Editorial: Rio Rancho gets schooled on its open records fees - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: Rio Rancho gets schooled on its open records fees

Rio Rancho city officials should consider why state law NMSA 1978 Article 14, Chapter 2, is the “Inspection of Public Records Act” and not the “Copying of Public Records Act.” Contrary to the actions of the city clerk’s office, the act is not supposed to be a copy-shop revenue stream.

Back in January, Rio Rancho resident Dianne Goodman, a frequent user of IPRA, formally requested access to all 911 calls and call-for-service reports for a specific address in Rio Rancho since 2012. But a city official told Goodman the audio recordings of 911 calls were unavailable until they were copied and put into a different format – and that a fee of $30 per call was required in advance.

While the illegal and exorbitant fee would have scared off many public-records seekers – and that could have been the intent – Goodman went to the state Attorney General’s Office, one of the agencies charged with upholding IPRA.

The AG’s Office has now informed Rio Rancho city clerk Stephen Ruger that inspection of public records should cost the requester nothing and that the law allows government agencies to charge a “reasonable” fee for downloading or copying records should the requester ask for copies. It says they cannot charge fees for the cost of “identifying and isolating records,” called the $30 fee for downloading the records excessive, and recommends the city re-evaluate its fee structure to ensure IPRA compliance.

Goodman got her records; the city is refunding her $30. Unfortunately, the fight isn’t over. A spokeswoman says the city disagrees with the AG’s “interpretation” of “relevant statutory language” and will review the “suggestions” to determine if it will amend its policy. The AG and the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government have been down this road before; the smart (and public) money is on them.

Every record Rio Rancho officials produce is on behalf of the citizenry, and with narrow exceptions that citizenry should get full cooperation to know what government is doing.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: Rio Rancho gets schooled on its open records fees


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Editorial: NM merits radiation compensation, too
Editorials
Extending the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act ... Extending the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act another two years was the right thing to do. Conti ...
2
Editorial: Sorry, NM lawmaking doesn’t need armed staff
Editorials
Guns can be intimidating. That's why ... Guns can be intimidating. That's why crooks often brandish them while robbing stores.  &n ...
3
Editorial: Pulitzer honors NM artist
Editorials
Earlier this month, Raven Chacon, a ... Earlier this month, Raven Chacon, a Diné composer based in Albuquerque, became the first Native Ame ...
4
Editorial: Pet-surrender fee unleashes avalanche
Editorials
Since the Journal implemented a weekly ... Since the Journal implemented a weekly Top of Mind question last fall for our expanded Sunday Opinio ...
5
Editorial: Make fire-ravaged NM whole
Editorials
The federal response to Gov. Michelle ... The federal response to Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham's request for disaster relief as a result ...
6
Editorial: Ronchetti best among GOP field for governor
Editorials
Today, the Journal concludes its endorsements ... Today, the Journal concludes its endorsements in contested primary races with its picks for governor ...
7
Editorial: Journal announces endorsements for state AG, auditor and ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its endorsements ... Today, the Journal announces its endorsements in contested primary races for New Mexico attorney gen ...
8
Editorial: Journal backs Garcia Holmes and Vasquez in CD1 ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its endorsements ... Today, the Journal announces its endorsements for contested primary races for the U.S. House of Repr ...
9
Editorial: Journal announces endorsements for BernCO commission and county ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its primary ... Today, the Journal announces its primary endorsements for Bernalillo County commission and county assessor.