Is noncitizen voting next for 'sanctuary cities'? - Albuquerque Journal

Is noncitizen voting next for ‘sanctuary cities’?

As California goes, so goes the country?

Santa Fe progressives take notice. The Department of Justice has indicated that the current lawsuit filed against California is just the first of other suits that may be filed against states and cities that obstruct immigration enforcement. That could also involve sanctuary cities in New Mexico.

The suit has brought several interesting comments from progressive politicians in California. Among them is a comment from junior U.S. Senator Kamala Harris, who succeeded Barbara Boxer. In a recent MSNBC interview, she said, “California’s going to fight because the state represents the future.”

The nationwide RESIST movement is opposing U.S. immigration law, which is clearly defined in our Constitution as belonging to federal jurisdiction. The sanctuary declarations passed by cities and states are an attempt to supersede or nullify federal law, and are rightly seen as unconstitutional.

Santa Fe officials have adamantly reinforced its sanctuary city policy, which may cause the city fathers some heartburn, if not money. Albuquerque and the state have wisely ended their sanctuary position.

The progressives’ sanctuary agenda is not over human or immigrant rights; it is an incremental attempt to eventually register noncitizen voters. And California is the model state where globalists and progressives are attempting to nullify federal voting requirements by first claiming immigration law is a state’s rights issue.

Sure to follow will be an effort to secure voting rights for non-U.S. citizens by claiming “discrimination” under the federal Voting Rights Act of 1965 and granting all state residents the right to vote in elections, without discrimination.

Progressives often advance the thought, “If you live here and pay taxes here, you should be able to vote here.” While that may sound reasonable to some, it is not even close to the real-world experience. If you are a noncitizen of Mexico or Canada, try voting there. Or try slipping into Mexico and find out what happens to you. How about applying for welfare in other countries or enrolling in a Mexican high school or university as an illegal immigrant. You can’t.

Merit-based immigration with quotas is a Trump agenda opposed by progressives because it cuts the numbers of possible future voters.

If California is allowed to set the precedent of nullifying federal immigration law, it becomes a short hop to nullifying federal voting law. Should California’s progressives decide residency, not citizenship, is the only qualifier to being a registered voter, then a legitimate vote count of American citizens in federal elections will become impossible to tally. If other progressive-led states follow California, then election outcomes could become a noncitizen takeover of this country.

In 2015, Gov. Jerry Brown signed into law California’s motor voter act, which requires no federal documentation, like Social Security numbers, for residents to obtain a driver’s license and become registered voters. The True the Vote organization, which monitors voter fraud, said this law only worsens voter fraud in California and could give noncitizens an opportunity to vote fraudulently in federal elections.

These incremental moves by progressives in California are intended to make way for the issuance of voter registrations to immigrant residents for local elections; but there will be no real way to determine if the citizenship requirement is met should they vote in federal elections.

In 2017, New Mexico did pass a new motor voter law requiring verification of social security and citizenship status, placing it in the hands of the Secretary of State, who then notifies the county clerks of a person’s eligibility to receive voter registration.

Progressive values like sanctuary cities may sound appealing, but before we ask what is fair to illegal immigrants, we must ask what is fair to American families, students, taxpayers, jobseekers and, yes, American voters.

Tom Wright is a political commentator and columnist in Santa Fe


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


Fishing Line for Jan. 20, 2022
Fishing Line
World Cleanup Day initiative aims to remove debris collecting ...
Bright Spot
Waterways are always important.In New Mexico ... Waterways are always important.In New Mexico – which is touched by drought eve ...
Del Norte hoops star Douma-Sanchez returns after ACL tear
Boys' Basketball
BERNALILLO – Basketball coaches ... BERNALILLO – Basketball coaches are fond of dividing a season into thirds.The ...
NM can reach higher with free college for all
From the newspaper
Over the past few years, our ... Over the past few years, our state has expanded opportunities for New Mexicans to pursue career trai ...
Lobbyist answers to landowners, not county residents
From the newspaper
Vanessa Alarid's accusations that I am ... Vanessa Alarid's accusations that I am "undemocratic" and unresponsive to my distr ...
San Felipe Pueblo member to lead museum
From the newspaper
San Felipe Pueblo's Cynthia Chavez Lamar ... San Felipe Pueblo's Cynthia Chavez Lamar has been hired to lead the Smithsonian's Nati ...
Tutu teachings offer us moral compass, conscience
From the newspaper
He always believed in a humanizing ... He always believed in a humanizing worldview
School of Public Health can transform NM
From the newspaper
UNM and NMSU can create government ... UNM and NMSU can create government resource center meant to prevent health threats
Editorial: Dow backed ethics commission - until it investigated ...
Shortly after taking office in 2017, ... Shortly after taking office in 2017, state Rep. Rebecca Dow joined other House members in a 66-0 vot ...