State rep. backs off bill to censor internet content - Albuquerque Journal

State rep. backs off bill to censor internet content

Andrea Romero

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – After a scorching backlash, freshman state Rep. Andrea Romero on Friday quickly backed off a bill that would have required that publishers remove “inaccurate, irrelevant, inadequate or excessive content regarding an individual” from the internet.

Critics saw the measure as an assault on the First Amendment and press freedom by Romero, who was the subject of months of hard-hitting news coverage and commentary during her successful run for northern Santa Fe County’s House District 46 seat last year.

Romero, a Democrat, introduced what she titled the “Right to be Forgotten Act,” which would require “certain persons that provide public information to remove damaging information upon request.”

“A publisher shall remove inaccurate, irrelevant, inadequate or excessive content regarding an individual, and any links or indexes to that content, within thirty days of the date of receipt of a request to do so from that individual,” House Bill 437 says.

Chuck Peifer, an attorney with First Amendment expertise who represents the Journal, said the proposed bill could be used to punish a publisher who refused to censor information.

“It’s plainly unconstitutional; that’s the bottom line,” Peifer said. “That’s classically unconstitutional as violating the First Amendment.”

Romero said in a written statement Friday afternoon that she is quashing the bill. News reporters and others had thrashed the measure, filed at the Legislature Thursday, on social media.

“Although there is not a formal process for withdrawing legislation, I have asked the Speaker of the New Mexico House of Representatives to table this bill indefinitely,” her statement said.

The bill broadly defines “inaccurate, irrelevant, inadequate or excessive” information as “content relating to an individual that, after a significant lapse in time from its publication, is no longer material to current public debate or discourse when considered in light of the demonstrable harm that the information, article or other content is causing to the individual’s professional, financial or personal reputation or other interest.”

The bill did include an exception for “criminal convictions, legal matters relating to violence in which the individual played a substantial role or content that is of significant public interest.”

The proposed legislation would impose monetary penalties of $250 for each day after 30 days from when an individual asked for content to be removed from the web.

New Mexico Foundation for Open Government Executive Director Melanie Majors said the bill could restrict freedom of speech and lead to censorship.

“Transparency and accountability are essential for a working democracy, and this is a terrible anti-transparency bill,” Majors said. “The New Mexico Foundation for Open Government is opposed to any law that restricts the public’s right to know. This proposed legislation is troubling. It’s like walking into a library and forcing them to destroy books you don’t like.”

Romero’s statement said her intent was “to protect victims of revenge porn, cyber bullying, and others,” though neither revenge porn nor cyber bullying are mentioned in the bill.

Romero did not answer emailed questions or return a phone call asking for an explanation of this discrepancy.

Her statement further read, “I understand that the language was far more sweeping than intended, and I would never want to – in any way – undermine the 1st Amendment. Media plays an important role in Democracy and I respect and honor their contribution to public debate.”

Romero faced controversy during and after her successful Democratic primary race against then-District 46 incumbent Carl Trujillo.

Two audits raised questions about thousands of dollars of travel and other spending by the taxpayer-supported Regional Coalition of LANL Communities, where she was executive director. Romero was reimbursed for spending on booze and Major League Baseball tickets at coalition board events.

Her contract with the coalition, which advocates for federal dollars for hazardous waste cleanup and jobs at Los Alamos National Laboratory, expired during the controversy.

News coverage of the coalition’s financial mess and Romero’s role in it continued even after the primary. Romero defeated a write-in opponent in the November general election.

David Carl, the spokesman for the state Attorney General’s Office, said Romero is being investigated, apparently over Regional Coalition matters, but would not say specifically what is being looked into.

“We can confirm the Office of the Attorney General has received a public referral and this matter is under review,” Carl said in an email. “All complaints received by the Office of the Attorney General are fully reviewed and appropriate action is taken, but we remain deeply concerned about any misuse of public funds by officials.”

This article has been changed from an earlier version to note that Romero did have a write-in opponent in the November general and did not run unopposed.

Home » News » New Mexico News » State rep. backs off bill to censor internet content

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
David Batista named branch manager with Yellowstone Landscape
ABQnews Seeker
BRIEFCASE: NMSU grad has been with ... BRIEFCASE: NMSU grad has been with the landscape company for 17 years.
Mexico: Migrants lit mattresses in protest; fire killed 39
ABQnews Seeker
MEXICO CITY (AP) -- Migrants fearing ... MEXICO CITY (AP) -- Migrants fearing deportation set mattresses ablaze at an immigration detention center in northern Mexico, starting a fire that left 39 ...
New Mexico abortion care: What's happening now and what ...
ABQnews Seeker
When Roe v. Wade was overturned ... When Roe v. Wade was overturned last summer, New Mexico seemed poised to become a destination for those seeking abortion. Here's what's happened since ...
WaFd's Lonnie Corral promoted to senior VP
ABQnews Seeker
BRIEFCASE: Corral will continue to lead ... BRIEFCASE: Corral will continue to lead the nine branches he oversees in southern New Mexico.
La Luz Elementary School students were originally expected to ...
ABQnews Seeker
Originally, the district's plans were to ... Originally, the district's plans were to move students out in 2025. Now, APS wants to do it this fall.
Authorities say a man brought a gun into Flix ...
ABQnews Seeker
If not for the theater's beer ... If not for the theater's beer taps or the man's suspected use of cocaine, the gun-wielding patron who sent Flix Brewhouse employees into a ...
Lobo hoops notebook: Seck to transfer, House returns, Udeze ...
ABQnews Seeker
News and notes around Lobo basketball, ... News and notes around Lobo basketball, including another transferring scholarship player and updates on Morris Udeze and Jaelen House.
Judge: District attorney can't be co-counsel in Baldwin case
ABQnews Seeker
SANTA FE, N.M. (AP) -- A ... SANTA FE, N.M. (AP) -- A New Mexico judge said Santa Fe's district attorney shouldn't serve as co-counsel in the manslaughter case against actor ...
What do PNM-Avangrid merger opponents really want?
ABQnews Seeker
Here's what merger supporters and opponents ... Here's what merger supporters and opponents have to say about the public-power movement’s influence on the Avangrid-PNM deal.