As Space Force lifts off, hurt service members grounded - Albuquerque Journal

As Space Force lifts off, hurt service members grounded

In the quiet of the Friday before Christmas, President Trump signed the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) into law. Of the many provisions in this whopping $738 billion bill, Trump is most proud of the creation of his Space Force. In his remarks at the signing ceremony, he crowned it a “landmark achievement.”

This jubilation ignores a big problem. Even if the Space Force results in Trump’s desired “American superiority in space,” the NDAA leaves service members on Earth behind.

As Trump touted in his remarks, the Space Force is the first new military branch in over 70 years. The most recently created branch – the Air Force – was formed in 1947. What Trump didn’t mention, though, is that it has also been 70 years since service members had the right to sue the Defense Department for serious injuries. The NDAA doesn’t fix that.

Since 1950, a widely criticized Supreme Court decision known as “Feres” has prohibited tort suits by service members against the Defense Department. The Supreme Court issued this ban tentatively, admitting it had “few guiding materials.” It assured itself that if its opinion is wrong, “at least Congress possesses a ready remedy.”

Congress, however, has sat silent for the 70 years since Feres. This has left victims of military medical malpractice, sexual assault and other grievous harms with little recourse. And left the Defense Department with little accountability.

A bill that would have removed the Feres bar for medical malpractice cases was initially included in this year’s NDAA. But despite the dogged advocacy of the bill’s author, Rep. Jackie Speier, and the bill’s namesake, Sgt. First Class Richard Stayskal, a Green Beret with cancer stemming from medical negligence, this provision was ultimately tossed.

The bill passed the House only for Sen. Lindsey Graham to kill it in the Senate. He objected that exposing the Defense Department to liability would “open Pandora’s box.” He had little to say to defend Feres as a legal matter, though. Or about Defense Department accountability.

This missed opportunity to restore service members’ access to justice makes the 2020 NDAA a disappointment.

To give credit where credit is due, the NDAA does contain some provisions that will benefit service members. For instance, for the first time service members will be able to file administrative claims with the Defense Department for compensation for medical malpractice. No doubt, military families hurt by medical negligence deserve these awards. The NDAA also includes important military sexual assault reforms. Under the new law, special victims’ counsel will be available to domestic violence victims and will receive training on civilian criminal law.

The problem is these reforms only kick in once the damage has already been done. Medical malpractice compensation softens the blow of lost earnings. It doesn’t stop the injury from happening in the first place. Indeed, with some limits on awards the military might not feel the pinch strongly enough for there to be deterrence of future harms. Likewise, increased availability and training of special victims’ counsel helps assault survivors navigate the military justice system. But it doesn’t prevent rape or abuse.

For there to be a real sea change, service members need the right to sue. To hold the Defense Department accountable for medical negligence and its sexual assault epidemic, we need independent adjudicators. In reviewing service members’ medical malpractice claims, as the NDAA allows, the Defense Department is susceptible to motives of self-preservation. The courts, in contrast, have no skin in the game. And they aren’t afraid to demand the big structural changes that are sometimes necessary to protect individuals’ rights.

If Trump can take the military to the moon, we should be able to get service members through the courthouse doors. Congress should stop politicking, … face the Feres doctrine’s harms and heed the Supreme Court’s plea for intervention. At 70 years and counting, a congressional fix is way overdue.

Rose Carmen Goldberg represented veterans at Swords to Plowshares, a rights organization.


Home » Opinion » Columnists » As Space Force lifts off, hurt service members grounded

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

Busy thieves threaten licenses, steal pandemic relief
Anyone who is licensed by the ... Anyone who is licensed by the state - barbers, counselors, cannabis producers, etc. - has ...
ABQ has great, free resources to help you find ...
Do you know your family history? ... Do you know your family history? Where did they live? Did family members serve in the military? What ...
Journal Cartoonist John Trever's recent work
John Trever tackles Albuquerque and New ... John Trever tackles Albuquerque and New Mexico issues with his signature cartoons this and every Sunday.
Teens are targets of 'sextortion,' FBI warns
The FBI and a national parents' ... The FBI and a national parents' group are warning of an alarming rise in sextortion cases in w ...
COVID-19 treatments and medications
Sources: Who's at high risk for ... Sources: Who's at high risk for serious COVID-19? ...
Personal to me, Jose Armas' death felt across NM
One of the blessings about returning ... One of the blessings about returning to New Mexico was that it put me back in touch with Jose Armas. ...
Thieves take so much more than your cash
Being victimized can cause trauma, and ... Being victimized can cause trauma, and has nothing to do with your 'intelligence or common sense'
Tips for keeping you and your energy bills cool ...
It is hot outside. According to ... It is hot outside. According to PNM, demand for electricity is highest during the summer cooling sea ...
A new community hub for the South Valley
Social Enterprise Center brings new approach ... Social Enterprise Center brings new approach to economic development