Commentary: Student-athletes aren't only ones to feel a loss - Albuquerque Journal

Commentary: Student-athletes aren’t only ones to feel a loss

University of New Mexico Volleyball and Beach Volleyball player, Lauren Tweety, presented arguments to save women’s beach volleyball during the Regents meeting in the Student Union Thursday. (Greg Sorber/Albuquerque Journal)

Maybe you’re like me, a disinterested (as journalists must be) observer of University of New Mexico athletics who never once pulled for them to win or lose any athletic contest.

But disinterested doesn’t mean uninterested. I have cared about the vitality of their programs as a “quality of life” measure – just as I would root for a high school trying to field a football team as a suitable extracurricular activity. Just as I would root for the Isotopes to thrive in Albuquerque so that Triple-A baseball doesn’t skip town again.

Success for the community’s sake, the rising tide lifting all boats, all of that.

I was hoping against hope that UNM athletics would somehow magically avoid Terrible Thursday.

It hurts that it did not.

The merits of one sport vs. another forever will be debated. UNM athletic director Eddie Nuñez and President Garnett Stokes, rookies in their jobs no more as of today, did what they must do, to be clear, in requesting the elimination of four – men’s soccer, men’s and women’s skiing, and beach volleyball.

The athletic budget has gone red in nine of the last 11 years. The argument that red ink in the low seven figures doesn’t matter in a mammoth nine-figure overall budget is silly. Higher Education Secretary Barbara Damron otherwise wouldn’t have brought us to the day of reckoning and the mandatory repayment plan.

Anyone who thinks deficit spending is OK mustn’t have any skin in the game. But with public money, we all do.

Said Regent Suzanne Quillen on Thursday, before the board’s decision: “I have to think back to my first private meeting with President Stokes before she had really even started and I reminded her of all the very difficult issues we have going on at this university and how, sometimes, we just sort of move it down the road, hoping for a magic bullet. … I was sort of challenging her. ‘Do you think you’re up to these difficult decisions?’ And she turned it around and said, ‘I have to ask you. Are you all up to supporting my difficult decisions?'”

If only the regents hadn’t waited for years for the “magic bullet.” Or who knows what would have happened if Damron hadn’t intervened?

Anyway, those watching either in person or on the Journal’s live stream of the four-hour Board or Regents meeting Thursday saw legions of speakers in support of the affected programs and their students, who so positively impact UNM and this community.

Men’s soccer coach Jeremy Fishbein made that point over his 15 minutes, five times longer than given most speakers by rule. In that span, he was the consummate Fishbein – alternately eloquent, insightful and eventually abrasive, forgetting that vinegar doesn’t catch flies. Time’s up, he was told at the point he started calling out administrators and regents individually.

As to the narrative retold, we all get it. Athletics at this level attracts the achievers. They’re the best and the brightest to begin with, and when they get academic support that the average student doesn’t, they flourish.

Many of those young men and women, for these reasons, will have opportunities and land softly elsewhere, sooner or later.

That’s where we in Albuquerque lose out. I feel more sorry for us than for them.

Unfortunately, I didn’t hear, from any of these speakers, a financial solution to what brought them together on this fateful morning. Or a Title IX solution. Or any pragmatic solution.

So when these programs officially disband after July 1, 2019, will we miss men’s and women’s skiing? From a spectator standpoint, it’s not like you can hold a meet in South Campus before the student body.

Will we miss beach volleyball, a program only four years old, holding one home tournament a year?

Men’s soccer is different. It has been part of the fabric of this town for a long time, with high-quality play against high quality teams on invigorating fall nights for those who preferred fútbol to football, often by kids we had watched grow up – and who would continue to do so playing for an outstanding leader in Fishbein.

Absolutely we will miss that.

Even worse, there is this: The plan approved Thursday only achieves $1.15 million in savings, when $1.9 million is necessary. The plan to make up the rest of the difference includes the uncertain aspect of raising more revenue.

It’s never good when you’re asking the universe to meet you nearly halfway.

Meanwhile, by UNM’s own projections, the female proportion of the undergraduate student body will only grow each year, to 58 percent in 2021-22. Title IX problems were addressed Thursday, but not solved.

There is this gnawing feeling that all of this is by no means over.

Home » Sports » College » UNM Lobos » Commentary: Student-athletes aren’t only ones to feel a loss

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

Mississippi wins first CWS title by sweeping Oklahoma
The last team to get into ... The last team to get into the NCAA baseball tournament was the last team standing. Mississippi scored twice on wild pitches in a three-run ...
A numbers game: How UNM has shifted toward Title ...
ABQnews Seeker
As the nation celebrated 50 years ... As the nation celebrated 50 years of Title IX, the University of New Mexico is still trying to add opportunities for female athletes.
Lobo women's hoops staff undergoes several changes
Keith Freeman showed up in Albuquerque ... Keith Freeman showed up in Albuquerque this week with much to learn and eager to get started. He spent Wednesday afternoon prepping for his ...
Virgen: Two NM stars and what might have been ...
Featured Sports
About a year ago, Aidan Krafft ... About a year ago, Aidan Krafft of Cibola High and Quinn Yost of Piedra Vista might have had Cherry a ...
UNM has its three opponents for November's Lobo Classic
UNM's first in-season home tournament in ... UNM's first in-season home tournament in 15 years to be held Nov. 25-27 at the Pit
UNM creates 'Howl for Her' campaign for women athletic ...
ABQnews Seeker
University of New Mexico Athletics said ... University of New Mexico Athletics said Thursday it has launched a “Howl for Her” campaign that will raise funds specifically for Lobo women’s athletics. ...
Estes was linchpin in UNM's reach for sports equality
Title IX, passed into law on ... Title IX, passed into law on June 23, 1972, changed the women’s athletics landscape – and Linda Estes’ job – dramatically
Lobo golfer Choi transferring to Pepperdine
Sam Choi, who was named a ... Sam Choi, who was named a PING honorable mention All-American the past two seasons for the University of New Mexico, is transferring to play ...
First-round TBT game to pit former Lobos vs. former ...
ABQnews Seeker
A UNM Lobo alumni team and ... A UNM Lobo alumni team and an NMSU alumni team square off, highlighting the first night of the The Basketball Tournament's New Mexico Regional ...