BLM's Carlsbad plan must balance oil and wildlife - Albuquerque Journal

BLM’s Carlsbad plan must balance oil and wildlife

The landscape of Southeast New Mexico has been my home since I was born in Roswell in 1966. I’ve spent my life enjoying the outdoors on vast public lands containing a diverse population of wildlife species, but it is increasingly dominated by oil and gas development. While there are economic benefits to energy development, it also fragments important habitat and wildlife corridors, which puts further stress on already struggling wildlife populations. The Bureau of Land Management is preparing to release a Resource Management Plan (RMP) for the Carlsbad area and I am concerned that it will not do enough to safeguard the hunting traditions I hold dear.

The plan has been in development since 2011 and will determine how the Carlsbad field office manages more than 6.2 million acres for the next 20 years. In one of the busiest oil and gas regions in the western United States, the BLM wants to make nearly 97% of the planning area available to oil and gas leasing. That makes it impossible to protect key wildlife habitat and conserve big game wildlife migration.

Southeast New Mexico holds key habitat for pronghorn, deer and a variety of upland game birds, and that habitat has been increasingly stressed by energy development. The N.M. Department of Game and Fish identified this region as a priority area for deer and pronghorn habitat under the Interior Department’s own Secretarial Order 3362, so it is surprising and disappointing the plan does not do more to conserve New Mexicans’ natural heritage. Interior Secretary David Bernhardt has been an outspoken supporter of wildlife corridors, but neither he nor others at Interior or BLM appear interested in protecting wildlife in southeast New Mexico.

The Carlsbad plan fails to include protections for lands with wilderness characteristics and fails to designate proposed Areas of Critical Environmental Concern, including those that would specifically protect birds of prey and desert rivers.

The BLM is required by law and policy to inventory public lands for wilderness characteristics and consider protectively managing them in Resource Management Plans. The BLM has identified 66,666 acres of lands with wilderness characteristics in the Carlsbad Field Office, but protects only 5,119 acres in its Preferred Alternative.

Similarly, BLM is supposed to designate Areas of Critical Environmental Concern where special management attention is needed to protect important fish, wildlife and other natural resources, and historical, cultural and scenic values, but the Preferred Alternative includes less than 20% of the acreage that wildlife advocates recommended to protect wildlife, migratory birds and rare plants.

The final RMP should protect all lands with wilderness characteristics and areas of environmental concern to safeguard some of the last untouched places in the heavily developed Permian Basin for wildlife and ensure these continue to provide quality backcountry recreation and wilderness experiences for future generations.

Given the unprecedented pace of Permian oil and gas development, we need better protection of key wildlife habitat before it’s too late. There is still time for the BLM to improve its Carlsbad RMP with added protections for the land, air and water our wildlife and hunting traditions depend on.

Mark Pantuso is an active member of New Mexico Wildlife Federation and serves on the Sportsperson’s Advisory Committee to the N.M. State Land Office.


Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » BLM’s Carlsbad plan must balance oil and wildlife

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
'The Lost Archive' a collection of enjoyable realistic, historical ...
ABQnews Seeker
These 22 short stories, some previously ... These 22 short stories, some previously published, demonstrates writing that is crisp, smart, accessible and engaging.
PBS documentary looks at the life of solar power ...
ABQnews Seeker
"The Sun Queen" airs at 8 ... "The Sun Queen" airs at 8 p.m. Tuesday, April 4, on New Mexico PBS, channel 5.1, and is broadcast under the American Experience series. ...
Canna fairly easy to grow, come in wide varieties
ABQnews Seeker
The canna will want soil that ... The canna will want soil that can retain some moisture, but won't do too well if sitting in a puddle either.
New Mexico Photographic Art Show brings 188 works to ...
ABQnews Seeker
The 14th annual New Mexico Photographic ... The 14th annual New Mexico Photographic Art Show runs through April 18, in the Fine Arts Building at Expo New Mexico with work by ...
Fishing Line for April 2, 2023
Fishing Line
Val Armijo of Albuquerque caught a ... Val Armijo of Albuquerque caught a 20-inch brown trout on the Rio Chama using a Panther Martin spinner below Abiquiu Lake on March 23.
Albuquerque Half Marathon gears up for a fast pace ...
ABQnews Seeker
This year's edition of the Albuquerque ... This year's edition of the Albuquerque Half Marathon kicks off on Saturday, April 15.
Mountain bluebirds are often overlooked but gorgeous
ABQnews Seeker
The mountain bluebird is 7.25 inches ... The mountain bluebird is 7.25 inches long with a sky blue back, a whitish belly and a dark, short pointed beak. The female is ...
A small northern New Mexico community is trying to ...
ABQnews Seeker
The mission church at El Macho ... The mission church at El Macho has been a reassuring presence in Pecos Canyon for more than 165 years.
'Millet' for the win: State spelling bee finalists go ...
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Academy sixth grader Keith Lee ... Albuquerque Academy sixth grader Keith Lee spells the winning word and will represent NM at the national bee