NM should be scientific leader on nuclear issues - Albuquerque Journal

NM should be scientific leader on nuclear issues

I support the Journal’s (March 20) editorial, “NRC is right to put science before politics.” That editorial endorsed the Nuclear Regulatory Commission decision that the proposed interim used fuel storage site near Carlsbad and Hobbs presents minimal impacts on land, industry and public health. I learned first-hand how the NRC reaches decisions – based on sound science. From both my service at the NRC and as an assistant secretary at the DOE, with responsibility for all the nation’s nuclear energy programs, I agree that the NRC decision is correct.

New Mexico has a corner on the nation’s nuclear expertise and, therefore, I’m concerned when a decision is made at the Governor’s Office to argue against science and bow to politics. That political illogic has embroiled and endangered the nation during the coronavirus pandemic. We ignored science and followed the political path for too long in arguing the pandemic was a hoax or worse.

Good science stands on its own merits and I applaud the N.M. response to COVID-19. The decision of the state on the virus was correct and, on interim storage, it was wrong.

We have four great nuclear facilities in New Mexico: Los Alamos, Sandia, WIPP and the Urenco USA enrichment facility. Those four unquestionably share the expertise to handle a simple interim storage site – and an interim storage site is a very simple, safe nuclear installation. With the superb transportation record at WIPP, we clearly know that the risks of shipment of used fuel can be readily managed.

Attempts to move to interim storage during the Obama administration, which I helped lead, were consistently blocked in Congress. Yet the nation needs a solution for the used fuel that is now stored at many sites across America. New Mexico will benefit from providing good jobs at the interim storage site, while making a vital contribution to nuclear energy in the nation.

Nuclear energy provides safe, clean, dispatchable power for the nation. It currently accounts for about 20% of our total electricity and over half of our clean electricity. Countless studies are showing that a reliance solely on intermittent renewables will not suffice to reliably power a modern grid and support our high technology industrial society with clean energy. New Mexico should be building on its nuclear expertise and encouraging introduction of the new generation of reactors – ones that cannot melt down and that represent a new gold standard for safety. These new reactors, coupled with expanded renewables to provide 100% clean energy for the state, would be a real step forward for New Mexico and its leadership in the nation’s quest for clean energy.

In addition, an argument for 100% renewables ignores the fact that this technology does not exist today or in the foreseeable future. It requires storage technology that doesn’t exist and will have to be underpinned by dirty fossil energy. And estimates of the cost to seek 100% renewables, such as recent work at MIT, show the expenses of seeking that solution now are prohibitive.

True respect for science-based solutions in New Mexico would lead to support for interim storage, would validate the state’s path on containment of COVID-19 and would also abandon pipe dreams or political wishes for 100% renewable solutions for the state’s grid.

Let’s embrace good science through decisions at the state level that move New Mexico further into scientific leadership for the nation and the world.

Peter Lyons served as a commissioner of the U.S. NRC from 2005-2009 and as Science Advisor to U.S. Sen. Pete Domenici, R-N.M., from 1997-2005. He also served for over 30 years at Los Alamos National Laboratory and is now retired in Golden, Colo.


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop


Advisory panel endorses redistricting maps for New Mexico
ABQnews Seeker
Lawmakers plan to convene in December ... Lawmakers plan to convene in December to redraw a range of boundaries
NM awards millions for child care
From the newspaper
Checks start going out this month ... Checks start going out this month and could be a lifeline for struggling child care centers
CYFD probes child's death, reviews procedures
ABQnews Seeker
Aunt says she reported abuse of ... Aunt says she reported abuse of tot, siblings; dad, grandmother charged
CYFD to open bids for tech upgrade
ABQnews Seeker
Change follows departure of former Cabinet ... Change follows departure of former Cabinet secretary, who pushed for single vendor
Competency hearing set in school shooting
ABQnews Seeker
13-year-old will be tried as a ... 13-year-old will be tried as a juvenile if he is deemed fit
Plant-based milks offer an array of viable alternatives
From the newspaper
Q: Doctor, there are several types ... Q: Doctor, there are several types of plant-based milks available. Which one should I be giving my 3 ...
When the core musculature is working optimally, there is ...
From the newspaper
Maintaining the ideal alignment from the ... Maintaining the ideal alignment from the neck to the shoulder blades, spine and pelvis when performi ...
Best Bond song ever? Louis Armstrong's 'We Have All ...
You have questions. I have some ... You have questions. I have some answers.Both the film and the song, performed by Louis ...
'Cherry on top': Actor Julio Macias 'excited to be ...
Like many others, Julio Macias is ... Like many others, Julio Macias is adjusting to a new version of life.Things have chang ...