Russia, Trump campaign colluded legally, just like PACs do regularly - Albuquerque Journal

Russia, Trump campaign colluded legally, just like PACs do regularly

Special counsel Robert Mueller’s report evidently failed to find sufficient evidence that President Donald Trump or his campaign illegally conspired with Russian agents in the 2016 election. However, to understand political reality we must place the unusual Trump-Russian relationship in the financial context of usual presidential campaigns.

The U.S. Supreme Court has recast – some would say emasculated – post-Watergate reforms starting with Buckley v. Valeo (424 U.S. 1 [1976]). The court created a two-tiered system of permissible regulation of campaign finance. Contributions directly to campaign organizations controlled by the candidate can be subject to relatively severe restrictions – e.g., limits on how much can be contributed – because there is a high chance of corruption or the appearance of corruption in that situation. The court maintains that less severe restrictions are permitted if a campaign organization – a PAC – is independent of the candidate, because there is less chance of corruption.

This independence is a fiction. Media purchases and campaign ads are available, and the candidate can publicly acknowledge strategic information. Independent PACs easily tailor their efforts to match the publicly known efforts of the candidate. Public statements can help guide the efforts of independent PACs. For example, the candidate could say, “We are putting maximum effort into Florida and cannot contribute more to Pennsylvania.” Message to independent PACs: put money into Pennsylvania. Or the candidate can announce, “We think we will make inroads into the opposition party’s support among white, working class voters.” Message to independent PACs: target those voters. Suppose the candidate said: “If somebody has those missing emails of my opponent, I wish they would release them.” Message to an independent PAC: find and release those emails.

The judicial myth of independence does, however, have a pernicious effect. Independent PACs can run scurrilous, negative ads against an opponent. If there is blowback, the candidate has plausible deniability, because he or she cannot legally direct the efforts of an independent PAC.

It is illegal for the candidate or his or her organization to communicate directly with independent PACs. Coordinating by burner phones, secret email accounts, or midnight meetings in abandoned car parks would be illegal. But this would also be incredibly stupid. The independent PAC can achieve all necessary coordination by closely monitoring the candidate’s campaign.

What does this tell us of the Trump-Russia connection before and during the 2016 election? Russian entities and individuals, some with ties to President Vladimir Putin, interfered in the campaign with appeals that neatly tied in with Trump rhetoric. But Trump could hardly be held legally accountable for what the Russians were doing independently. Direct contact by the Trump campaign with Russian entities might be illegal. Such contact would be similar to, but legally distinct from, illegal cooperation with an independent PAC.

Why did Russians help the Trump campaign? One answer is that Trump’s rhetoric fit into Russian’s historic strategy of denigrating democratic institutions and promoting racial, ethnic, and class divisions in countries deemed to be enemies. This strategy goes back to the Comintern – the Third International 1919-1943 – and the Soviet Union during the Cold War. In a sense, the Trump campaign joined the Russian effort rather than the other way around.

There was, however, more than serendipitous similarity. Trump continually praised President Putin and called for better relations with the Russians. The Russian campaign aimed vicious charges at Hillary Clinton, advocated for Trump and discouraged voting by usual Democratic voters. The timing of Russian efforts shows this coordination. For example, release of Hillary Clinton’s hacked emails by WikiLeaks just as The Washington Post published the “Access Hollywood” tape in which Trump boasts of grabbing women.

Trump and the Russians were clearly working together or “colluding” during the campaign in the way that presidential campaigns routinely collude with supposedly independent PACs. Whether there was an illegal conspiracy to facilitate this collusion and any quid pro quo for the Russian efforts, are separate questions.

Theodore S. Arrington is Emeritus Professor of Political Science, University of North Carolina at Charlotte

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


NM can reach higher with free college for all
From the newspaper
Over the past few years, our ... Over the past few years, our state has expanded opportunities for New Mexicans to pursue career trai ...
Lobbyist answers to landowners, not county residents
From the newspaper
Vanessa Alarid's accusations that I am ... Vanessa Alarid's accusations that I am "undemocratic" and unresponsive to my distr ...
San Felipe Pueblo member to lead museum
From the newspaper
San Felipe Pueblo's Cynthia Chavez Lamar ... San Felipe Pueblo's Cynthia Chavez Lamar has been hired to lead the Smithsonian's Nati ...
Tutu teachings offer us moral compass, conscience
From the newspaper
He always believed in a humanizing ... He always believed in a humanizing worldview
School of Public Health can transform NM
From the newspaper
UNM and NMSU can create government ... UNM and NMSU can create government resource center meant to prevent health threats
Editorial: Dow backed ethics commission - until it investigated ...
Shortly after taking office in 2017, ... Shortly after taking office in 2017, state Rep. Rebecca Dow joined other House members in a 66-0 vot ...
HopeWorks rebuts public allegations of fraud by city
From the newspaper
Homeless provider 'committed to resolving this ... Homeless provider 'committed to resolving this misunderstanding'
NM Kids Count says pandemic undermined child well-being
ABQnews Seeker
Report says Hispanic famialies are hit ... Report says Hispanic famialies are hit the hardest
Shortage of COVID tests posing problems for schools
ABQnews Seeker
Health officials are working on distributing ... Health officials are working on distributing tests and masks over the coming weeks