Trump does not understand immigration system - Albuquerque Journal

Trump does not understand immigration system

SAN DIEGO – I’m usually a gracious host. But did I ever tell you about the time that I threw someone out of my house?

This was about 15 years ago, when I was living in North Texas and working for The Dallas Morning News. As a Mexican-American whose grandfather came from what President Trump would call a “shithole” country, it might surprise you to hear that the person who got escorted out the door was a well-educated and highly skilled Mexican elitist.

Or maybe it won’t surprise you, if you know anything about how the U.S. immigration system works.

Trump doesn’t. Based on comments attributed to him about his preferred type of immigrants, there are at least three things the president doesn’t understand about America and its magical place in the world:

• What Trump considers “shithole countries” can produce some of the most loyal and productive immigrants and refugees, in much the same way that those who flee totalitarian regimes treasure freedom or those who escape countries that sponsor terrorism are committed to ending it. We learned this lesson during the Cold War with Eastern Europeans and Cubans. Many newcomers implicitly reject their home country when they swap it for this one.

• The whole purpose of America is not to skim the cream of the immigrant pool but to take in desperate people from countries that are poor, corrupt and dysfunctional. Not just out of compassion, but also in our own self-interest. Ours is the ultimate land of second chances, where people come when their own nations neglect, abuse, oppress and underserve them. And they often succeed here because they know what else is out there.

• Those who have a good thing going in their home countries – like, say, people from Norway – are probably not interested in putting in the effort to migrate to a country where nothing is guaranteed and success usually comes at a cost of blood, sweat and tears. That’s fine. We have enough entitled and arrogant elitists who are homegrown, so we don’t have to import more from foreign countries.

It’s disgraceful that Trump is so brazen about wanting to take in fewer immigrants from places like Haiti or El Salvador. It’s disappointing that he wants to exclude the dark-skinned and the downtrodden to make room for the light-skinned and prosperous. It’s dumb that Trump wants to end what Republicans call “chain migration” and what the rest of us know as “family reunification.” And it’s disturbing that he likes the idea of a merit system that favors educated and skilled immigrants – the kind of system that would have rejected the Irish, Italian and Jewish immigrants of the 20th century.

Test scores and degrees are overrated. Give me the hungry, the hustling and the hard-working. Besides, immigration should be driven by labor needs; if we require nurses, we shouldn’t bring in nuclear physicists just because we can.

Which raises the question: How can Trump be expected to lead America if he doesn’t understand America?

This takes me back to that run-in with the Mexican elitist, who had been brought to my home by a friend. He came from a wealthy family in Mexico City, and he was on a student visa. After getting an education, he planned to return to Mexico to run the family business – unless, he said, he got a better offer from a company in the United States. He had an undergraduate degree and spoke perfect English. I bet his test scores were good.

He reminded me of those high-class Mexicans who, a hundred years earlier, wouldn’t have given my poor and dark-skinned grandfather with his sixth-grade education the time of day.

And there this little jerk was, sitting at my dinner table, bad-mouthing the United States. He was saying how we brought misery upon ourselves by meddling in the affairs of other countries. What I remember most of all was that he acted like he was doing my country a favor by coming here, going to our universities, even taking a job.

Apparently the concept of looking down on fellow human beings isn’t exclusive to U.S. presidents.

I argued with my dinner guest for a while, as others in the room became more uncomfortable. Then finally, fed up, I told him to leave.

Behold the kind of people that Trump insists we need more of – high-achievers incapable of humility, devoid of gratitude, flattered that they’re being recruited, and so well versed in fouling up their home countries with their sense of entitlement that now they’d like to do the same to this one.

E-mail: Copyright, The Washington Post Writers Group. His daily podcast, “Navarrette Nation,” is available through every podcast app.


Home » Opinion » Columnists » Trump does not understand immigration system

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

Personal to me, Jose Armas' death felt across NM
One of the blessings about returning ... One of the blessings about returning to New Mexico was that it put me back in touch with Jose Armas. ...
Thieves take so much more than your cash
Being victimized can cause trauma, and ... Being victimized can cause trauma, and has nothing to do with your 'intelligence or common sense'
Tips for keeping you and your energy bills cool ...
It is hot outside. According to ... It is hot outside. According to PNM, demand for electricity is highest during the summer cooling sea ...
A new community hub for the South Valley
Social Enterprise Center brings new approach ... Social Enterprise Center brings new approach to economic development
Navajo nurses took different paths to making big differences ...
Looking back on long nursing careers, ... Looking back on long nursing careers, Erma Marbut and Lavenia Diswood are most proud of the ways the ...
Anniversaries of grief bring lessons, opportunities to help
ABQnews Seeker
You will not 'get over' the ... You will not 'get over' the loss of a loved one; you'll learn to live with it
Journal reader engagement focusing on underrepresented communities
I moved to Albuquerque from Colorado ... I moved to Albuquerque from Colorado last November, marking the third time in my 53 years that IR ...
NM voters should get say on healthy environment
What is the Green Amendment and ... What is the Green Amendment and what would it do? Democrats in the New Mexico House and Senate have ...
Newspaper memo from the past rings just as true ...
Editorial page writer Sharon Hendrix rarely ... Editorial page writer Sharon Hendrix rarely throws anything out. So before retiring last month after ...