Federal judge strikes down ABQ panhandling law - Albuquerque Journal

Federal judge strikes down ABQ panhandling law

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

A federal judge has ruled that an Albuquerque ordinance severely restricting panhandling is unconstitutional, a decision the American Civil Liberties Union of New Mexico is hailing as a “significant victory.”

Judge Robert Brack of U.S. District Court in Albuquerque on Thursday issued a 37-page opinion in the ACLU’s 2018 lawsuit against the city. Brack wrote that most of the Pedestrian Safety Ordinance, passed in 2017 and amended last month, is “an unconstitutional restriction on free speech because it is not narrowly tailored to meet the City’s interest in reducing pedestrian-vehicle conflicts.”

The ordinance, sponsored by City Councilor Trudy Jones, bars anyone from standing inside travel lanes, along interstate entrance and exit ramps and on certain medians. It also prohibits “any physical interaction or exchange” between pedestrians and occupants of vehicles in traffic lanes.

The ACLU and the Goodwin Procter law firm represented four plaintiffs in the case: Rhonda Brewer, a homeless woman who regularly seeks donations from medians or near freeway entrances; Mary O’Grady and David McCoy, who hand out donations from their vehicles; and Marissa Elyse Sanchez, who has distributed fliers and other material to motorists stopped at red lights.

Leon Howard, legal director for ACLU New Mexico, celebrated Brack’s decision in a written statement Friday morning.

“This is a significant victory, not just for free speech, but basic fairness and human compassion,” he said. “These types of unconstitutional laws not only erode the right to express oneself in public places, but endlessly cycle those on the margins of society in and out of the criminal justice system.”

The ordinance, which went into effect in December 2017, never fully took root.

The plaintiffs filed suit the following month, and the city agreed not to enforce the law pending the outcome of the case.

But the City Council voted 8-1 last month to pass an amended version with an eye toward resuming enforcement if the city prevailed in the case.

The matter was supposed to go to trial next month, but Brack called off the trial in his opinion.

He instead decided to grant partial summary judgment to the plaintiffs, agreeing that most subsections of the ordinance violated the First Amendment.

The judge did, however, write that the ordinance’s ban on people standing in traffic lanes was a “valid restriction” and agreed with the city’s arguments that the ordinance is “content neutral” and addresses a significant government interest.

“In sum, pedestrian safety is a concern and a valid government interest in Albuquerque. Pedestrians who choose to stand, seek donations, or hand out leaflets in any area where increased physical proximity to vehicles benefits their expressive activity may be taking on more risk than individuals who choose to do so from the sidewalk,” Brack wrote. “Still, prohibiting all access to these spaces on the grounds that Albuquerque struggles with troublingly high rates of pedestrian-vehicle conflicts, without presenting any evidence beyond anecdotal and personal speculation that the ban would actually reduce the number of such conflicts in the City and that less sweeping restrictions would not suffice, runs afoul of the First Amendment.”

Jones called the opinion “disappointing” but noted that Brack upheld part of the ordinance.

“If there’s anything I can do, I would like to appeal, or write a better ordinance or whatever it takes to see if we can stop this unsafe condition,” she said Friday.

A spokeswoman for Mayor Tim Keller’s office said the city has not decided whether to appeal but indicated in a statement that the administration was ready to move on.

“The legal reality is now clear,” spokeswoman Jessie Damazyn said in a written statement. “We are ready to support new City Council efforts to keep our streets safe and reduce pedestrian injuries associated with chronic panhandling.”

Keller has said combating homelessness is one of his priorities. The city recently extended operations at its West Side homeless shelter, keeping what has been a winter-only facility open year-round. The city is also seeking $14 million in this fall’s general obligation bond election to develop a new, 24/7 shelter in a more central location.

Howard of the ACLU said the city should keep looking for ways other than the Pedestrian Safety Ordinance to tackle the problems.

“They’re not going to cite their way out of any poverty issue, and they’re certainly not going to criminalize their way out of the poverty issue,” he said in an interview. “We’d like to see the city continue to focus on those things and not target people on the fringes, and certainly we don’t want to see them doing anything that restricts First Amendment rights.”

Home » News » Albuquerque News » Federal judge strikes down ABQ panhandling law


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
New Mexico inks trust land leases for massive wind ...
ABQnews Seeker
New Mexico's public land commissioner on ... New Mexico's public land commissioner on Monday signed nearly a dozen leases that will clear the way for a major renewable energy developer to ...
2
Details emerge in Sunday shootings after more video is ...
ABQnews Seeker
Police say a man who is ... Police say a man who is suspected of killing his wife may have killed himself. They initially had charged the couple's son in the ...
3
Retired teachers can now return to classroom, keep retirement
ABQnews Seeker
Enticing retired teachers to come back ... Enticing retired teachers to come back may be an answer to New Mexico's teacher shortages — or at least that's what lawmakers hope with ...
4
Official: Upgrades urged at Amtrak crash site, but no ...
ABQnews Seeker
The chief elected official in the ... The chief elected official in the Missouri county where an Amtrak train slammed into a dump truck said Tuesday that residents and county leaders ...
5
Albuquerque redistricting committee to take final vote
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque's citizen redistricting committee is slated ... Albuquerque's citizen redistricting committee is slated to take its final vote Wednesday, deciding what it thinks is the best way to reshape the city's ...
6
Teen charged in shooting threat at Edgewood school
ABQnews Seeker
A 17-year-old allegedly threatened to shoot ... A 17-year-old allegedly threatened to shoot up a school earlier this month in Edgewood. State Police spokeswoman Candace Hopkins said Emma Haviland, of Edgewood, ...
7
TOP OF MIND: What do you think of the ...
ABQnews Seeker
Click here to tell us: ... Click here to tell us: What do you think of the governor's opposition to bringing migrants to N.M. at this time? Responses must ...
8
APD creates unit to target road rage, aggressive driving
ABQnews Seeker
with a way for the public ... with a way for the public to submit evidence — as detectives search for the shooters in two recent road-rage incidents on Interstate 40. ...
9
Woman charged in 2020 ABQ homicide
ABQnews Seeker
Detectives arrested a woman for her ... Detectives arrested a woman for her alleged role in the fatal shooting of a man in 2020 outside an apartment complex on West Central. ...