UNM sports cuts based on seriously flawed analysis - Albuquerque Journal

UNM sports cuts based on seriously flawed analysis

One would hope that before UNM decided to reduce and eliminate sports programs – a decision that has angered the community, left over 65 student-athletes without a team and cost coaches their jobs – the university would at least have made sure its financial analysis was correct. In fact, the analysis that UNM has used is fundamentally flawed.

The UNM regents concluded that eliminating various teams, including the highly popular and successful men’s soccer program, and reducing the rosters of others, was necessary in order to deal with Athletic Department financial issues and Title IX concerns. This decision was based on recommendations and reports provided by the UNM administration, including a financial analysis prepared internally by the Athletic Department.

The regents’ decision was met with public uproar, as well as criticism of UNM’s financial analysis. Among those who found fault with UNM’s analysis was Andy Schwarz, a nationally known economist who specializes in collegiate athletic financial issues.

Schwarz and his firm, OSKR Consulting, have worked on many cases involving college sports accounting issues and are considered leading experts in assessing potential savings and costs that accrue to a university when adding, eliminating or roster-managing sports programs.

The overall conclusion by Schwarz was that UNM’s internally prepared financial analysis was seriously flawed. Schwarz focused primarily on UNM’s assertion that it would save $467,485 annually by no longer having to provide grants-in-aid – athletic scholarships – to students on the eliminated or reduced teams. Schwarz determined UNM had seriously erred in assessing how much money each eliminated scholarship would actually save and had failed entirely to take into account the lost revenues from the tuition and fees paid by non-scholarship athletes on these teams. His conclusion: Not only would the grants-in-aid portion of the cuts not save UNM $467,485 annually, it would actually cost the university $328,830 annually due to lost revenues.

Therefore, this independent analysis demonstrated the financial information provided by the Athletic Department was materially flawed by an annual amount totaling approximately $796,000. Considering that the UNM administration asserted that the cuts as a whole would save UNM about $1.15 million per year, that meant UNM’s figures were overstated by at least half.

UNM and the regents have had this information since August. Community members provided it to them for their further consideration with an offer to respond to questions on Schwarz’s conclusions. At no time have UNM representatives or regents expressed any interest in meeting and discussing the results of this OSKR analysis, and when community members have raised these issues at regents’ meetings, the regents have showed no interest in further addressing them.

Surprisingly, a document recently released by UNM regarding the athletic cuts concedes the financial issues related to cuts were “minimal to the overall scope of the university,” an unbelievable admission by UNM at this late date…

Given the significance of the regents’ decision to cut and reduce sports and the apparent legitimacy of the independent third-party analysis, it seems unreasonable and illogical that the regents and UNM administration would not now take the necessary steps to sit down and discuss these financial inconsistencies.

While significant new state monies and bipartisan support for changing this decision exist and will manifest themselves at the upcoming legislative session, we encourage reasoned and financially qualified individuals – both from within and from outside UNM – to arrange collaborative communication in order to resolve these financial inconsistencies.

Only if this happens can the regents truly know they have made appropriate and responsible decisions that will impact the university for many future years.

Home » From the newspaper » UNM sports cuts based on seriously flawed analysis

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Editorial: APS calendar plan earns mixed grades
From the Editorial Board: More classroom ... From the Editorial Board: More classroom time and more teacher training make sense, but not if students only get four additional instructional days and ...
Editorial: Mayor’s right: Pay camera fines or wear a ...
From the Editorial Board: If chronic ... From the Editorial Board: If chronic speeders aren't getting the message to slow down through citations, then a boot should do it.
Young worker makes good money but zero benefits
ABQnews Seeker
Dear J.T. & Dale: My daughter ... Dear J.T. & Dale: My daughter graduated college in the pandemic. Because she couldn't go o ...
5 ways to help protect your health on your ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: Proper travel preparation can help ... OPINION: Proper travel preparation can help avoid health issues, promote well-being and protect against unexpected complications.
We need different approaches for folks who have entered ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: There's an immediate need to ... OPINION: There's an immediate need to support shelters for migrants.
Chamber leaders assess impact on businesses after legislative session
ABQnews Seeker
The Journal reached out to three ... The Journal reached out to three chamber leaders - New Mexico Chamber of Commerce President and CEO Rob Black, Albuquerque Hispano Chamber of Commerce ...
Albuquerque junk removal company expands into pressure washing
ABQnews Seeker
A year after quitting their desk ... A year after quitting their desk jobs to start a junk removal company, Nathan Farmer and Brian Battaglia have added pressure washing to the ...
Hamill: Tax administration is not the right venue for ...
ABQnews Seeker
COLUMN: We should expect that AI ... COLUMN: We should expect that AI tools have significant deficiencies in administering tax laws if their decisions are not human-reviewed.
FBI raid nets fentanyl, meth, guns and cash
ABQnews Seeker
An FBI raid of two Albuquerque ... An FBI raid of two Albuquerque area homes on Thursday led to the discovery of around 1 ...