Holtec defends plan for nuclear waste storage facility - Albuquerque Journal

Holtec defends plan for nuclear waste storage facility

Holtec International addressed concerns raised by environmental groups during the second day of a federal hearing in Albuquerque on Thursday, but not to the satisfaction of many of the parties opposing the company’s planned interim storage site for spent nuclear fuel in southeast New Mexico.

“They’re engaging in delusional, magical thinking,” said Michael Keegan of Don’t Waste Michigan, one of the petitioners represented at the hearing.

Keegan referred to Holtec’s responses to some of the questions posed by the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board.

“Can a leaking canister be repaired?” judge Nicholas Tikouros asked.

“The answer is, that is outside the scope because there are no credible leak threats,” answered Holtec counsel Jay Silberg, causing jeers and laughter from the audience of around 60 people.

According to the company, none of its existing canisters have ever leaked.

Silberg followed that by saying, hypothetically, if a canister did have a leak, it could be encapsulated by another intact canister.

Holtec similarly dismissed other concerns, including a Sierra Club contention that subsidence at the site between Carlsbad and Hobbs could damage waste-laden casks.

“… We do not believe there will be subsidence at the site,” said Holtec attorney Anne Leidich, who said research indicates there is no historical evidence of subsidence occurring at the 1,000-acre site.

Holtec said in a news release released Thursday afternoon that it does not believe any of the parties’ contentions had merit.

“Neither the (board’s) questions nor the parties’ responses raised any new issues as to the technical merits of Holtec’s HI-STORE application submitted to the (Nuclear Regulatory Commission) in March 2017,” the release said. “The opponents’ responses were largely hypothetical and speculative statements rather than ones based on sound science and appropriate legal standards.”

Holtec did concur with opponents that the U.S. Department of Energy cannot take ownership of the radioactive waste under current law, which stipulates there must be a permanent repository in place before the DOE can do so.

If the federal Nuclear Waste Policy Act is not altered or a permanent repository is not constructed in the meantime, Silberg said the plan will still be viable if electric utilities retain title to the waste.

“Right now, as we discussed this morning, DOE can’t own the fuel,” Silberg said during a break at Thursday’s proceedings. “They’re not authorized. But the argument that somehow listing DOE as one of the possibilities makes the whole deal illegal is just crazy.”

But opponents questioned the validity of the project should the law not be changed.

“The electric utilities are wanting to move (spent nuclear fuel) to this location to get rid of liability,” said Tom “Smitty” Smith, director of special projects with Public Citizen, another petitioner. “So, the question then becomes are they willing to retain the liability when it’s offsite and maintained by a third party?”

Thursday was the final day of the hearing.

The Atomic Safety and Licensing Board will now determine which contentions raised, if any, will be considered during future, more substantial, hearings in the next few months.

Home » News » Albuquerque News » Holtec defends plan for nuclear waste storage facility


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Emptying the Notebook: Where Morris Udeze's performance stacks up ...
ABQnews Seeker
Some extra notes, quotes, stats and ... Some extra notes, quotes, stats and analysis from Sunday's Lobo game, including some historical perspective on the game Morris Udeze had.
2
Do job-seekers still have the upper hand with salary ...
ABQnews Seeker
You are at the mercy of ... You are at the mercy of the market until you can prove you’re worth more
3
A man lost his leg after being run over ...
ABQnews Seeker
Lawsuit claims forklift operator, store did ... Lawsuit claims forklift operator, store did not take proper precautions
4
The annual Rio Grande Arts and Crafts Festival Holiday ...
ABQnews Seeker
In its 22nd year, the holiday ... In its 22nd year, the holiday show featured the work of 165 artists
5
University of New Mexico's plan for massive development project ...
ABQnews Seeker
Plan to use tax money for ... Plan to use tax money for site's development under scrutiny
6
End of the line: Why some New Mexicans may ...
ABQnews Seeker
NM Medicaid enrollees warned: Yearly requalifications ... NM Medicaid enrollees warned: Yearly requalifications on horizon again
7
NM National Guard delivers donated freezers to families affected ...
ABQnews Seeker
Freezers were given to San Miguel ... Freezers were given to San Miguel and Mora county residents after damage caused by fire or related power outages
8
Udeze's monster game, defense late lead Lobos to blowout ...
ABQnews Seeker
Morris Udeze had 33 points and ... Morris Udeze had 33 points and 14 rebounds, earning the Lobo Classic MVP award, and led UNM to a blowout win over Northern Colorado.
9
Albuquerque Police Department: Man hospitalized after stabbing
ABQnews Seeker
Victim in stable condition after multiple ... Victim in stable condition after multiple stab wounds, police say