High Court rules against nursing home arbitration - Albuquerque Journal

High Court rules against nursing home arbitration

The state Supreme Court this week determined a nursing home agreement requiring residents to arbitrate their most likely claims, while allowing the facility to file suit over its most likely claims, is unenforceable.

The attorney for the plaintiffs said the opinion issued Monday sends an important message to New Mexico consumers that they can dispute arbitration agreements, and it gives a clear process for doing that.

The ruling comes in a case against multiple defendants, including the Rehabilitation Center of Albuquerque, which included in its 78-page admission agreement a clause stating that all claims, including allegations of negligent care, must go to mediation and then to arbitration rather than to court, according to the opinion. But it included an exception for claims involving disputes over the collection of money or discharge of patients – the claims the business would most likely file against its residents.

The attorney representing the defendants could not be reached for comment.

The plaintiff in the case, Keith Peavy, entered into the agreement on behalf of his mother, which specified that parties would attempt to mediate a claim first, and move on to arbitration before a panel of three arbitrators if necessary. Arbitration is a less formal, private form of dispute resolution.

Peavy filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the facility and others after his mother’s death in 2010. The defendants responded with a motion to dismiss and to compel arbitration. A District Court judge ultimately found that the agreement was “substantively unconscionable.”

The Supreme Court affirmed that order Monday, saying there was not enough evidence to show that the one-sidedness of the agreement was justified.

“We conclude that under New Mexico conscionability law a presumption of unfair and unreasonable one-sidedness arises when a drafting party excludes its likeliest claims from arbitration, while mandating that the other party arbitrate its likeliest claims,” the opinion written by Justice Shannon Bacon states. “This presumption stems from the lack of mutuality that correlates with overly one-sided contracts.”

That presumption can be overcome if the drafter can show that the exceptions are reasonable and fair.

The case will be sent back to the 2nd Judicial District Court.

Attorney Jeff Pitman, who represents the plaintiffs in the case, said nursing homes often use arbitration agreements, which are frequently included in a bulky admission packet and often don’t get explained very well.

“They’re asked to sign here, sign here, sign here, and usually we find that you’ve got an arbitration agreement tucked in there somewhere,” he said.

Refusal to sign, he said, sometimes means you can’t be admitted into the nursing home.

He said the ruling is big for New Mexico consumers at a time when arbitration agreements are ubiquitous.

“I think it’s important that consumers know that they have the right to dispute these agreements in New Mexico,” Pitman said. “And now we have a very clear process for them to do that.”

Home » News » New Mexico News » High Court rules against nursing home arbitration


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Cannon PFAS destroyed longtime Clovis farmer's dairy
ABQnews Seeker
State estimates put the farm's revenue ... State estimates put the farm's revenue losses and increased expenses at more than $5.9 million
2
Tainted peanut butter nearly kills retired Sunport canine 'ambassador'
ABQnews Seeker
The Jif she had eaten was ... The Jif she had eaten was apparently contaminated with salmonella bacteria
3
Soundtrack to summer: The songs of Isotopes Park
ABQnews Seeker
Dozens of songs make up the ... Dozens of songs make up the soundtrack of Isotopes Park -- keeping fans engaged whether the home team is doing 'So good! So good!' ...
4
Study: Areas may be at risk of floods, ash ...
ABQnews Seeker
US Forest Service officials warn of ... US Forest Service officials warn of increased danger
5
Detectives looking for murder suspect
ABQnews Seeker
Man, 22, accused of gunning down ... Man, 22, accused of gunning down acquaintance last week
6
4 candidates vie for GOP nomination in Bernalillo County ...
2022 election
BCSO employs 458 staff, 305 ... BCSO employs 458 staff, 305 being sworn deputies; office is largest in the state
7
Crews gain 50% containment on Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak Fire
ABQnews Seeker
Crews mapped out hotspots, official says Crews mapped out hotspots, official says
8
Navajo sign water rights settlement with Utah and feds
ABQnews Seeker
Federal officials signed an agreement with ... Federal officials signed an agreement with leaders of the Navajo Nation on Friday that provides funding for clean drinking water infrastructure for reservation residents ...
9
Veterans celebrated with Honor Flight
ABQnews Seeker
25 to be taken on a ... 25 to be taken on a free trip to visit memorials