Judge rules for state regarding large gatherings - Albuquerque Journal

Judge rules for state regarding large gatherings

Copyright © 2020 Albuquerque Journal

Journal Staff Writer

A federal judge has sided with the state on its ban on mass gatherings in places of worship during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The order by U.S. District Judge James Browning is in response to a complaint filed late last week by Legacy Church seeking a temporary restraining order and permanent injunction to prevent the “secretary (of health) from now enforcing mass gathering restrictions on places of worship, including Legacy’s four New Mexico campuses,” according to court documents.

“While Legacy continues to encourage its members to worship with them through their online services, the Secretary cannot require them to lock out parishioners if Legacy can provide the same socially distant measures used by essential businesses,” the church wrote. “In the alternative, Legacy requests that restrictions on gathering be no-less than those imposed on retail spaces in the state. Further in the alternative, Legacy requests the Court enjoin the Secretary and the State from enforcing the (April 11 order’s) mass gathering restriction of five people or more in a connected space, as it specifically targets people freely exercising their religious beliefs.”

However, Browning determined Friday that the public health order does not violate Legacy Church’s right to religious freedom because it is neutral and generally applicable. He also wrote that the order provides a “reasonable time, place and manner restriction,” so it doesn’t violate the church’s right to assemble.

The issue arose after state Health Secretary Kathy Kunkel issued a public health order last Saturday that included houses of worship in the ban on mass gatherings to stem the spread of coronavirus. Previous orders had made exemptions for churches, synagogues and mosques.

Pastor Steve Smothermon told the Journal earlier in the week that although Legacy Church had not planned to hold in-person services for Easter, its online production requires about 30 people in the building.

Executive Pastor Daniel McCabe said Friday that the judge’s order will allow the church to have more than five people in the room to produce the livestream services.

“We’ll continue to fight for churches to have the right to fill 20% of their auditoriums if they so choose,” he said.

After nearly 100 pages spelling out the arguments made by the Department of Health and the church and analysis of those arguments, Browning denied the church’s motion.

“The public’s interest in limiting the COVID-19 outbreak in the state, a compelling interest, outweighs the right to gather,” he wrote.

The Governor’s Office responded Friday by pointing out that the state is still allowing churches to conduct services through audiovisual means and other creative ways, such as drive-up services.

“For a limited time, during the pendency of this health emergency, the court saw the state was within its constitutional authority to restrict those gatherings,” said Nora Meyers Sackett, the governor’s spokeswoman. “As is clear in the order, nothing in the order precludes churches from conducting audiovisual presentations of their services.”

Home » News » Albuquerque News » Judge rules for state regarding large gatherings

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Blake's still serving up the food that makes it ...
ABQnews Seeker
The late Blake Chanslor launched his ... The late Blake Chanslor launched his eponymous restaurant way back in 1952.
Filmed in ABQ, 'Flamin' Hot' tells the story of ...
ABQnews Seeker
"Flamin' Hot" begins streaming Friday, June ... "Flamin' Hot" begins streaming Friday, June 9, on Hulu and Disney+.
Local actress lands part in New Mexico-filmed Cheetos movie
ABQnews Seeker
On June 9, "Flamin' Hot," starring ... On June 9, "Flamin' Hot," starring New Mexico native Lora Martinez-Cunningham, is set to stream on both Hulu and Disney+.
Country duo LOCASH making stop at Isleta with Kane ...
ABQnews Seeker
LOCASH recently released the single, "Three ... LOCASH recently released the single, "Three Favorite Colors" which has already become a hit at its concerts.
Pitino is high on UNM newcomers as Lobos start ...
ABQnews Seeker
A wide variety of updates on ... A wide variety of updates on Lobo hoops as UNM players start summer workouts, including Pitino's thoughts on rivalry scheduling and much more.
APS Superintendent Scott Elder to step down at the ...
ABQnews Seeker
The Albuquerque Public Schools board is ... The Albuquerque Public Schools board is parting ways with Superintendent Scott Elder. He was officially given the full position just over two years ago. ...
Local golf: Lobo Herron has memorable run -- and ...
ABQnews Seeker
For Carson Herron, golf's longest day ... For Carson Herron, golf's longest day started when the alarms went off around 5:45 a.m ...
Lobo football adds transfer receiver from Mississippi State
ABQnews Seeker
Mississippi State transfer wide receiver Kaydin ... Mississippi State transfer wide receiver Kaydin Pope, listed at 6-feet, 175 pounds, announced his intention to transfer to New Mexico on Wednesday via social ...
Details emerge in Albuquerque triple homicide: Police say shooters ...
ABQnews Seeker
Late Wednesday, police detailed what they ... Late Wednesday, police detailed what they believe happened at the Northeast Albuquerque home just before midnight Saturday.