Editorial: SB 118 well intentioned, but weakens due process - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: SB 118 well intentioned, but weakens due process

Once again, well-intentioned legislation in the Roundhouse is being touted as a way to protect the identities of sexual assault victims, when in reality it’s a way to circumvent due process and shield those who would make false accusations.

Senate Bill 118, sponsored by Sen. Jacob Candelaria, D-Albuquerque, is a reconstituted version of his SB 149, which was vetoed in 2017. This time around, it’s on Democratic lawmakers’ “rocket docket,” meaning along with 37 other bills it will be fast-tracked through committees next week while receiving minimal, if any, scrutiny.

Top-ranking Democrats have said the “rocket docket” is a way to show New Mexicans that lawmakers are serious about having a productive session. That’s one interpretation. It’s also a way to ram though legislation without having to answer too many questions. It’s a way to disenfranchise 19 brand new House members who will get little chance to debate it in committee.

While most bills go to two or three committees in each chamber, those on the “rocket docket” only have one hearing.

House Minority Whip Rod Montoya, R-Farmington, calls it “a dereliction of duty.”

And that methodology has no place when dealing with the legal system and crime victims.

SB 118 would amend the state’s Inspection of Public Records Act to allow law enforcement agencies to keep secret anything in police reports that would reveal the identity of victims of, or non-law enforcement witnesses to, six crimes before charges are filed.

Those are: assault with intent to commit criminal sexual penetration; assault against a household member with intent to commit criminal sexual penetration; stalking; aggravated stalking; criminal sexual penetration; and criminal sexual contact.

Those are awful crimes, and the desire to protect victims is understandable. That’s why local news media have policies against reporting alleged sexual assault victims’ names in criminal cases unless they choose to go public.

But go beyond the raw emotion a sexual assault evokes. Remember that our country’s system of jurisprudence and due process can be antiseptic, messy and everything in between, yet it remains the foundation of our legal system. And that includes a justice system based on due process, giving both accuser and accused their legal rights. And it’s based on the ability to follow an accusation through to see if law enforcement did its job or if justice was served.

It’s much more difficult to follow a case and judge how law enforcement handled it without the identities of all involved. Do we as a state want to shield incompetency or worse when it comes to investigations of these crimes, adding insult to the victims’ injuries? Do we want to shield false accusers and leave the falsely accused out there alone?

Let’s say you’re a successful businessman or woman, and someone files a false allegation against you. What if it’s someone who has a history of filing false reports? This accuser’s name is kept secret while your name is public. That person is protected while your reputation alone is on the line for all to see. Is that justice?

Candelaria’s SB 118 preys on the reasonable desire of all New Mexicans to protect crime victims, especially those of sexual assault. We understand it has broad support among lawmakers. It will be heard in the Roundhouse as early as Monday before Senate Judiciary.

But a strong case can be made that it puts the state’s imprimatur on the kind of secrecy that gave the false University of Virginia rape allegations life.

No one wants to add to the pain endured by sexual assault victims. But our justice system and due process dictate that the rights of all those involved be protected – regardless of the allegations. SB 118 does the opposite.

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: SB 118 well intentioned, but weakens due process


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Editorial: NM merits radiation compensation, too
Editorials
Extending the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act ... Extending the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act another two years was the right thing to do. Conti ...
2
Editorial: Sorry, NM lawmaking doesn’t need armed staff
Editorials
Guns can be intimidating. That's why ... Guns can be intimidating. That's why crooks often brandish them while robbing stores.  &n ...
3
Editorial: Pulitzer honors NM artist
Editorials
Earlier this month, Raven Chacon, a ... Earlier this month, Raven Chacon, a Diné composer based in Albuquerque, became the first Native Ame ...
4
Editorial: Pet-surrender fee unleashes avalanche
Editorials
Since the Journal implemented a weekly ... Since the Journal implemented a weekly Top of Mind question last fall for our expanded Sunday Opinio ...
5
Editorial: Make fire-ravaged NM whole
Editorials
The federal response to Gov. Michelle ... The federal response to Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham's request for disaster relief as a result ...
6
Editorial: Ronchetti best among GOP field for governor
Editorials
Today, the Journal concludes its endorsements ... Today, the Journal concludes its endorsements in contested primary races with its picks for governor ...
7
Editorial: Journal announces endorsements for state AG, auditor and ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its endorsements ... Today, the Journal announces its endorsements in contested primary races for New Mexico attorney gen ...
8
Editorial: Journal backs Garcia Holmes and Vasquez in CD1 ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its endorsements ... Today, the Journal announces its endorsements for contested primary races for the U.S. House of Repr ...
9
Editorial: Journal announces endorsements for BernCO commission and county ...
Editorials
Today, the Journal announces its primary ... Today, the Journal announces its primary endorsements for Bernalillo County commission and county assessor.