Prosecutors urge court to uphold Jodi Arias’ conviction

PHOENIX — The prosecutor who won a guilty verdict against Jodi Arias in the 2008 death of her former boyfriend made mistakes at trial that should be outweighed by overwhelming evidence of her guilt, state lawyers said while urging an appeals court to uphold her conviction.

The Arizona Attorney General’s Office acknowledged instances in which Maricopa County prosecutor Juan Martinez was argumentative with two witnesses, responded to a claim that he was uncivil during the trial, and argued that publicity didn’t cause any prejudice against Arias.

“While the prosecutor unsurprisingly made some mistakes during Arias’s 69-day trial, those errors did not prejudice the jury in light of the court’s curative actions and the overwhelming evidence of Arias’s guilt,” wrote Terry Crist, an assistant attorney general.

The arguments made this summer in Arias’ appeal include allegations that Martinez improperly questioned witnesses and courted news coverage. Her lawyers also argued that Judge Sherry Stephens let news organizations turn the trial into a “circus-like atmosphere.”

Arias, 38, is serving a life sentence after her first-degree murder conviction in the death of Travis Alexander at his home in Mesa.

Prosecutors said Arias attacked Alexander in a jealous rage after he wanted to end their affair and planned a trip to Mexico with another woman. Arias has acknowledged killing Alexander but claimed it was self-defense after he attacked her.

The guilt phase of Arias’ trial ended in 2013 with jurors convicting her but deadlocking on punishment. A second sentencing trial stretched into early 2015, also resulting in a jury deadlock. That required Stephens to sentence Arias to prison for life.

The case turned into a media circus as salacious and violent details about Arias and Alexander were broadcast live around the world.

Arias actively courted the spotlight after she was arrested in 2008. She did interviews on TV’s “48 Hours” and “Inside Edition” and was on the witness stand for several weeks during the trial. She also did a series of media interviews after her conviction.

The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office, which prosecuted Arias during the trial, didn’t immediately respond Thursday afternoon to a request for comment from Martinez.

The Attorney General’s Office said Martinez was argumentative toward Arias and a psychotherapist who testified on her behalf, such as when Arias claimed that she had a memory problem. “If it benefits you, you have a memory issue?” Martinez responded.

Crist said many of the people who testified on Arias’ behalf were difficult and not adequately responding to questions.

The Attorney General’s Office also pointed out that when issues of publicity popped up during the trial, jurors repeatedly said they hadn’t seen news coverage of the case and could remain fair and impartial.

Crist said Arias generated publicity by giving TV interviews before the trial and spoke on camera to a reporter on the day of her guilty verdict, even though her attorneys didn’t want her to do so.

Arias’ attorneys complained that Martinez signed autographs and posed for photos outside the courthouse during the trial, but Crist said the judge found no evidence that autographs and photos would affect the verdict, because no jurors saw those exchanges.

Mike Black, a Phoenix defense attorney who isn’t involved in the Arias case, said he believes Arias’ conviction will be upheld. Overturning a case on a publicity argument is “an extraordinarily high bar,” he said.


Follow Jacques Billeaud at

Share Your Story

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango


taboola desktop


Houston officer dead, another wounded while serving warrant
Around the Region
A Houston police officer was killed ... A Houston police officer was killed and another was wounded Monday morning during a shooting that also killed a 31-year-old man who the officers ...
Lawmakers: Atmosphere at Arizona Legislature more toxic now
Around the Region
Senate President Karen Fann's Sept. 10 ... Senate President Karen Fann's Sept. 10 press release was short on details but clear on one point – a senator had received a threat ...
Liability concerns lead to shutdown of some Colorado 14ers
Around the Region
The ramifications of a lawsuit that ... The ramifications of a lawsuit that ended with the U.S. government paying an injured mountain biker several million dollars after a crash on a ...
COVID burnout rises among Colorado's public health leaders
Around the Region
A few weeks ago, Dawn James' ... A few weeks ago, Dawn James' job as Kit Carson's public health director was making her sick to her stomach. After being questioned, threatened ...
Trust's investment profits produce outpouring of grants
Around the Region
A Phoenix-based charitable trust's investments over ... A Phoenix-based charitable trust's investments over the last 15 months did well and dozens of social service groups, arts organizations and other nonprofits still ...
Maricopa County attorney: Returning to work after treatment
Around the Region
Maricopa County Attorney Allister Adel plans ... Maricopa County Attorney Allister Adel plans to return to work Monday after getting treatment for nearly three weeks for anxiety as well as an ...
Rural patients unable to transfer to full Arizona hospitals
Around the Region
As Arizona's biggest hospitals fill up ... As Arizona's biggest hospitals fill up with COVID-19 cases, physicians in some of the state's smaller or more rural communities fear it's their patients ...
Arizona reports 2,457 new COVIC-19 cases and 26 more ...
Around the Region
Health officials in Arizona on Sunday ... Health officials in Arizona on Sunday reported 2,457 new COVID-19 cases and 26 additional deaths. The latest numbers increased the state's totals to 1,066,803 ...
Colorado Republican leaders reject opting out of primary
Around the Region
Colorado Republican leaders have voted down ... Colorado Republican leaders have voted down a proposal from that would have allowed GOP nominees to be selected by a relatively small number of ...