State forges ahead on San Juan abandonment hearings - Albuquerque Journal

State forges ahead on San Juan abandonment hearings

The Public Regulation Commission voted 5-0 on Wednesday to immediately begin public hearings on Public Service Co. of New Mexico’s plans to abandon the coal-fired San Juan Generating Station near Farmington.

PNM had asked the commission to wait until mid-2019 to give the utility time to prepare a detailed plan for abandoning the plant and replacing that electricity with alternative resources.

The utility said immediate hearings are unnecessary, since San Juan would not close until June 2022. And it warned that immediate PRC proceedings could interfere with a PNM-backed legislative initiative to help finance plant closure and mitigate the economic impact on local communities. That’s because the Legislature can’t approve things that may directly alter management of a regulatory case already under way.

But commissioners said PNM and three of the other four plant co-owners already firmly stated their intent in June and July 2018 to abandon San Juan yet PNM did not inform the commission about that decision until Dec. 31, when it submitted a “compliance filing” to the PRC on the future of San Juan.

The decision to cease operating the plant in 2022 represented a “triggering event” that requires the PRC to immediately review the issue with public input, according to PRC General Counsel Michael Smith.

“The commission is required to have an abandonment proceeding,” Smith told commissioners on Wednesday. “It’s our obligation to provide notice to the public and allow parties to intervene in opposition and support with a public hearing.”

That includes input from the city of Farmington, which owns an 8 percent share in one of two generating units that still operates at San Juan. The city, San Juan County and others in the Four Corners want to explore the potential transfer of San Juan to new operators after 2022.

Commissioner Stephen Fischmann said proceedings are urgent because closing San Juan and replacing it with alternative resources will take years of preparation and action. The plant supplies more than a third of PNM’s electric generation.

“This is a big deal,” Fischmann said. “I can’t imagine any scenario where San Juan just turns off and other generating resources turn on. It will be a complex process to phase things out and in, and that will have to start happening pretty fast.”

Commissioner Cynthia Hall questioned why PNM waited six months to tell the PRC about its abandonment decision.

“PNM simply didn’t tell us, and that impacts many people in this state, including people who would like to keep the plant open,” Hall said. “…We need to hear from all voices in the community.”

Regarding the upcoming legislation, Wednesday’s order says the commission is obligated to act under existing law, not base its actions on “speculative legislation,” Smith told commissioners.

Environmental groups are divided on the forthcoming legislation, which which would allow PNM to recover 100 percent of its investment in San Juan by selling low-cost bonds that utility customers would pay for through a surcharge on their bills. The money raised would help finance renewable energy replacement power, while providing resources to mitigate impacts from plant closure through economic development projects.

But opponents call it a bailout for the utility, which might not receive full recovery for its coal investments if left to the PRC, which must balance the costs of early plant closure between utility customers and PNM shareholders.

PNM called the commission’s action premature.

“During the session, lawmakers and our new governor are expected to enact legislation that will affect all aspects of our state’s energy policy,” said PNM spokesman Raymond Sandoval in an email to the Journal. “It would be prudent to let the governor and lawmakers do their jobs.”

Home » Business » Energy » State forges ahead on San Juan abandonment hearings

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
There’s almost unlimited clean, geothermal energy under our feet. ...
ABQnews Seeker
Modern drilling capabilities developed by the ... Modern drilling capabilities developed by the oil and gas industry are opening the gateway to deep underground geothermal energy.
Find out when Luke Bryan's tour will make a ...
ABQnews Seeker
The critically acclaimed country singer and ... The critically acclaimed country singer and 'American Idol' judge will hit the road on his 36-city 'Country On Tour' beginning June 15.
In the near future, clean geothermal energy could heat ...
ABQnews Seeker
The University of New Mexico's Utility ... The University of New Mexico's Utility Services Department could in the near future he ...
Get to know Harry Montoya, who reads NM Senate ...
ABQnews Seeker
“One of my friends, he said, ... “One of my friends, he said, ‘Oh, you’re God’s voice in the Capitol,'” Harry Montoya said, laughing.
Bill would allow New Mexico cities, counties, tribes to ...
ABQnews Seeker
The proposed legislation would allow local ... The proposed legislation would allow local governments to take over electric generation from privately run utilities.
Best sites for Albuquerque building and road construction information
ABQnews Seeker
WHAT'S UP WITH THAT CONSTRUCTION? Michael ... WHAT'S UP WITH THAT CONSTRUCTION? Michael A. Blackledge asks "does the city of Albuquerq ...
Bernalillo County sheriff calls current body camera tech 'trash,' ...
ABQnews Seeker
The sheriff's statement on body cameras ... The sheriff's statement on body cameras was in response to a recommendation from the Sheriff's Office Advisory and Review Board. The board gave BCSO ...
Largest police cadet class in years seated in Santa ...
ABQnews Seeker
The 205th New Mexico Law Enforcement ... The 205th New Mexico Law Enforcement Academy class has 64 prospective officers. The class is shaping up to be the largest in years.
New Mexico seems determined to extend class time. What ...
ABQnews Seeker
Three competing proposals are on the ... Three competing proposals are on the table
Find out how to get involved with Netflix's 'Rez ...
ABQnews Seeker
Calling all Native American hoopsters. Midthunder ... Calling all Native American hoopsters. Midthunder Casting announced a casting call for Native American males and females to play high school basketball players in ...