Editorial: UNM bungled your right to see ex-AD's work emails - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: UNM bungled your right to see ex-AD’s work emails

It’s never a great situation when incompetence would appear to be your best defense. But that’s where we find the University of New Mexico and its handling of the Albuquerque Journal’s request to review emails from former Athletics Director Paul Krebs on his UNM email account.

The request covered emails generated while Krebs was at UNM and after he retired last spring as controversy swirled over financial mismanagement in the department and the fact public money paid for donors to go on a golf trip to Scotland.

In reviewing the IPRA request by Journal sports reporter Geoff Grammer, the university custodian noticed some emails were between Krebs – who continued to use the UNM email system after his departure – and his private lawyer. A spokeswoman says that raised concerns some of the communications were covered by attorney-client privilege.

What UNM did next was either a boneheaded move or deliberate flouting of the state Inspection of Public Records law.

Incredibly, the university turned ALL of Krebs’ emails over to his lawyer to peruse and remove the ones he felt should be protected. The UNM custodian didn’t even bother to keep a log so UNM would know which emails were pulled.

UNM marketing and communications officer Cinammon Blair says the school did this because “there is no way for anyone at UNM to sort them without risking violating attorney-client privilege.” But as Peter St. Cyr, executive director of the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government, points out, it’s not even clear there is attorney-client privilege when emails are authored by a public employee on a public email system.

The university’s actions also would seem to run afoul of UNM’s “Policy 2500: Acceptable Computer Use.” It says UNM employees “understand that their emails are public.” And the last line reads: “Therefore, all employees are urged to use the same discretion and good judgment in creating electronic documents as they would use in creating paper documents.”

Krebs, who in records that were produced told colleagues to delete emails, should have known better. And even if UNM decided it wanted to allow Krebs’ lawyer to review and remove certain documents, it should have set up a process by which it was accountable for what was removed from the public file.

St. Cyr argues giving all emails to Krebs’ attorney to review and remove those he chose to is a clear violation of IPRA.

So it would seem. UNM botched its duties under IPRA. Whether it was bungling or worse is the only question left – that, and knowing what was pulled from Krebs’ email stack.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: UNM bungled your right to see ex-AD’s work emails


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Editorial: Egolf's involvement doesn't help restore trust in the ...
Editorials
It sounded a bit suspect from ... It sounded a bit suspect from the outset.    As speaker of the New Mexico House of Re ...
2
Editorial: Questions abound in wake of fatal campus shooting
Editorials
New Mexico State University has announced ... New Mexico State University has announced it will hire an independent investigator to review last mo ...
3
Editorial: New Mexicans need to better understand paid sick ...
Editorials
When the contentious Healthy Workplaces Act ... When the contentious Healthy Workplaces Act passed the New Mexico Legislature in the waning days of ...
4
Editorial: Mastery over memory worth trying to help tackle ...
Editorials
The initial reaction by many Journal ... The initial reaction by many Journal readers to exploring equitable grading at Albuquerque Public Sc ...
5
Editorial: Gallup's Miyamura a real American hero
Editorials
The term "hero" gets bandied about ... The term "hero" gets bandied about these days. But, in such cases as Hiroshi "Hers ...
6
Editorial: Open Space Unit will have more impact patrolling ...
Editorials
Every little bit helps when it ... Every little bit helps when it comes to crimefighting.    The Albuquerque Police Depa ...
7
Editorial: At last, tech transfer is poised to live ...
Editorials
For years, New Mexico's extensive scientific ... For years, New Mexico's extensive scientific infrastructure — the state's national ...
8
Editorial: Contract impasse not good medicine
Editorials
New Mexicans have been living with ... New Mexicans have been living with a lot of health uncertainty for nearly three years. Now, due to s ...
9
Editorial: Tissue donations can benefit science, animals
Editorials
Using what is otherwise considered biomedical ... Using what is otherwise considered biomedical waste to potentially reduce live animal testing? That ...