Editorial: Albuquerque law focuses on safety of drivers, pedestrians - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: Albuquerque law focuses on safety of drivers, pedestrians

Through September of this year 51 pedestrians have died on New Mexico roads. Seventy-seven pedestrians were killed in 2016; 55 in 2015; 74 in 2014; 53 in 2013. Not a month goes by in the Land of Enchantment that someone isn’t struck by a vehicle and killed.

And while there are many factors in those many deaths, the common denominator is physics – flesh and blood is no match for steel wrapped around a combustion engine.

So why would anyone argue in favor of flesh-and-blood human beings standing inches from high-speed traffic?

They shouldn’t.

Last week the Albuquerque City Council unanimously approved a carefully crafted ordinance as a pedestrian and traffic safety measure. It requires the mayor’s signature and will go into effect five days after it’s published. And while its origins are in curbing the burgeoning number of panhandlers on metro-area medians and corners, and opponents might classify it as an anti-panhandling law or an unconstitutional attack on their free speech, it is neither.

City Councilor Trudy Jones sponsored the measure, which prohibits soliciting motorists at medians and on sidewalks and also makes it illegal for motorists to physically interact with solicitors. Under it a driver can be cited for physically engaging with pedestrians while in a travel lane. How forcefully the city’s understaffed police department will enforce it is a different question entirely.

But the fact remains that when drivers are behind the wheel, they should be focused on driving safely – not texting, not fiddling with the GPS, and not handing cash to or taking flyers from individuals representing charities, youths holding car washes, or yes, panhandlers.

The ACLU has long argued it’s unconstitutional for municipalities to prohibit people from begging for money in public spaces because it’s a form of free speech. We would argue public safety should define what are appropriate public spaces – under that rationale places including medians, highway overpasses and railroad crossings that are designed for motor vehicles, not speechifying, wouldn’t qualify.

In a 2015 case that had nothing to do with panhandling but set a precedent that applies to any local regulations that limit certain types of speech, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against the town of Gilbert, Ariz., which had passed an ordinance restricting where signs for religious services could be displayed. In Reed v. the Town of Gilbert, the court ruled that government regulations curtailing free speech have to be as narrow as possible and must fulfill a “compelling government interest.”

In the wake of that ruling, several municipal anti-panhandling ordinances were struck down on the premise they restricted panhandlers’ constitutional right to free speech. And in fact Albuquerque had a stringent panhandling ordinance that was struck down more than a decade ago for violating free speech and due process rights.

But this new law correctly focuses on the safety of everyone, not the speech of a specific segment of the population. And not facilitating human carnage on public roads sure sounds like a “compelling government interest.” Further, as Jones says, those who would flag down motorists from medians will still “have as much free speech as they want. They just have to put it someplace different. We’re not trying to limit their speech; we’re just trying to say it needs to be in a safe place.”

Because you don’t have to be a traffic engineer to understand that medians are constructed to guide traffic, not stand in for the town square. And you don’t have to be a physicist to know a charity volunteer or a high school club member or a panhandler is no match for a coupe, sedan, pickup or SUV – and all deserve to be safe.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: Albuquerque law focuses on safety of drivers, pedestrians


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Editorial: Vo-tech, welfare reform can fix our dismal worker ...
Editorials
New Mexico is in an economic ... New Mexico is in an economic rut.    It's not due to a shortage of jobs. More t ...
2
Editorial: PED’s ‘restorative’ discipline should not forget victims
Editorials
The New Mexico Public Education Department's ... The New Mexico Public Education Department's heart is in the right place with a new discipline ...
3
Editorial: Recreational pot's greener pastures still elusive for some
Editorials
"New Mexico's cannabis legalization policy must ... "New Mexico's cannabis legalization policy must ensure equity and diversity, while reinv ...
4
Editorial: IPRA brush-off by Corrections Department is inexcusable
Editorials
When a state agency blows off ... When a state agency blows off a state senator's request for public documents, something is ter ...
5
Editorial: Defendant's GPS data is a real public safety ...
Editorials
District Attorney Raul Torrez says that, ... District Attorney Raul Torrez says that, if he had been told he'd have to file a lawsuit against ...
6
Editorial: Know something? Say something to solve Muslim killings
Editorials
Someone knows something. And we need ... Someone knows something. And we need them to speak up before another person is added to the recent s ...
7
Editorial: APS right-sizing puts district in position to succeed ...
Editorials
Superintendent Scott Elder appeared downright peppy ... Superintendent Scott Elder appeared downright peppy Thursday, welcoming students back to school. The ...
8
Editorial: ABQ’s arroyo/ditch ban should save lives
Editorials
Albuquerque city councilors found common ground ... Albuquerque city councilors found common ground on legislation that could actually save lives when t ...
9
Editorial: Dedicated retirees and quest for justice
Editorials
The families of eight Metro-area women ... The families of eight Metro-area women missing for 16 years or more may not have much hope they̵ ...