Defense attorneys commend plan to reduce grand juries - Albuquerque Journal

Defense attorneys commend plan to reduce grand juries

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

The state’s Criminal Defense Lawyers Association is commending a district court plan to reduce grand jury availability, calling it a step toward meaningful criminal justice reform.

The association weighed in Tuesday amid an ongoing tug of war in the 2nd Judicial District about how felony cases should be launched.

Most cases are initiated either when a grand jury signs off on an indictment or a judge finds probable cause to support formal charges at a preliminary hearing. And the court is gradually shifting away from Bernalillo County’s indictment-heavy system. That means prosecutors will have to start an increasing number of cases using preliminary hearings, which can take place in either district or Metropolitan Court.

District Attorney Raúl Torrez and Mayor Tim Keller have asked the state’s chief justice to intervene, and Torrez’s office recently notified district court that it would no longer schedule preliminary hearings there. NMCDLA suggests he made the decision “in retaliation for the Second Judicial District Court reducing the number of available grand jury hours.”

“Such politics have no place in the courtroom,” NMCDLA wrote in a news release Tuesday. “This will create an unnecessary backlog and greatly restrict the ability of the accused to exercise their constitutional right to have the (charges) against them reviewed for probable cause. After being given $6 million last year by the legislature, District Attorney Torrez has abandoned his promise to make his office more efficient, instead deciding to embark on a war against judges.”

In a statement Tuesday evening, a spokesman for the DA’s Office called the district court preliminary hearing process an “inefficient use of time and resources.” He said a third of all preliminary hearings were reset in the month of April “meaning the defendant was still in the community without felony charges initiated against them.”

“It is not surprising defense attorneys are defending district court preliminary hearings because it benefits their clients at the expense of public safety,” spokesman Michael Patrick wrote.

Prosecutors say that because they use stricter evidence rules, preliminary hearings can require multiple witnesses, while grand juries decide whether to indict based, in general, on the testimony of a case agent.

The Criminal Defense Lawyers Association, on the other hand, writes that preliminary hearings protect an individual’s right to a lawyer, due process, confrontation and speedy trial.

“District Attorney Torrez wants to remove judicial involvement in the determination of who is dangerous and who gets to be locked up until his office can find the time and resources to prosecute the case,” NMCDLA past-president Matthew Coyte said in the news release. “His latest request seeks to remove judges and defense attorneys from the probable cause determination entirely.”

Home » News » New Mexico News » Defense attorneys commend plan to reduce grand juries


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire now largest wildfire in state ...
ABQnews Seeker
The teams battling the Calf Canyon/Hermits ... The teams battling the Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire said Monday morning that the blaze has grown to more than 298,000 acres, making it the ...
2
In US, states struggle to replace fossil fuel tax ...
ABQnews Seeker
Government budgets are booming in New ... Government budgets are booming in New Mexico: Teacher salaries are up, residents can go to an in-state college tuition-free, moms will get medical care ...
3
Additional floors will allow for UNMH's future expansion
ABQnews Seeker
New tower will house updated surgical ... New tower will house updated surgical rooms
4
Zanetti leaning on military lessons in governor's race
ABQnews Seeker
NM should pursue both high-, low-tech ... NM should pursue both high-, low-tech solutions to economic challenges, says GOP hopeful
5
As winds relent, fire grows by 9K acres
ABQnews Seeker
Officials: Chance for thunderstorms Monday Officials: Chance for thunderstorms Monday
6
Can ABQ crush speeders' cars? It did $1M in ...
ABQnews Seeker
Forfeiture Act determines legal framework for ... Forfeiture Act determines legal framework for impounding cars
7
Stage set for the return of Summerfest
ABQnews Seeker
Summerfest and Freedom 4th are back. ... Summerfest and Freedom 4th are back. ...
8
Lobos land skilled forward transfer Josiah Allick
ABQnews Seeker
The UNM Lobos got a commitment ... The UNM Lobos got a commitment Sunday from 6-8 forward Josiah Allick, who played the past three seasons at UMKC.
9
Multiple vehicles involved in crash on westbound I-40
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque police responded to a major ... Albuquerque police responded to a major wreck Sunday evening that forced the closure of westbound lanes of Interstate 40. Gilbert Gallegos, a police spokesman, ...