Lawyer calls court an eviction machine - Albuquerque Journal

Lawyer calls court an eviction machine

The first time I went to Bernalillo County Metropolitan Court to watch an eviction proceeding, in the summer of 2015, I left feeling numb. I had just arrived in Albuquerque from New York City, where I had been a tenant attorney for the previous decade, and I was hoping to get a sense of how landlord-tenant disputes were adjudicated in preparation for my work in UNM School of Law’s Clinical Program.

What I saw in the courtrooms I visited that day – rapid-fire, unrecorded hearings in which unrepresented tenants were presumed to be some combination of lazy, unreliable and untrustworthy – left me with the impression that Metro Court was not a place where tenants had any real chance of being heard, much less of achieving justice.

Fast forward several years, and I wasn’t surprised to learn that a Metro Court judge, Daniel Ramczyk, is being sued by the ACLU for refusing a hearing-impaired tenant’s lawful request for an American Sign Language interpreter. According to the transcript of the hearing, after finding for the landlord in the case, Ramczyk called the tenant an “obstructionist” who came to his courtroom to “cause trouble.”

While Ramczyk’s behavior is appalling, it would be a mistake to view it as an outlier, as it is in fact representative of the treatment meted out to poor and working people who walk through the doors of Metro Court every day seeking a fair hearing.

Tenants appearing before the three Metro Court judges who handle eviction cases have virtually no shot at prevailing. In fact, they are barely given the opportunity to assert defenses and are regularly treated with contempt by the judges charged with impartially deciding their cases.

In a typical eviction hearing, a judge uses a prefabricated script to walk a landlord through the elements of their case, often without eliciting any sworn testimony or evidence to substantiate a claim. Then, the same judge turns to the tenant and asks – in an open-ended way – if they have anything to add. Rarely do judges ask questions regarding the conditions of an apartment or other circumstances that might defeat a landlord’s claim.

In other words, landlords are directed by the court toward their goals – a money judgment and/or an eviction – while tenants are left grasping to mount a defense. All of this takes place in the span of around three minutes, a strikingly short amount of time considering all that is at stake for a tenant who is being evicted – finding a new home on short notice, the loss of longstanding community ties, having to relocate children to a new school.

After a couple of years representing tenants in Metro Court eviction proceedings, I found myself struggling with how to discuss the court with students, most of whom came to law school with the belief that our legal system is anchored in the rule of law and basic standards of fairness. Many of my students walked away from Metro Court completely flabbergasted, questioning the legitimacy of what they had seen. After a morning spent observing eviction proceedings, one student memorably commented that they had seen more due process at the MVD.

The recent incident involving Judge Ramczyk should be closely scrutinized, but it should not be exceptionalized. Anyone with a moral compass should have grave concerns about how eviction proceedings are carried out in Metro Court. The problems in Metro Court go well beyond a single judge and require an examination of the ways in which the court systematically disadvantages poor and vulnerable people.

Metro Court, as it currently functions, is little more than an eviction machine. It is well past time for that to change.

John Whitlow is a tenant attorney and law professor at the City University of New York School of Law. From 2015-18, he taught at UNM School of Law.

 


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Exhaustion in the ICU: Doctors reflect on state's nearly ...
From the newspaper
New Mexicans urged to get vaccinated, ... New Mexicans urged to get vaccinated, wear masks indoors
2
Half of city voters favor Keller's job performance
2021 city election
60% approval rating a year ago ... 60% approval rating a year ago likely due to pandemic response
3
TOP OF MIND: Should schoolchildren be required to be ...
From the newspaper
This week's question: Should children 5 ... This week's question: Should children 5 and older be required to have COVID-19 vaccinations, along with other required immunizations, to attend public schools in ...
4
Taos hosts its 38th micro balloon event
From the newspaper
Views of the 'spectacular' Rio Grande ... Views of the 'spectacular' Rio Grande Gorge and nearby mountains are a draw
5
'Nova' series tells the story of the universe from ...
Arts
Chris Schmidt is no stranger to ... Chris Schmidt is no stranger to making films about science and space.He's made a caree ...
6
Tarantulas: Listening for love
Education
Dozens join guided tour seeking much-maligned ... Dozens join guided tour seeking much-maligned arachnids
7
Anita Hill urges us all to battle gender violence
Arts
Anita Hill didn't care if President ... Anita Hill didn't care if President Joe Biden apologized or not, but she found his aversion to doing ...
8
North Sports: Week in Review
Boys' Soccer
A look back at the top ... A look back at the top sporting stories, and scores, in northern New Mexico
9
Xeric Garden Club to host event
Arts
Xeric Garden Club of Albuquerque will ... Xeric Garden Club of Albuquerque will host a presentation by George Duda, a founding member of Think ...