Court: Grand jury cuts are local issue - Albuquerque Journal

Court: Grand jury cuts are local issue

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

Instead of intervening as requested, the Supreme Court is urging Bernalillo County’s district attorney to work with local justice partners to resolve his concerns about ongoing cuts to the grand jury system.

Chief Justice Judith Nakamura responded last Friday to a letter sent by District Attorney Raúl Torrez and Mayor Tim Keller asking the high court to step in as Bernalillo County’s District Court moves forward with a plan to increase the use of preliminary hearings by decreasing grand jury settings.

“We believe the issue raised in your letter is more appropriate for review, discussion and resolution by the (Bernalillo County Criminal Justice Coordinating Council) at this time,” Nakamura wrote. “A successful resolution however, will depend upon the full and cooperative participation of key stakeholders, a thorough review of all the data, and a willingness to consider both evidence-based best practices and community needs.”

Nakamura urged Torrez to “participate personally in this process or, at a minimum, designate a representative with policy and decision making authority to attend on his behalf.”

The BCCJCC is made up of 11 council members, including the chief judges at district and Metropolitan Court, the DA, the district public defender, the sheriff, police chief and others. According to its website, the group aims to identify issues in the legal system along with potential solutions and to maximize efficient use of resources.

Torrez wrote back to Nakamura on Thursday, saying that he has no confidence that the concerns of prosecutors and police will have an effect on members of the committee, who have repeatedly opposed the request.

“Despite these misgivings, I will personally ask the BCCJCC to vote on a resolution that we maintain sufficient grand jury capacity to handle no less than 1/3 of our current felony referrals and that no additional cuts be considered until the crime rate in this community matches the rest of the state,” Torrez wrote. He says representatives from his office regularly participate in the group’s meetings and subcommittees.

A spokesman for his office said the DA’s Office receives around 10,000 felony referrals each year, and in recent years it has filed about 4,000 cases in District Court annually.

“We are forced to leave roughly 60 percent of referred cases on the table because the current system can’t handle it,” spokesman Michael Patrick said in a text message Thursday.

Torrez and Keller wrote in their letter that when the court’s plan is fully implemented, it would offer grand jury capacity for “fewer than 10% of all referred felony cases.” Prior to 2015, they wrote, the court offered grand jury capacity for around 6,000 indictments per year.

Since then, the court has gradually reduced the amount of grand jury availability.

In his letter Thursday, Torrez asked Nakamura to direct the court to halt those planned cuts to the grand jury system as he makes his presentation to the BCCJCC.

Sidney Hill, a spokesman for the 2nd Judicial District Court, said in a statement Thursday that the court has worked with law enforcement and defense lawyers to “gradually increase the use of preliminary hearings in lieu of grand jury proceedings.”

He said the court agrees with Nakamura that developing methods for efficient use of system resources should be a collaborative process, and “we would welcome participation by the district attorney” in the coordinating council.

Entities within the Bernalillo County justice system have been sparring for months over the best way to launch new cases in District Court. Most cases are started in one of two ways: a grand jury proceeding before a group of citizens or a preliminary hearing before a judge. The jury or judge is tasked with determining whether there is probable cause to support formal charges.

In a grand jury hearing, the panel of citizens determines whether to sign off on an indictment based often on the testimony of a case agent during a secret and relatively short proceeding. A defendant is not present unless he or she is testifying. Torrez has said it is easier to charge via grand jury because they employ less strict evidence rules.

More witnesses — law enforcement officers and sometimes the crime victim — may testify in a preliminary hearing, which is like a mini trial. The defendant is present and represented by an attorney who can question witnesses and present evidence. Advocates say preliminary hearings often lead to earlier resolutions because they force parties to evaluate evidence early on.

Maggie Hart Stebbins, a Bernalillo County commissioner who also serves as chairwoman of the BCCJCC, said Thursday that the council is the appropriate place for this conversation.

“It’s a mechanism that was established specifically to bring all entities to the table to resolve issues that arise in the criminal justices system,” she said.

And Ben Baur, chief public defender, said the purpose of the council is to address these concerns. He has said that preliminary hearings are much more effective and efficient than grand juries.

“In the same way that preliminary hearings are designed for everybody to understand a particular case early in the process and make decisions, the coordinating council is designed so that people’s ideas and proposals get vetted and discussed early in the process,” he said.

A spokeswoman for the city of Albuquerque said that the city’s police department and the Keller administration have a “good working relationship” with District Court and will continue to work with justice partners to “come up with a reasonable solution that puts public safety first.”


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Half of city voters favor Keller's job performance
2021 city election
60% approval rating a year ago ... 60% approval rating a year ago likely due to pandemic response
2
Book merchant Jim Hoffsis was a pillar of Old ...
ABQnews Seeker
Korean War veteran was an admirer ... Korean War veteran was an admirer of military, supporter of local authors
3
Gonzales' current job approval stands at 34%
2021 city election
Democratic sheriff has little support from ... Democratic sheriff has little support from members of own party
4
NM film and television community honors Halyna Hutchins
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico's film and television community ... New Mexico's film and television community came together to remember cinematographer Halyna Hutchins at a candlelight vigil at Civic Plaza in Albuquerque on Saturday ...
5
Journal Poll: Keller has large lead over mayoral opponents
2021 city election
Gonzales, Aragon lag behind; runoff may ... Gonzales, Aragon lag behind; runoff may not be needed
6
Hours before showtime, Las Cruces High's band truck is ...
ABQnews Seeker
The Las Cruces High School Showcase ... The Las Cruces High School Showcase band's trip to Albuquerque this weekend started on a sour note. Hours before the Zia Marching Band Fiesta ...
7
Don't forget: 10-digit phone dialing to be required in ...
ABQnews Seeker
Starting Sunday, phone users across New ... Starting Sunday, phone users across New Mexico must include area codes when dialing to make all calls, including local calls that previously only required ...
8
States mostly defer to union guidance for on-set gun ...
ABQnews Seeker
Safety standards developed by film studios ... Safety standards developed by film studios and labor unions are the primary protection for actors and film crews when a scene calls for using ...
9
Vigil to be held at Civic Plaza for cinematographer
ABQnews Seeker
The New Mexico community will come ... The New Mexico community will come together to remember filmmaker Halyna Hutchins. The 42-year-old director of photography was killed on the set of 'Rust' ...