.8 percent since the state began using a risk assessment tool known as the Public Safety Assessment. During that same time period, crime has dropped 3.8 percent, and violent crime has decreased 12.4 percent, according to the New Jersey State Police.

By shifting away from cash bail, our justice system becomes blind to the wealth of the accused and instead focuses pre-trial release decisions on the specific individual’s threat to the public. As a member of the law enforcement community who has spent his entire life removing violent and sexual offenders from society, I’m grateful to the people of New Mexico, who had the courage to lead the country in reforming a centuries-old system that wasn’t providing the public safety return they deserve.

Bail reform needed to fight crime surge

Election Guide

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Bail reform needed to fight crime surge

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

Editorial: Do you know what your kids are watching?
A New Mexico lawsuit is one ... A New Mexico lawsuit is one of six in the country targeting TikTok as a result of "blackout ch ...
Editorial: Young Shiprock poet shines in D.C. spotlight
It's a long way from Shiprock ... It's a long way from Shiprock to Washington, D.C.    Jesse Begay got there on t ...
GOP should have targeted NM's awful licensing rules
From the newspaper
Mailer misses the point: Too many ... Mailer misses the point: Too many with minor offenses can't work in professions here
Agriculture must be part of water conservation strategy
From the newspaper
When it comes to any water ... When it comes to any water crisis, no matter whose fault it is, it's all our problem. Fortunat ...
NM's military bases pack an economic punch
From the newspaper
Installations' impact detailed in new report Installations' impact detailed in new report
Governor candidates could find tricky footing in homelessness debate
ABQnews Seeker
Ronchetti and Lujan Grisham could find ... Ronchetti and Lujan Grisham could find homelessness, panhandling and tent cities to be tricky topics to navigate as they run in next month's gubernatorial ...
View from the basket
ABQnews Seeker
First balloon ride puts new city ... First balloon ride puts new city in perspective
Keller wins latest veto battle over safe outdoor spaces
ABQnews Seeker
City Council fails to redirect funding City Council fails to redirect funding
Former NM college official found guilty in embezzlement scheme
From the newspaper
SANTA FE – A ... SANTA FE – A former official at Northern New Mexico College has pleaded guilty in an embezzl ...