APS board votes to criticize science curriculum changes - Albuquerque Journal

APS board votes to criticize science curriculum changes

The Albuquerque Public Schools Board of Education and Superintendent Raquel Reedy are speaking out against controversial science curriculum proposed by the New Mexico Public Education Department.

APS Superintendent Raquel Reedy

On Tuesday, the board’s policy committee voted 5-1 to send PED a letter that criticizes the proposal to exclude references to evolution, rising global temperatures and the age of Earth from state science standards.

Board member Peggy Muller-Aragón cast the lone vote against the letter, and supported PED’s push to make the controversial edits to the Next Generation Science Standards, a curriculum created by a consortium of 26 states in 2013.

Under PED’s plan, a reference to Earth’s “4.6 billion year history” was replaced with “geologic history” in the middle school curriculum. The proposal also omits a reference to a “rise in global temperatures” and replaces it with “fluctuations” in temperature.

“I have looked and thought these look good to me because they kind of leave things a little bit open for the other side,” Muller-Aragón said.

She added that she didn’t want to demean anyone whose spiritual or religious beliefs align with PED’s curriculum changes.

Muller-Aragón said APS should not be adversarial over the proposed standards, and instead should “focus on what is positive” in them.

The rest of the board was uniformly critical.

“We don’t need Scopes trials going on,” said board member Barbara Petersen, referencing the landmark 1925 court case on teaching human evolution in public schools.

Petersen, a former teacher, said educators sometimes face resistance to lessons on evolution and other topics from parents. The board’s letter will show teachers that they have support to “teach real science,” Petersen said.

Board member Lorenzo Garcia said he is also behind the letter, but questioned whether PED will listen to different points of view.

“I am skeptical,” he said, adding that he feels the district’s input has been ignored in the past.

To Garcia, PED’s plan undermines the scientific method.

Reedy shared her own letter to PED on Tuesday. It highlights possible economic impacts if national businesses don’t move to New Mexico because they believe the state’s workforce is not well educated.

Technological driven jobs “demand that students be prepared for scientific fields and the standards must reflect that demand for our graduates,” Reedy’s letter states.

PED chief Christopher Ruszkowski told the Journal that he is open to feedback, and the proposed changes are not set in stone.

“I think it is incumbent on us to have a very hard look at all the feedback that comes in — both in terms of the standards themselves and in terms of the roll-out and the implementation and the resources and the partnership” he said.


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Half of city voters favor Keller's job performance
2021 city election
60% approval rating a year ago ... 60% approval rating a year ago likely due to pandemic response
2
Book merchant Jim Hoffsis was a pillar of Old ...
ABQnews Seeker
Korean War veteran was an admirer ... Korean War veteran was an admirer of military, supporter of local authors
3
Gonzales' current job approval stands at 34%
2021 city election
Democratic sheriff has little support from ... Democratic sheriff has little support from members of own party
4
NM film and television community honors Halyna Hutchins
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico's film and television community ... New Mexico's film and television community came together to remember cinematographer Halyna Hutchins at a candlelight vigil at Civic Plaza in Albuquerque on Saturday ...
5
Journal Poll: Keller has large lead over mayoral opponents
2021 city election
Gonzales, Aragon lag behind; runoff may ... Gonzales, Aragon lag behind; runoff may not be needed
6
Hours before showtime, Las Cruces High's band truck is ...
ABQnews Seeker
The Las Cruces High School Showcase ... The Las Cruces High School Showcase band's trip to Albuquerque this weekend started on a sour note. Hours before the Zia Marching Band Fiesta ...
7
Don't forget: 10-digit phone dialing to be required in ...
ABQnews Seeker
Starting Sunday, phone users across New ... Starting Sunday, phone users across New Mexico must include area codes when dialing to make all calls, including local calls that previously only required ...
8
States mostly defer to union guidance for on-set gun ...
ABQnews Seeker
Safety standards developed by film studios ... Safety standards developed by film studios and labor unions are the primary protection for actors and film crews when a scene calls for using ...
9
Vigil to be held at Civic Plaza for cinematographer
ABQnews Seeker
The New Mexico community will come ... The New Mexico community will come together to remember filmmaker Halyna Hutchins. The 42-year-old director of photography was killed on the set of 'Rust' ...