Unborn the last unprotected group - Albuquerque Journal

Unborn the last unprotected group

The debate over abortion, interrupted by a Supreme Court decision almost half a century ago, is finally beginning anew. And it will not go away until some sort of a national consensus is achieved. Some are attempting to achieve this consensus by articulating reasoning based on science and enumerated rights in the Constitution. A quick review of videos on the Internet confirms that others have not moved beyond yelling, bullying and outright violence. Since we know the latter will not result in consensus, let’s look at the science and enumerated rights.

The science is clear. The fetus is a human being. The standard medical text “Human Embryology and Teratology” states, “Although human life is a continuous process, fertilization is a critical landmark because, under ordinary circumstances, a new, genetically distinct human organism is formed.” The textbook “The Developing Human” states, “Human life begins at fertilization.” I could add 40 more references.

Abortion-rights author David Boonin in his book “A Defense of Abortion” acknowledges, “A human fetus after all is simply a human being at a very early stage of development.”

So, if the consensus is to be based on science and morality, the decision is simple. Taking an innocent human life is immoral. There is no justification. A child is not responsible for the circumstances for her conception, so rape, incest, poverty and being unwanted are not grounds for taking a human life. Likewise, mental illness or physical deformities are not justification for killing a human being.

But Roe v. Wade was not based on morality. Justice (Harry) Blackmun claimed to base it on the 14th Amendment to the Constitution. This created a sticky situation since the 14th Amendment explicitly states, “nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.” Justice Blackmun acknowledged this in Roe v. Wade when he wrote: “The (state of Texas) argue(s) that the fetus is a ‘person’ within the language and meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment. In support of this, they outline at length and in detail the well-known facts of fetal development. If this suggestion of personhood is established, (Jane Roe’s) case, of course, collapses, for the fetus’ right to life would then be guaranteed specifically by the Amendment.”

This – the question of personhood – is the core issue to be resolved in this debate over abortion. All other issues are used by one side or the other to distract from the central question. Based on the words of the author of the Roe v Wade decision, if the fetus is a person, then the fetus is protected in all circumstances by the 14th Amendment.

So, the question we need to resolve and reach a consensus on is actually very simple: We know a fetus is a human being, the question is: Are all human beings persons? And if not a person, what would this human being be?

History gives us some possible answers. In the infamous Dred Scott decision, the Supreme Court found a human being – a slave – to be property. During much of the early history of our country, owing to their non-person status, Native Americans were almost exterminated. But on issues of human rights, history says Americans eventually get it right. If we can agree that all humans are persons, we can resolve this divisive issue and finally bring protection to the last unprotected group – the unborn.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Unborn the last unprotected group


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Exhibition looks at works inspired by the vistas of ...
Arts
'New Beginnings: An American Story of ... 'New Beginnings: An American Story of Romantics and Modernists in the West' showcases 127 works created from the late 1800-1900s at the Harwood Museum ...
2
The Complete Works of Shakespeare (Abrig'd) hits Albuquerque Little ...
Arts
'The Complete Works of William Shakespeare ... 'The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (Abrig'd)' returns to the Albuquerque Little Theatre at 224 San Pasquale Ave. SW.
3
Taos Abstract Artist Collective debuts inaugural exhibition
Arts
The group will show its first ... The group will show its first exhibition from Sept. 2-10 at the Stables Gallery at the Taos Center for the Arts.
4
Guild Cinema screening short film inspired by '90s horror ...
Arts
'Quiet Hours' will screen at the ... 'Quiet Hours' will screen at the Guild Cinema at 1 p.m. Sunday, Aug. 21.
5
Pulling out weeds by the root key to keeping ...
Arts
Bindweed and common purslane spotting in ... Bindweed and common purslane spotting in ABQ backyard
6
Visit Las Cruces puts out a call for artist(s) ...
Arts
Visit Las Cruces is looking for ... Visit Las Cruces is looking for an artist or artist group to submit proposals for the design and installation of a permanent exterior mural.
7
'Eyeshine' showing at Harwood with 'Holy Land' through Sept. ...
Arts
Adrian Pijoan will show his work ... Adrian Pijoan will show his work at the Harwood Art Center through Sept. 15. Organizers paired his work with 'Holy Land' by Diego Medina.
8
Caja del Rio is teeming with wide open spaces ...
Arts
Covering more than 104,000 acres, Caja ... Covering more than 104,000 acres, Caja del Rio is rife with history.
9
Man Ray muse takes center stage in biography
Arts
Her name was Alice Prin, but ... Her name was Alice Prin, but she was better known in the bohemian world of 1920s Paris as Kiki de Montparnasse