Openness advocates blast ethics panel bill - Albuquerque Journal

Openness advocates blast ethics panel bill

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – New Mexico’s new ethics commission would operate largely in secret and impose harsh penalties for violating that confidentiality under legislation proposed in the state Senate.

The secrecy provisions drew sharp criticism Friday from a variety of advocacy groups – including Common Cause, Ethics Watch and the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government. Common Cause, for example, described the ethics commission proposed in Senate Bill 619 as “a weak body, shrouded in secrecy with little enforcement power.”

The sponsor of the proposal, Sen. Linda Lopez, D-Albuquerque, said she is still working on the bill and seeking bipartisan input on how to proceed.

“It’ll be changing,” she said of the legislation.

As it stands now, Senate Bill 619 would impose stiffer penalties on people who violate the confidentiality provisions than it would on officials who violate ethical standards. The gag provision includes those who file a complaint.

The commission’s hearings would be closed to the public, and its documents would be confidential, except in limited circumstances.

Transparency advocates said the secrecy would undermine public confidence in the ethics process.

“Any committee created to hold our elected officials to high ethical standards can only be effective if its proceedings are as open as possible,” said Melanie J. Majors, executive director of the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government.

The debate comes as lawmakers wrestle with how to establish a state ethics commission approved by New Mexico voters last year. The board is empowered to investigate and decide on complaints alleging ethical misconduct by government officials, candidates, lobbyists, contractors and employees.

Approval of the constitutional amendment, which passed with 75 percent of the vote, followed a series of ethics scandals in New Mexico, including the 2017 conviction of a former state senator on corruption charges.

The amendment left it up to the Legislature to establish the details of how the commission would operate, and Lopez’s bill is just one proposal.

House Bill 4, sponsored by Rep. Daymon Ely, D-Corrales, outlines a less secretive process. He said it would allow people involved in ethics complaints – either the accused or the person making the allegation – to speak publicly about the matter, if they choose to.

“In no way are we abridging people’s First Amendment rights,” Ely said of his proposal.

However, the commission itself would not disclose complaints that were found to be unsubstantiated, under his proposal.

The Senate measure, meanwhile, calls for the commission to release a public report only if it finds someone guilty of an ethics violation. It could issue a public reprimand or censure and recommend disciplinary action, but it would be up to the House, Senate or other public body to determine whether to actually impose any discipline.

Disclosing a confidential ethics document could result in a year in jail or a $10,000 fine, unless a court authorizes a bigger fine, under the Senate proposal.

Heather Ferguson, executive director of Common Cause New Mexico, said the Senate proposal doesn’t match what people voted for.

“What they want is a commission that has integrity, that encourages the public to file complaints and that restores their trust in our political process,” she said. “A commission shrouded in secrecy, with high penalties for those who file complaints, will do nothing but have a chilling effect.”

Kathleen Sabo, executive director of New Mexico Ethics Watch, said the bill “fails miserably to engender public trust in the commission’s work by keeping most things behind closed doors.”

The concerns raised by Common Cause and Ethics Watch include:

⋄  The inability of the commission to punish wrongdoers beyond a reprimand or censure.

⋄  The lack of subpoena power. The commission would have to ask a state District Court to issue subpoenas to compel the testimony of witnesses or obtain documents. (Ely’s House bill would give the commission subpoena power.)

⋄  The requirement of such a high standard of proof that it would be difficult to charge and find public officials guilty of ethical violations.

⋄  The lack of public access to hearings and complaints, exemptions from the Open Meetings Act and Inspection of Public Records Act, and the institution of harsh penalties for those who release information to the public.

Home » News » New Mexico News » Openness advocates blast ethics panel bill

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
FBI raid nets fentanyl, meth, guns and cash
ABQnews Seeker
An FBI raid of two Albuquerque ... An FBI raid of two Albuquerque area homes on Thursday led to the discovery of around 1 ...
Hobbs police officer shoots and injures teenager in stolen ...
ABQnews Seeker
Hobbs police were called to a ... Hobbs police were called to a fight involving several people at 1:45 p.m. on Saturday. An officer shot a 17-year-old who was driving a ...
A basketball decision: Josiah Allick opens up on opting ...
ABQnews Seeker
Josiah Allick, a fan favorite who ... Josiah Allick, a fan favorite who many assumed would be back for the Lobos, entered the transfer portal. In his own words, he tells ...
'They made a statement by hiring a guy like ...
ABQnews Seeker
"I think they made a statement ... "I think they made a statement when they hired a guy like me," said Jason Hooten, who came from Sam Houston State and was ...
At 41, Holly Holm continues to evolve as a ...
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque's Holm, who at age 41 ... Albuquerque's Holm, who at age 41 has signed a six-fight contract extension with the UFC, soundly defeated Yana Santos — a mere kid of ...
APD reviewed every 2022 police shooting. Here are the ...
ABQnews Seeker
New equipment and training are among ... New equipment and training are among the actions proposed by the Albuquerque Police leadership group.
Meteorologists say El Niño typically brings wetter weather to ...
ABQnews Seeker
With the departure of La Niña, ... With the departure of La Niña, New Mexicans can expect to see lower temperatures and wetter weather in wintertime, a meteorologist said.
Stansbury, Dems call on Buttigieg to increase train regulations
ABQnews Seeker
U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury, D-N.M., and ... U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury, D-N.M., and two other Democratic representatives wrote to Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg, calling for stricter regulations after a hazardous train ...
FBI raid nets 100,000 fentanyl pills, 16 pounds of ...
ABQnews Seeker
One of the men arrested "was ... One of the men arrested "was found to be in possession of an incredible amount of drugs," a motion reads.