Confusion reigns over public access to APD oversight communications - Albuquerque Journal

Confusion reigns over public access to APD oversight communications

All sides in a yearslong Albuquerque police reform effort have asked the federal judge overseeing the process to clarify what the city should do when it receives public records requests for documents, such as communications between the monitor overseeing the reforms and police officials.

The city, in a joint motion filed in court last week, said it has received requests for such records.

The settlement agreement between the city and the U.S. Department of Justice says that communications between the city and the monitor shouldn’t be made public.

But documents such as emails to city officials and drafts of reports are public records under the New Mexico Inspection of Public Records Act, said Peter St. Cyr, the executive director of the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government.

“The city is in a catch-22 situation as it tries to follow both the state public records law and the Settlement Agreement, which is a federal court order,” City Attorney Jessica Hernandez said in an email.

‘We want to make sure that we satisfy our obligations under both, but they say different things on this issue. That is why all parties — the City, the DOJ, the APOA, and the Monitor — joined together in asking for clarification from the Court on whether the City would be in violation of the Settlement Agreement if it produces the requested records.”

The motion said that an order by U.S. District Judge Robert Brack, who is presiding over the reform effort, would help the city in its response to some records requests or if the city is sued for not producing the records.

Albuquerque police are in the midst of a yearslong reform effort brought on by a DOJ investigation, which found Albuquerque police had a pattern of excessive force.

Throughout the reform process, James Ginger, the independent monitor, and his team have met with police officials, studied police documents and written reports outlining the department’s progress. He has often submitted drafts of reports to the parties in the case before a final version is filed in court.

The Journal has requested this year’s communications between the monitor and city and police officials, as well as  drafts of official reports that Ginger has submitted to the city. The city hasn’t produced the records.

Peter St. Cyr

St. Cyr said drafts of documents aren’t exempt from public records requests and would provide the public with additional insight in how the reform effort is going.

“Until this complex conflict is resolved, the city is still obligated under state law to comply with the state Inspection of Public Records Act,” St. Cyr said.

In its official response denying the Journal access to those records, the city cited an exemption in the state public record’s law and a specific paragraph in the settlement agreement that said communications between the parties and the monitor shouldn’t be made public.

The city’s response also said it is seeking guidance about what to do with future records requests from a federal court.

Home » News » Albuquerque News » Confusion reigns over public access to APD oversight communications


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Shooting by Chaves County sheriff's deputies raises questions
ABQnews Seeker
Lapel camera footage shows deputies opening ... Lapel camera footage shows deputies opening fire on man
2
Hidden fuels still a threat in northern blazes
ABQnews Seeker
Weather shifts to critical fire Weather shifts to critical fire
3
Voters to decide two Dems for District Court posts
2022 election
Winners of Division 10, 16 will ... Winners of Division 10, 16 will likely run unopposed in November
4
Two first-generation Americans face off in CD2 Democratic primary
2022 election
Vasquez, Patel vie for chance to ... Vasquez, Patel vie for chance to run against Yvette Herrell, the state's only Republican member of Congress
5
County closes Carlito Springs, bans open fires
ABQnews Seeker
Ban will remain in place until ... Ban will remain in place until further notice
6
Guns found at ABQ, RR high schools
ABQnews Seeker
No injuries were reported as two ... No injuries were reported as two students face charges
7
APD arrests son in father's death, IDs unrelated homicide ...
ABQnews Seeker
Police looking into a possible homicide ... Police looking into a possible homicide Tuesday afternoon at a mobile home park on West Central
8
House race features past, present representatives
2022 election
Ex-legislator takes on Dem incumbent in ... Ex-legislator takes on Dem incumbent in primary
9
Feds: Ohio man plotted visit to Texas to kill ...
ABQnews Seeker
An Iraqi man who came to ... An Iraqi man who came to the United States two years ago and applied for asylum hatched a plot to assassinate former President George ...