Judge dismisses federal lawsuit over new bond rules - Albuquerque Journal

Judge dismisses federal lawsuit over new bond rules

Copyright © 2017 Albuquerque Journal

A U.S. district judge has thrown out the federal class-action lawsuit against the state Supreme Court and its judges over rules affecting pretrial detention, finding that the claims raised are without merit.

“Criminal defendants have never been guaranteed the option of monetary bail under New Mexico law in existence before or after the 2017 rules,” U.S. District Judge Robert A. Junell wrote in his 42-page ruling issued Monday.

The lawsuit was filed in July by the Bail Bond Association of New Mexico, a handful of Democratic and Republican state lawmakers and a woman who spent five days at the Metropolitan Detention Center. The plaintiffs had sought an injunction to prevent courts from using the new Supreme Court rules, arguing that those rules are unconstitutional because “the availability of bail is enshrined in the Bill of Rights.”

Among the defendants named in the lawsuit were New Mexico’s Supreme Court justices, the chief judges of the 2nd Judicial District Court and Metropolitan Court and the Bernalillo County Commission.

The Supreme Court issued the rules after voters in November 2016 supported a constitutional amendment that said people could be held in jail without bail until their trial if they are found to be a danger to the community. It also said inmates who are not a risk could be released from custody even if they couldn’t afford a monetary bond. The rules went into effect in July.

The bond association said the rules have decimated its profession, as most defendants are being released from custody as soon as they appear before a judge without having to post a bond.

Barry Massey, a spokesman for the Administrative Office of the Courts, said he was aware of the federal court ruling but could not comment late Monday. In a court filing in August, the Supreme Court and other defendants called the lawsuit a desperate move by the bail bonding industry to regain control over pretrial release practices.

The president of the New Mexico Bail Bonds Association expressed dismay at Monday’s ruling.

“I’m disappointed, of course,” said Gerald Madrid. “It didn’t appear we were close on any of our issues.”

Madrid said he’d be meeting with Blair Dunn, the attorney for the bail bonds association, today to discuss options. “It’s just crushing. … It’s overwhelming for the (bond) industry,” he said. “I don’t see anything that’s positive that’s come of these changes to court rules.”

In his ruling, Judge Junell granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the lawsuit and denied plaintiffs’ motion to amend their complaint, determining that all the federal claims they wanted to add would be futile. He also found that the Bail Bond Association of New Mexico and individual state lawmakers lack standing to bring the suit, although he did find that Darlene Collins – the plaintiff in the lawsuit who spent about five days in jail in July – did have standing to file the lawsuit.

Junell then went through an exhaustive analysis of the claims raised in the lawsuit and why they cannot move forward.

“In the present case, the fact that Collins was released on her own recognizance with minimal conditions does not shock the Court’s conscience, nor does the absence of a monetary bail option in lieu of, or in addition to, any potential restrictions that are aimed at deterring dangerousness,” Junell wrote. “Moreover, Collins failed to challenge any nonmonetary conditions of release when she had the opportunity to do so at her pretrial detention hearing. Either way, Plaintiffs present no grounds for finding that a criminal defendant’s option to obtain monetary bail is a fundamental right or implicit in the concept of ordered liberty.”

 


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
TOP OF MIND: Should faith leaders be allowed to ...
ABQnews Seeker
This week's question: Should faith leaders ... This week's question: Should faith leaders be allowed to endorse candidates from the pulpit and retain their institutions' tax-exempt status? Want to participate in ...
2
Federal medical team leader touts positive experience in New ...
ABQnews Seeker
Disaster assistance group was deployed to ... Disaster assistance group was deployed to San Juan County
3
Preserving the beauty of the past for the future
ABQnews Seeker
Conservation work starts at historic Córdova ... Conservation work starts at historic Córdova church
4
Roundhouse bracing for debate on redistricting
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico established a citizen committee ... New Mexico established a citizen committee to hold hearings and develop recommendations
5
SF Archdiocese set to hold web auction for 427 ...
ABQnews Seeker
First sale in September generated winning ... First sale in September generated winning bids of almost $1.4M
6
Home of pioneer African American educator gains historic status
ABQnews Seeker
Las Cruces teacher, the current homeowner, ... Las Cruces teacher, the current homeowner, made it her mission to honor Clara Belle Williams
7
Catalytic converter thefts up across New Mexico
ABQnews Seeker
While thieves fetch as little as ... While thieves fetch as little as $50, replacements costs owners $2,000 to $3,000
8
Moscow native helped ABQ look beyond borders
ABQnews Seeker
AIA founder exposed city to 'international ... AIA founder exposed city to 'international spark and sizzle'
9
Prep cross country: Kuykendall's time at elite meet thought ...
ABQnews Seeker
  Hope Christian junior Rendon Kuykendall ...   Hope Christian junior Rendon Kuykendall on Saturday placed 14th in the gold division of the Garmin RunningLane Cross Country Championships in Huntsville, Alabama. ...