DOE takes bungling to a new level at LANL - Albuquerque Journal

DOE takes bungling to a new level at LANL

The U.S. Department of Energy is uncertain whether plutonium components for renovation of the nation’s nuclear weapons stockpile should be manufactured at the Los Alamos National Laboratory or moved to another DOE site.

The uncertainty stems primarily from a long series of major project failures at LANL.

Several decades ago, LANL successfully built a modern plutonium facility at TA-55. A highly competent laboratory project team, working closely with DOE headquarters and field office personnel, completed the project ahead of schedule and under budget

Now, the laboratory appears to be incapable of managing significant projects.

What happened? Several things happened – all of them bad.

Internally, the lab continued to employ outstanding scientists, but the same cannot be said for management in some of the support divisions.

Managers of support divisions were selected for a variety of reasons, not necessarily including merit. The process of selecting managers included such nefarious criteria as church affiliation. Occasional meddling by DOE field office managers also influenced poor selections.

It will take time and a commitment for the lab to eradicate this malignant legacy.

Externally, disastrous DOE policy and organizational changes occurred. Less than a decade after the highly successful TA-55 project, an inscrutable reorganization of the DOE was executed.

Perhaps well-intentioned, but seriously misguided, these changes were imposed by Congress in collusion with senior DOE managers.

The reorganization involved creation of an agency within the DOE bureaucracy, the National Nuclear Security Administration, along with creation of a totalitarian Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board supported by hundreds of martinets running amok in DOE facilities.

Additionally, an irrational regulatory process lacking risk perspective was established whereby contractors who are hired, directed and paid by the DOE are subjected to legalistic rule-making as if they were in the private commercial sector.

This convoluted DOE bureaucracy has taken the art of bungling to a new level. The result has been dozens of project failures and hundreds of billions of wasted tax dollars throughout the DOE, and most notably at Los Alamos.

The DOE bureaucratic blockade can never be circumvented. Congress must rescind the legislation that unduly encumbers the activities of LANL and the rest of the nuclear weapons complex.

The onerous regulatory system and the totalitarian Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board should both be abolished.

These improvident schemes should be replaced with an intelligent, efficient and effective risk management process as recommended decades ago by the Advisory Committee on Nuclear Facility Safety.

Risk management would increase the chances of success for nuclear projects while providing improved safety and security with lower cost to the taxpayers.

A time-honored project management aphorism contends that once a project is fouled up, anything done to fix it will only make it worse. This has been the case throughout the history of the DOE.

Congress must admit their mistakes and undo the damage that produced this mess; otherwise, all hope is lost.

Members of the U.S. Senate’s Armed Forces Committee have raised a concern about “long-term delays” in renovation of the nation’s nuclear weapons stockpile.

This concern is justified. In the DOE, a light year is defined as the time it takes the DOE to change a light bulb.

Schinkle lives in Los Lunas.


Home » Journal North » Journal North Opinion » DOE takes bungling to a new level at LANL

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Cirque Italia brings its maritime-themed show to Albuquerque
ABQnews Seeker
Cirque Italia's latest adventure is called ... Cirque Italia's latest adventure is called "Water Circus" and will start a two week stand in Albuquerque beginning Thursday, March 30, at Cottonwood Mall.
UNM is talking contract extension, but is Pitino receptive?
The coaching carousel is spinning in ... The coaching carousel is spinning in college basketball as fast as the transfer portal is filling up ...
Editorial: N.M. must take care when terminating DD Waiver ...
From the Editorial Board: History shows ... From the Editorial Board: History shows New Mexico must be careful cutting off providers of services to those with developmental and intellectual disabilities.
Prep basketball: Metro stars are abundant on all-state teams ...
Boys' Basketball
a boys basketball season dominated by ... a boys basketball season dominated by schools in the metro area would also see that dominance reflected in the All-State teams announced earlier this ...
Sports Speak Up! More consternation caused by Lobo women's ...
Featured Sports
Lobo fan in MT   MEDIOCRE ... Lobo fan in MT   MEDIOCRE MIKE will never get the Lady Lobos to the Promised Land. Top players bailing out this year, similar ...
Lobo K.J. Jenkins, team's best outside shooter, goes into ...
The best outside shooter on a ... The best outside shooter on a team desperate to improve its outside shooting for the coming season has announced he's leaving the Lobos. K.J. ...
Extra! Extra! 'Newsies' coming to UNM's Rodey Theatre
ABQnews Seeker
"Newsies" opens on Friday, March 24. ... "Newsies" opens on Friday, March 24. It will run through April 2, at Rodey Theatre on the University of New Mexico campus.
Comedian Paula Poundstone coming to Lensic stage
ABQnews Seeker
Paula Poundstone is coming to Santa ... Paula Poundstone is coming to Santa Fe on Friday, March 24, at the Lensic Performing Arts Center.
Livin' 'Mi Vida Loca': 7 activities for this weekend
ABQnews Seeker
Before Ricky Martin was "Livin' la ... Before Ricky Martin was "Livin' la Vida Loca" in the '90s, there was Pam Tillis living "Mi Vida Loca." The "Cleopatra, Queen of Denial" ...