EPA says NM methane down, but some question data - Albuquerque Journal

EPA says NM methane down, but some question data

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency says methane emissions from oil and gas operations in New Mexico’s Permian and San Juan basins dropped by 6 percent between 2016 and 2017, although environmentalists dispute the accuracy of EPA data collection.

Total emissions fell by nearly 830,000 metric tons, according to the EPA’s greenhouse gas reporting program. That lowered overall releases in both basins from a combined 13.78 metric tons in 2016 to 12.95 metric tons last year.

The Permian in southeastern New Mexico accounted for the lion’s share. Emissions there fell by 728,000 metric tons, compared with a 100,000-metric-ton decline in the San Juan Basin in northwestern New Mexico.

Industry representatives say that demonstrates producer success in reducing methane venting and leaking.

“The facts themselves demonstrate that methane emissions are plummeting even as production in New Mexico is climbing,” said New Mexico Oil and Gas Association Executive Director Ryan Flynn. “Environmental groups say heavy-handed government regulations are needed to control methane emissions, but that story is betrayed by the facts.”

Environmentalists, though, question the EPA’s data collection process. The Western Environmental Law Center, for example, says statistics compiled by the state Oil Conservation Division from monthly reports it receives from local operators shows methane emissions from venting and flaring increased by 18 percent from January-July of 2018 compared with the same period last year.

The state data came from an inspection of public records request filed this summer with the OCD, said Law Center senior policy adviser Thomas Singer.

Flynn said the EPA’s latest statistics are more accurate than in the past, when that agency focused only on natural gas extraction. In contrast, the EPA’s new data include releases from gathering and processing operations as well, providing comparable statistics over two consecutive years.

“It’s the most comprehensive data set now available,” Flynn said. “These numbers aren’t generated by industry, but by the U.S. government.”

Still, the EPA may be missing a lot of information from small operations that aren’t included in its data collection, said Jon Goldstein, regulatory and legislative affairs director for the Environmental Defense Fund.

“The EPA captures data from the biggest emitters, but it’s missing smaller ones that cumulatively add up,” Goldstein said. “EPA data is also based on modeling estimates of things like leaks that are outdated and don’t reflect what’s happening in the real world.”

A peer-reviewed report published in the Journal Science last June said real emissions may be 60 percent higher than EPA estimates.

“The data reported to EPA does show a drop,” said David McCabe, senior scientist with the Clean Air Task Force in Washington, D.C. “But we know these studies consistently underestimate methane emissions from oil and gas by large factors, so it’s not clear that the small drop in reported methane is meaningful.”

Meanwhile, a simultaneous increase in flaring, or burning, of methane in the Permian is also raising carbon dioxide emissions, offsetting the drop in methane releases. Flaring in the Permian led to a 680,000-ton increase in CO2 emissions last year, according to the Clean Air Task Force.

Home » Business » Energy » EPA says NM methane down, but some question data


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
New Mexico oil group appeals ozone pollution rules
ABQnews Seeker
Opponents note some rules will 'inflict ... Opponents note some rules will 'inflict economic hardship' on residents
2
PNM earnings plummet in second-quarter 2022
ABQnews Seeker
Losses on investments, climbing interest rates, ... Losses on investments, climbing interest rates, hurt company
3
Geothermal plant wins appeal but pauses Nevada construction
Energy
RENO, Nev.-- -- The developer of ... RENO, Nev.-- -- The developer of a geothermal power plant facing legal challenges in Nevada agreed Monday to suspend construction just hours after a ...
4
Unprecedented profit for major oil drillers as prices soared
Energy
Oil companies swam in record profits ... Oil companies swam in record profits over the last few months at a time when Americans struggled to pay for gasoline, food and other ...
5
Climate disinformation leaves lasting mark as world heats
Energy
In 1998, as nations around the ... In 1998, as nations around the world agreed to cut carbon emissions through the Kyoto Protocol, America's fossil fuel companies plotted their response, including ...
6
Russia cuts gas through Nord Stream 1 to 20% ...
Energy
Russia's Gazprom on Wednesday halved the ... Russia's Gazprom on Wednesday halved the amount of natural gas flowing through a major pipeline from Russia to Europe to 20% of capacity. It's ...
7
EU agrees to cut natural gas use amid Russian ...
Energy
European Union governments agreed Tuesday to ... European Union governments agreed Tuesday to reduce consumption of natural gas this winter to protect themselves against any further supply cuts by Russia amid ...
8
Regulators berate PNM again on rate credit
ABQnews Seeker
Commissioners deny utility appeal, but Supreme ... Commissioners deny utility appeal, but Supreme Court decision still pending
9
Gazprom says it's cutting gas Nord Stream to 20% ...
Energy
Russia's Gazprom said Monday that it ... Russia's Gazprom said Monday that it would further reduce natural gas flows through a major pipeline to Europe to 20% of capacity, citing repairs ...