Law firms made $1.1 million defending APS in Moya case - Albuquerque Journal

Law firms made $1.1 million defending APS in Moya case

Albuquerque Public Schools’ legal fees to battle former chief financial officer Don Moya’s whistleblower lawsuit add up to $1.1 million paid out over more than two years.

Don Moya

The case, which was filed in August 2015 in Santa Fe’s 1st Judicial District Court, was settled last month with APS paying Moya $800,000.

Two firms handled APS’ defense: German & Associates, which billed $924,800, and Robles Rael & Anaya, which billed $180,991.

APS’ insurance caps its out-of-pocket costs at $350,000.

Under the terms of the settlement, Moya and APS face a $20,000 fine if they disparage one another.

Superintendent Raquel Reedy also provided Moya with a positive letter of reference that highlights various awards and his success boosting the district’s bond rating and cash reserves.

While Moya’s attorney, Kate Ferlic, cannot provide any new comments on the case, she previously told the Journal she thought APS was “cutting off its nose to spite its face.”

Ferlic said APS had many opportunities to settle but opted to “try to defend this case more vigorously than any case of this nature that I’ve seen.”

She also claimed that the district had buried her in nearly 100,000 pages of “meaningless documents.”

APS has declined to comment on the lawsuit.

The saga began Aug. 7, 2015, when then-Superintendent Luis Valentino, recently hired from San Francisco’s school district, tried to text New Mexico Education Secretary Hanna Skandera about “going after” Moya for running “roughshot.”

He accidentally sent the text to Moya himself. Later that day, Valentino placed Moya on paid administrative leave.

The two were reportedly friendly when Valentino began the job in May 2015, but they tangled over proposed audits that Moya believed were wasteful and unnecessary. Then-Deputy Superintendent Jason Martinez, a curriculum expert Valentino hired from Colorado, also supported the audits.

Less than two weeks after Moya was placed on paid leave, Martinez resigned amid allegations that he had skipped a mandatory criminal background check to conceal child sex assault charges against him filed in Denver. He was later found not guilty.

Valentino stepped down at the end of August 2015 with an $80,000 buyout and a positive reference letter from the APS Board of Education.

Moya now works as a finance director for Santa Fe County.

Ferlic previously told the Journal she hopes Moya’s lawsuit will “change practices at APS and make them more fiscally responsible than what the facts of the case revealed here.”

Home » News » Albuquerque News » Law firms made $1.1 million defending APS in Moya case


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Auto dealership is No. 5 mid-size company in Top ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Rob Sneed, managing partner ... Q&A with Rob Sneed, managing partner and general manager of Power Ford
2
Eye care firm is No. 5 large company in ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Eye Associates of New ... Q&A with Eye Associates of New Mexico CEO Tony Lenhart and Chief Human Resources Officer Cris Todd
3
School is No. 4 small employer in Top Workplaces ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Rebecca Maestas-Sanchez, principal for ... Q&A with Rebecca Maestas-Sanchez, principal for St. Mary's Catholic School
4
Engineering firm is No. 4 mid-size company in Top ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Bohannan Huston Inc. president ... Q&A with Bohannan Huston Inc. president and CEO Bruce Stidworthy and Nancy Simutis, vice president of human resources
5
Telecommunications firm is No. 4 large company in Top ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Karen Viola, customer experience ... Q&A with Karen Viola, customer experience center senior director for T-Mobile US
6
Construction firm is No. 3 small company in Top ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Paul Farless, president and ... Q&A with Paul Farless, president and CEO of SDV Construction Inc.
7
Oil and gas firm is No. 3 mid-size company ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Ezra Yacob, CEO of ... Q&A with Ezra Yacob, CEO of EOG Resources ...
8
Electrical company is No. 3 large company in Top ...
ABQnews Seeker
B&D Industries is the No. 3 ... B&D Industries is the No. 3 large company in Top Workplaces for 2022.
9
School is No. 2 small employer in Top Workplaces ...
ABQnews Seeker
Q&A with Aldis Philipbar, development director ... Q&A with Aldis Philipbar, development director at Amy Biehl High School.