Medical damages debate hits NM Supreme Court - Albuquerque Journal

Medical damages debate hits NM Supreme Court

Lisa Curtis

Copyright © 2019 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – Attorneys clashed before the state Supreme Court on Wednesday over the legality of a New Mexico law limiting medical malpractice damages.

In a 60-minute hearing, the state’s justices skeptically questioned both sides in a case that could shape the legal landscape for physicians accused of wrongdoing.

The argument centered on whether the state Legislature exceeded its constitutional authority by imposing a $600,000 cap on compensatory damages for lost wages, pain and suffering in the Medical Malpractice Act. The limit doesn’t apply to medical costs.

State District Judge Victor Lopez ruled in 2018 that the cap improperly interfered with a plaintiff’s constitutional right to a jury verdict.

The case involves a Placitas woman, Susan Siebert, who alleged she was hospitalized for months after suffering injuries during a gynecological procedure, according to court records.

After a jury trial, Siebert won a $2.6 million judgment. Judge Lopez later denied a motion by the defendants to limit the payout to caps outlined in the Medical Malpractice Act, ruling it would violate the plaintiff’s rights.

Lisa Curtis, an attorney for Siebert, told the state Supreme Court on Wednesday that limiting the damages would “eviscerate” the plaintiff’s right to have a jury decide her case. Allowing for damages beyond the cap also serves as a deterrent to wrongdoing by doctors, she said.

“When you put a cap on death or catastrophic injury,” Curtis said, “you attract poor medical care” to New Mexico.

Bennett Cooper, an attorney for defendants Rebecca Okun and Women’s Specialists of New Mexico, said the cap can’t be stripped from the larger Medical Malpractice Act. The law works as a whole, he said, to ensure that physicians can find medical malpractice insurance in New Mexico, while also ensuring that patients who are harmed can get continuing care.

It’s the role of the Legislature, not the court, to change the damage limit if necessary, Cooper said.

Senior Justice Barbara Vigil highlighted that theme in her questioning of Curtis. She asked whether arguments over the propriety of a cap are more appropriate for state lawmakers.

“Wouldn’t we be legislating if we followed your reasoning?” she asked Curtis.

Curtis herself is a former state senator.

Justice Shannon Bacon suggested it’s within the Supreme Court’s purview to decide on the caps. Court decisions on similar laws in other states have been split, she said.

“It’s a close call,” Bacon said of the outcome in other states.

The court didn’t issue a decision in the case Wednesday.

The case is being closely watched by medical groups and others who say the legal environment in New Mexico plays a role in recruiting physicians.

Home » Journal North » Journal North Recent News » Medical damages debate hits NM Supreme Court


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Democratic Sen. Kyrsten Sinema switches to independent
ABQnews Seeker
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Democratic Sen. Kyrsten ... WASHINGTON (AP) -- Democratic Sen. Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona announced Friday she has registered as an independent, a renegade move that could bolster her ...
2
Katy Duhigg in line to lead Rules Committee
ABQnews Seeker
She will fill a vacancy created ... She will fill a vacancy created with Sen. Daniel Ivey-Soto gave up the post
3
Albuquerque Little Theatre brings 'A Tuna Christmas' to stage
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Little Theatre gets in the ... Albuquerque Little Theatre gets in the holiday spirit with "A Tuna Christmas."The prod ...
4
Lawmakers discuss new oversight for NM prisons
ABQnews Seeker
Hefty legal settlements over past year ... Hefty legal settlements over past year draw attention, calls for action
5
'Our new Santa': Good Samaritan gifts bike after clothing ...
ABQnews Seeker
Crime occurred Tuesday night at Northeast ... Crime occurred Tuesday night at Northeast Albuquerque nonprofit
6
Fifth-year senior 'Uncle Mo' Udeze mentors his Lobo freshmen ...
ABQnews Seeker
'He’s definitely the big dog in ... 'He’s definitely the big dog in the house,' says one roomie Donovan Dent
7
Inmates train pups that don't get adopted
ABQnews Seeker
The program is a win-win solution ... The program is a win-win solution for both humans and canines
8
Public weighs in on Mayor Tim Keller’s sweeping zoning ...
ABQnews Seeker
The legislation seeks to grow the ... The legislation seeks to grow the city’s housing stock with development ordinance amendments enabling greater density
9
$117 million grant expected to expand high-speed internet across ...
ABQnews Seeker
'We don't want to miss any ... 'We don't want to miss any opportunity,' Gov. Lujan Grisham said.