Padilla claims AG concealed recording device in coffeepot - Albuquerque Journal

Padilla claims AG concealed recording device in coffeepot

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

Former Taxation and Revenue Secretary Demesia Padilla sits with her attorney, Paul Kennedy, during her arraignment in July. (Eddie Moore/Albuquerque Journal)

SANTA FE – Former New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Secretary Demesia Padilla is asking a judge to dismiss public corruption charges against her, claiming investigators in Attorney General Hector Balderas’ office violated her due process rights by secretly recording a conversation with her attorney – via a coffeepot outfitted with a recording device – before she was arrested in December 2016.

But the AG’s Office denies surreptitiously listening in on Padilla’s privileged chat, saying the coffeepot recording device – which was on loan from the Albuquerque Police Department – stopped recording while she was talking with her attorney.

“There was no ‘intrusion’ into the attorney-client relationship, deliberate or not,” two assistant attorneys general wrote in a court response filed Tuesday in which they asked the judge to deny the motion.

The allegation of secret recording is at the heart of just one of several pending defense motions in a long-simmering case that’s scheduled to go to trial this summer.

In the initial motion, Padilla’s attorney, Paul Kennedy, argued that AG’s Office agents hid “multiple” recording devices around the office in which they were interviewing Padilla – more than a year before she was ultimately charged with a crime. One of the recording devices was built into a coffeepot to record and transmit both audio and video to another office in the building.

When Padilla asked to speak privately with her attorney, they were not informed of the secret camera, according to the court filing. Their subsequent conversation was also likely used to help guide the AG’s Office’s investigation, the filing claims.

“In this case, the state’s conduct violated due process and warrants dismissal,” Kennedy argued in the motion, adding that the secret recording in the attorney general’s Albuquerque office violated Padilla’s attorney-client privilege.

He also accused the AG’s Office of “outrageous government conduct.”

But Balderas’ office countered that it had a “legitimate law enforcement interest” in recording agents’ interview of Padilla, saying such video recordings can be used to document one’s body language and demeanor.

The AG’s Office also claimed in its court response that Padilla was told her interview with investigators was being recorded – although apparently the coffeepot recording device was not disclosed.

“The Office of the Attorney General will always properly safeguard evidence, and as demonstrated in the previous transparent preliminary hearing, defendant and her attorney were informed that their interview was appropriately recorded and no privileged communications were obtained,” Attorney General’s Office spokesman David Carl told the Journal.

One of former Gov. Susana Martinez’s original Cabinet appointees, Padilla abruptly resigned in December 2016, shortly after state investigators raided the Taxation and Revenue Department’s office in Santa Fe in search of tax documents connected to Padilla and her husband.

She was then charged by the AG’s Office in June 2018 with embezzling more than $25,000 from a Bernalillo-based company, Harold’s Grading & Trucking, and using her appointed position to push for favorable tax treatment.

A Santa Fe Magistrate Court judge ruled in November that there was enough evidence to move forward with most of the charges in the case.

If convicted of all seven charges she is still facing, Padilla, who has pleaded not guilty, could face up to 16 years in prison and as much as $20,000 in fines. In addition to embezzlement, other charges against her include violating the ethical principles of public service and engaging in an official act for personal financial gain.

District Judge Mary Marlowe Sommer could rule on the motion later this month.

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


Bus crashes in Albuquerque after passenger grabs steering wheel, ...
ABQnews Seeker
A Greyhound bus driver was seriously ... A Greyhound bus driver was seriously injured and five passengers taken to local hospitals after a bus carrying 25 people crashed into a light ...
Paseo crash leaves motorcyclist dead
ABQnews Seeker
BCSO: Traffic is backed up, seek ... BCSO: Traffic is backed up, seek an alternative route
Students in need get a holiday shopping splurge
ABQnews Seeker
Businesses donate thousands to let kids ... Businesses donate thousands to let kids shop at local department stores
‘Double dip La Niña’ ahead
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico braces for another warm, ... New Mexico braces for another warm, dry winter
Suit: APS failed to probe reports of gun at ...
ABQnews Seeker
Family of slain 13-year-old student also ... Family of slain 13-year-old student also faults parents of alleged shooter
A prescription for winning the COVID fight
From the newspaper
UNM doctor likens the current battle ... UNM doctor likens the current battle to smallpox and says the vaccine can eradicate it
NM Legal Aid helps over 1,000 every month
From the newspaper
But scores turned away; Legislature can ... But scores turned away; Legislature can change that with more funding
Nominations open for Journal's 10th Top Workplaces program
‘Leaders in today’s post-COVID workplace are ... ‘Leaders in today’s post-COVID workplace are facing a new reality,’ says CEO of research firm Energage
STEM Boomerang helps plug NM's brain drain
Service will host annual career fair ... Service will host annual career fair Thursday to connect local employers with science, technology, engineering and math professionals who want to apply their talents ...