Learn from Yazzie/Martinez, lotto scholarship to implement free college - Albuquerque Journal

Learn from Yazzie/Martinez, lotto scholarship to implement free college

We applaud and support Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham’s proposal to use the budget surplus to pay college tuition costs for all N.M. residents. Using a relatively modest amount of our state’s fiscal capital to invest in the human capital of our youth will bring us dividends far into the future. This is both bold and prudent. Kudos, Gov. MLG.

We are a group of progressive educators from different backgrounds and disciplines. We have been involved in opening doors for underrepresented students, developing academic success programs, mentoring students and feeling the pride and joy that comes from seeing students succeed despite high barriers and go on to provide leadership for New Mexico. The governor’s big idea can be bigger and bolder.

Conservative forces predictably argue we can’t afford this program, but this plan has a modest price tag in the range of $25 million to $35 million for 55,000 students. A carefully designed program will not exacerbate and compound other problems, such as high levels of racial stratification and economic inequality. According to the 2019 N.M. Kids Count report, 20% of Hispanic families and 29% of Native American families live in poverty compared to 7.5% of white families. Moreover, in 2016 New Mexico had higher income inequality than 38 other states; inequality correlates with higher unemployment, lower education achievement, worse health outcomes, greater parental stress, etc.

Watch the cost go up and graduates leave if college is ‘free’

To effectively address New Mexico’s interlocking problems, this free-tuition idea can avoid regrettable results if we learn from the Yazzie-Martinez litigation and the Lottery Scholarship outcome data.

Yazzie-Martinez established that New Mexico has underperforming schools, which impede students from graduating with the knowledge and skills they need to succeed in K-12 and post-secondary studies. We urge a holistic approach, one that meets the students’ intersectional needs by providing racially, ethnically, tribally, linguistically and culturally appropriate curricula and academic support programs to bolster their academic readiness and performance.

The Lottery Scholarship outcomes warn that free college tuition will disproportionately benefit families with the highest income. According to Voices for Children, one in three Lottery Scholarship dollars go to first-time scholarship recipients with family incomes above $90,000; that is the top 15% income group.

Postsecondary attainment is not a magic bullet, but it is an important factor in economic mobility. New Mexico’s economic mobility ranks very low compared to other states, especially for indigenous communities. However, data show UNM has moderate success, i.e., its success rates are typical for schools in the Mountain West, for moving low-income students into higher-income levels. According to 2017 data, 19% of UNM students moved up two or more income quintiles.

Harvard economist David Deming concludes that the design of such plans matters, positing that the goal should be college completion with a focus on rural and first-generation college students, robust academic support, and stable funding with prudent regulation. As the Legislature moves forward, it can draw on the expertise of its educators, school teachers, community college and university professors, and community activists who have long been working to create educational success for N.M. students. One promising funding model is called the “first-dollar approach,” which leverages federal funds like Pell Grants to help families meet full costs. Such an approach uses state money to cover tuition first so that other financial aid can cover the 52% of college costs beyond tuition and fees.

We are eager to welcome and mentor those students who are presently excluded from the benefits of higher education because of tuition and related expenses. Increasing the number of well-educated workers, leaders, parents and citizens is the best investment New Mexico can make with its budget surplus.

This op-ed is also signed by Nancy López, professor of sociology, director of the Institute for the Study of “Race” and Social Justice; Marc-Tizoc González, law professor; Kiran Katira, director of the Community Engagement Center; Lisa Cacari Stone, associate Professor of Health and Social Policy and TREE Center director; Dr. Brenda Pereda, associate professor of medicine, Department of ObGyn and assistant dean for Diversity and Inclusion; and Christine Zuni Cruz, Regents’ professor of law.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Learn from Yazzie/Martinez, lotto scholarship to implement free college

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Editorial: NM can’t afford to go backward on government ...
From the Editorial Board: The Inspection ... From the Editorial Board: The Inspection of Public Records Act has a presumption that citizens are entitled to the greatest possible amount of information ...
We need to enact omnibus crime and gun law ...
From the newspaper
OPINION: State's violent crime rate needs ... OPINION: State's violent crime rate needs the 1-2 punch of an omnibus bill focused on harsher penalties and gun-control measures.
Tribal Remedy Framework addresses systemic inequities
From the newspaper
OPINION: Lawmakers should support tribal approach ... OPINION: Lawmakers should support tribal approach to improve educational outcomes for Native youth.
Dollars alone won't solve New Mexico's problems
From the newspaper
OPINION: The current system of distributing ... OPINION: The current system of distributing capital outlay funds needs an overhaul if we want those dollars to do the most good.
Medicaid provider procurement process canceled
From the newspaper
HSD says decision made after departures ... HSD says decision made after departures of Secretary Scrase and Medicaid Director Nicole Comeaux
'It's been a great ride': Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive ...
ABQnews Seeker
Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive director is ... Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive director is retiring
Prep football: Lee to take over at Albuquerque Academy
Featured Sports
The architect of Hope Christian's state ... The architect of Hope Christian's state championship defense in 2019, and the man who put together Albuquerque Academy's stellar defense the last two years, ...
Prep notes: Gary Bradley to continue family tradition at ...
Featured Sports
From father to son to brother, ... From father to son to brother, the Bradley family football tradition will continue at Mayfield High ...
It's a slow(er) week, but there's no resting for ...
The calendar would tell you the ... The calendar would tell you the workload for the UNM basketball team this week is a light one. ...