Judge lets murder charges stand despite SFPD losing evidence - Albuquerque Journal

Judge lets murder charges stand despite SFPD losing evidence

SANTA FE — A Santa Fe District Court judge on Friday denied a defense motion to dismiss a murder case, despite the Santa Fe Police Department losing evidence.

The ruling came after a crime scene technician who did an independent audit of evidence in the case testified that the SFPD didn’t adhere to its own policies regarding the safekeeping of the evidence.

Em092719b
Robert Valencia, grandfather of homicide victim Selena Valencia, and others protest outside the Santa Fe County courthouse during a hearing for murder defendant Christopher Garcia. Protesters were concerned about the police losing evidence in the case, but a judge ruled against dismissing Garcia’s charges over the evidence issue. (Eddie Moore/ Albuquerque Journal)

Christopher Garcia, 28, is charged with first-degree murder, aggravated battery, aggravated burglary and tampering with evidence. He’s accused of stabbing to death 21-year-old Selena Valencia, his live-in girlfriend, at a southside apartment complex in June 2017.

Garcia also allegedly beat a man after breaking into his apartment and stabbing another man outside the apartment complex.

In late June, Paul Joye, who was recently promoted to Deputy Chief of operations at the SFPD, sent a letter to Santa Fe Deputy District Attorney Todd Bullion saying the department lost 11 pieces of evidence, including trace hair that was found on Valencia’s body as well as some of her fingernail clippings.

As a result, Garcia’s attorney, Jennifer Burrill, filed a motion to have the case dismissed. She argued that the fingernail clippings could have shown that she was struggling with someone other than Garcia before her death.

Judge Mary Marlowe Sommer denied the dismissal motion Friday, but not before hearing from Santa Fe County Sheriff’s Office crime scene technician Shari Vialpando, who conducted the court-ordered audit of all of SFPD’s evidence in the case.

Vialpando said there was a lack of consistency in keeping track of the chain of custody of certain evidence and that some pieces of evidence were labeled with the wrong case numbers.

“I do not believe they (SFPD) adhered to the policies they set forth,” Vialpando said on the witness stand.

Vialpando also said some envelopes containing evidence were unsealed, but she couldn’t say for sure if the contents were contaminated.

“I think the integrity of the evidence has been compromised,” she said. “I can’t say if it has been compromised.”

Although Marlowe Sommer didn’t grant the motion to dismiss, she did say the missing evidence can be addressed in instructions to the jury at trial. The trial is scheduled to begin Oct. 21.


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Halyna Hutchins remembered as a gifted cinematographer
ABQnews Seeker
Ukrainian native called herself a 'restless ... Ukrainian native called herself a 'restless dreamer' and 'adrenaline junkie'
2
APS bus drivers get a pay boost amid ongoing ...
ABQnews Seeker
Board of Education OKs hiring, referral ... Board of Education OKs hiring, referral bonuses as rate reaches $18 per hour
3
City: Official not drunk in accident
ABQnews Seeker
Allegation was made by Gonzales against ... Allegation was made by Gonzales against COO in mayoral debate with Keller
4
Las Cruces educator named NM Teacher of the Year
ABQnews Seeker
Lorynn Guerrero will represent New Mexico ... Lorynn Guerrero will represent New Mexico in the national competition
5
Albuquerque's outdoors access lands it on a good list
ABQnews Seeker
Outside Magazine named Albuquerque one of ... Outside Magazine named Albuquerque one of its 20 top cities and towns to live in on its annual list.
6
Search warrant, 911 calls detail deadly incident on movie ...
ABQnews Seeker
Actor, producer Alec Baldwin shocked and ... Actor, producer Alec Baldwin shocked and saddened at tragic incident that left colleague dead
7
Governor to tout public works deal in DC visit
ABQnews Seeker
Lujan Grisham to visit the White ... Lujan Grisham to visit the White House, meet with congressional leaders
8
State GOP, district attorney settle records lawsuit
ABQnews Seeker
At issue was information focused on ... At issue was information focused on vandalism at party headquarters
9
Booster shots cleared for more NM adults
ABQnews Seeker
Getting first doses to the unvaccinated ... Getting first doses to the unvaccinated is, however, a priority