Court affirms that prison settlements are public records - Albuquerque Journal

Court affirms that prison settlements are public records

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

The state Court of Appeals has upheld a judge’s decision that settlement agreements reached between a prison health care contractor and its patients are public documents subject to disclosure under New Mexico’s public records law.

Open government advocates celebrated the decision, calling it a victory that “will help all of us for years to come.”

“The Appeals Court decision reaffirms the two key holdings from the district court: that settlement documents are public records and that private entities performing a public function for a public agency are subject to (the Inspection of Public Records Act),” the Foundation for Open Government wrote in a news release Tuesday afternoon.

The opinion comes more than three years after the Albuquerque Journal, Santa Fe New Mexican and FOG submitted written requests to the New Mexico Corrections Department for settlement documents involving Corizon Health.

In June 2016, the company settled claims filed by 59 inmates at two prisons for nearly $4.6 million, and many of those payouts appeared to be related to a physician accused of sexually abusing inmates. At the time, Corizon was paid $37 million a year to provide inmate medical services at 10 New Mexico facilities.

But the Corrections Department said that it did not have any responsive documents and that under the terms of its contract with Corizon, the department would not be involved in lawsuits alleging improper or unconstitutional care.

The same requests were then sent to Corizon, which provided a table listing settlement amounts and the facility involved. But the company ultimately sent a letter saying that IPRA did not require the release of the settlements and that confidentiality agreements would prohibit their disclosure.

A spokeswoman for Corizon Health said Tuesday that the company “received the ruling today” and is “reviewing it and considering our options.”

The newspapers and FOG argued that Corizon, as a private entity acting on behalf of a public body, was subject to the state’s open records laws. The District Court agreed and ordered Corizon to produce the settlements. Corizon appealed that decision.

In an opinion filed Monday, Judges Miles Hanisee, Linda Vanzi and Richard Bosson affirmed the District Court decision. They found that the agreements were created as a result of Corizon’s public functions on behalf of the state Department of Corrections and that they involve the alleged mistreatment of inmates who were in the state’s custody. The decision also points to a section of IPRA that says people are entitled “to the greatest possible information regarding the affairs of government” and notes that the court has previously found that settlements resulting from claims involving allegations of sexual abuse in detention centers are subject to release.

Allowing private entities that contract with the state to circumvent public access laws would thwart the purpose of IPRA, the opinion said.

The Court of Appeals also determined that the district judge properly awarded attorneys fees. According to FOG, the District Court decision found that Corizon had to pay around $37,000 in attorneys’ fees to attorneys Daniel Yohalem and Katharine Murray, who represented the organizations that sought the records.

Home » News » Crime » Court affirms that prison settlements are public records

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
'Jesús Muñoz Flamenco: En Cabaret' being staged throughout June
ABQnews Seeker
"Jesús Muñoz Flamenco: En Cabaret" is ... "Jesús Muñoz Flamenco: En Cabaret" is being staged at 7:30 p.m. Friday, June 9, and Saturday, June 10, and at 2 p.m. June 11.
Summerfest, Mustangs, movies and more: 7 events for this ...
ABQnews Seeker
In 1964, the Ford Motor Company ... In 1964, the Ford Motor Company began production of its Mustang and an American icon was born. If you’re a fan of this classic car, ...
Former Ruidoso officer convicted of soliciting a minor
ABQnews Seeker
Prosecutors said a former Ruidoso police ... Prosecutors said a former Ruidoso police officer Wednesday was convicted of two felonies after requesting sexual pictures and videos from a federal agent posing ...
Homegrown Albuquerque company Karoo Health launches digital platform for ...
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque-based startup Karoo Health will deploy ... Albuquerque-based startup Karoo Health will deploy a new digital platform this summer for real-time management of cardiovascular health care, backed by $3.4 million in ...
Jerry Pacheco: Title 42 ironies abound; better laws needed
ABQnews Seeker
Title 42, the health policy that ... Title 42, the health policy that allowed U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) to quickly expel migrants who illegally entered the U.S. seeking amnesty, ...
Albuquerque police looking for car involved in Downtown homicide
ABQnews Seeker
The Albuquerque Police Department is asking ... The Albuquerque Police Department is asking the public's help in finding a car believed to have been involved in a homicide in Downtown late ...
The stage is set: ‘La Traviata’ to kick off ...
ABQnews Seeker
New productions of 'Don Giovanni,' 'La ... New productions of 'Don Giovanni,' 'La Traviata' and 'Der Rosenkavalier,' and a revival of 'The Elixir of Love,' cap a 2024 Santa Fe Opera ...
Job Talk: 'I'm done': Finding a new career without ...
ABQnews Seeker
Dear J.T. & Dale: I no ... Dear J.T. & Dale: I no longer want to be a nurse. I tried to stick it out after the pandemic, but I'm done.
Isotopes manager Lopez can toast to a career milestone
ABQnews Seeker
Veteran manager gets 1,000th career victory ... Veteran manager gets 1,000th career victory with the Isotopes on Sunday, days after getting loss 1,000 as well.