Hillary Clinton comes out in support of incivility - Albuquerque Journal

Hillary Clinton comes out in support of incivility

It’s doubtful that a former American presidential candidate has ever formally endorsed incivility before, but Hillary Clinton is ever full of surprises.

In an interview on CNN, the erstwhile advocate of “if they go low, we go high” switched around to unapologetically call for going low.

“You cannot be civil with a political party,” she explained, “that wants to destroy what you stand for, what you care about.” She added that if Democrats retake a house of Congress, well, then, “that’s when civility can start again.”

Clinton’s statement is yet more confirmation of the radical mood of the current Democratic Party, not just in blessing tactics that once would have been anathema to the mainstream, but questioning the legitimacy of core elements of our system. The party’s base is just a few steps from beginning to give up on our common national life.

Civility is a rather fundamental thing to throw under the bus. It is the basis of our political life, assuring that disagreements are settled within certain bounds and don’t escalate into blood feuds. This doesn’t mean that there can’t be intense arguments, harsh condemnations, passionate controversies and partisan donnybrooks. These are all endemic to a free society and very healthy things. It does mean that there are certain widely accepted guardrails.

Yet this is now thought to be a sucker’s game from the attorney-provocateur Michael Avenatti to the opinion outlets of the center-left. Vox ran a piece that argued, “Civility is not an end on its own if the practices and beliefs it upholds are unjust.”

In the Brett Kavanaugh debate, the normal pressure points of the democratic process – rallies and demonstrations, phone calls to congressional offices, online, print and TV advocacy – were deemed insufficient; senators had to be berated in the hallways, chased out of restaurants and harassed at their homes.

By the way, none of the people treated this way were Donald Trump, who does so much to create raw feelings with his routinely crude and inflammatory rhetoric. The targets were elected officeholders who serve in what is still the most distinguished legislative body in the nation, and routinely call each other “friend” and “colleague.”

Asked on CNN if the actions against her fellow senators went too far, Mazie Hirono stood by the harassment: “I think it just means that there are a lot of people who are very, very much motivated about what’s going on.” There has even been resistance on the left and in the media to calling these groups of activists by their proper name, “mobs,” because it is considered too pejorative.

But when you angrily confront someone, especially as part of a group, it carries an inescapable whiff of physical intimidation. When you shout Ted and Heidi Cruz out of a Washington restaurant, you aren’t trying to convince them of anything, you are merely abusing them. When you yell at Senate hearings and floor votes, you aren’t influencing the process, but disrupting it.

Our system of government is increasingly held in low regard on the left. The 2016 election was somehow stolen, and the mechanism that gave Trump his victory, the Electoral College, is illegitimate. The Senate, which confirmed Kavanaugh and gives small, red states the same representation as large, blue states, is also illegitimate. Finally, the Supreme Court, now home to two Trump-appointed justices, is illegitimate as well. That’s a lot of illegitimacy, all stemming from one lost presidential election. Imagine if Democrats lose another? The fact is that if you believe an institution is legitimate only if you control it or it works in your favor, you never truly believed in its legitimacy to begin with.

Perhaps the Democratic fever will pass if the party gains some power again, as Clinton suggested in her remarks. But it’s notable enough that one of our major parties is showing signs of contemplating a divorce from our system as it currently exists.


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango


taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Feds need to finally get it together on marijuana ...
Columnists
Quick. Do you know if marijuana ... Quick. Do you know if marijuana is legal in your state? Is it approved for medical, or even recreati ...
2
Soft-peddling root cause of murder won't stop it
Columnists
Sad to say, we keep killing ... Sad to say, we keep killing each other. New FBI statistics show that, even though we practiced wides ...
3
The nation's fixation on the search for Gabby Petito
Columnists
There are hundreds of thousands of ... There are hundreds of thousands of people reported missing in the United States each year. Last year ...
4
UNM, city join to spur NM entrepreneurship
ABQnews Seeker
The University of New Mexico and ... The University of New Mexico and the City of Albuquerque are partnering on a new "Right to Start" in ...
5
Should we honor a killer's every last request - ...
Columnists
A medium rare rib eye steak, ... A medium rare rib eye steak, a baked potato with butter and sour cream, an iceberg lettuce salad, ga ...
6
CRIME AND JUSTICE: Do we need more - or ...
Columnists
Media has too many knee-jerk reactions ... Media has too many knee-jerk reactions to possible 'hate crimes'
7
Once again, history matters and so does political reality
Columnists
Here we go again! In the ... Here we go again! In the aftermath of the mismanaged U.S. military pullout in Afghanistan, calls to ...
8
NM wind project of historic size nearly complete
Business
Renewable power developer Pattern Energy is ... Renewable power developer Pattern Energy is nearing completion of a mammoth wind project in east cen ...
9
Clock is ticking on ways to fix the US ...
Columnists
This column is not about relitigating ... This column is not about relitigating the 2020 election. Joseph Biden is the duly certified U.S. pre ...