Mixed ruling on state's ethics law - Albuquerque Journal

Mixed ruling on state’s ethics law

Copyright © 2020 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – The state Court of Appeals has ruled that part – but not all – of New Mexico’s anti-corruption law is too vague to be enforced.

In a complex ruling Friday, the court ordered the reinstatement of at least one ethics charge against three defendants – former Doña Ana County Treasurer David Gutierrez, 6th Judicial District Attorney Francesca Estevez and former San Juan County Magistrate Judge Connie Lee Johnston.

The judges didn’t rule on the defendants’ guilt or innocence, just that charges could proceed.

By contrast, the court dismissed a series of other charges against them and against former Taxation and Revenue Secretary Demesia Padilla.

Attorney General Hector Balderas said the ruling demonstrates the need for legislative action.

“I am grateful that the Court upheld that it is illegal for public officials to misuse a public office for personal gain,” Balderas said in a written statement. “However, the Court also made it clear that the legislature must clarify and strengthen public corruption laws to protect the public trust.”

Paul Kennedy, an attorney for Padilla, said he and his client “are of course happy with the Court’s decision. Frankly, it wasn’t a close call.”

The opinion focuses on whether public officials can face criminal prosecution for violating parts of the Governmental Conduct Act.

A three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals upheld one section of the law but struck down two others.

The court ruled that prosecutors may bring charges against officials who use their power or resources to “obtain personal benefits or pursue private interests” in violation of the act.

The judges ordered lower courts to reinstate charges under that section of the law against Gutierrez, Estevez and Johnston. Padilla wasn’t charged under that part of the law.

The Court of Appeals, however, ruled that two other sections of the law are too vague for criminal charges. Those parts of the law call for public officials to conduct themselves in a way that justifies the “confidence placed in them by the people” and for officials to make reasonable efforts to avoid undue influence and abuse of office.

The court upheld the dismissal of those charges against all four defendants. The opinion touched on cases against:

• Gutierrez, who was accused of pursing an unwanted sexual relationship with one of his employees.

• Estevez, who was accused of using her position to manipulate or intimidate officers investigating whether she had improperly used a state-owned vehicle.

• Johnston, accused of illegally recording communications of her colleagues in secure areas of a court building.

• Padilla, accused of using her position to access tax records of her old accounting firm and records of former clients.

The Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal of some ethics charges against Padilla. But still pending against her are allegations of engaging in an official act for personal financial gain, embezzlement and computer access with intent to defraud or embezzle.

The 35-page opinion was written by Judge Julie Vargas, with concurrence by two pro tem judges, retired Supreme Court Justice Richard Bosson and retired Appeals Court Judge Michael Bustamante.

The decision can be appealed to the Supreme Court.

Home » Journal North » Journal North Recent News » Mixed ruling on state’s ethics law


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
APD: 5 teens charged in woman's death
ABQnews Seeker
Police issue warrants on murder, believe ... Police issue warrants on murder, believe shooting was case of mistaken identity
2
AG campaigns rake in big bucks
2022 election
Over $2.5M raised by Democrats in ... Over $2.5M raised by Democrats in primary race
3
Uninsured homes leave New Mexicans vulnerable in areas hit ...
ABQnews Seeker
Insurance firms unwilling to cover rural ... Insurance firms unwilling to cover rural homes
4
State starts delivering inflation relief payments to residents
ABQnews Seeker
Goal to offset consumer costs amid ... Goal to offset consumer costs amid inflation
5
Fire shows minimal growth over weekend
ABQnews Seeker
Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak blaze at 40% ... Calf Canyon/Hermits Peak blaze at 40% containment, 310,253 total acres burned
6
APD investigating homicide in NE Albuquerque
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque police suspect foul play in ... Albuquerque police suspect foul play in the death of a man at an apartment complex off of Central near Tramway early Sunday morning. Gilbert ...
7
NEA grants 15 NM arts organizations $1.16M
ABQnews Seeker
The National Endowment for the Arts ... The National Endowment for the Arts announced its latest round of grants to arts organizations. Fifteen New Mexico organizations will receive a total of ...
8
Inn at Rio Rancho will reopen as apartment complex
ABQnews Seeker
Panorama Apartments will feature 102 units, ... Panorama Apartments will feature 102 units, major renovations
9
Burnout victim: ‘I cannot participate in the hustle culture’
ABQnews Seeker
Dear J.T. & Dale: I'm in ... Dear J.T. & Dale: I'm in my late 20s, single, and I struggle with several chronic illnesses. I cannot participate in the hustle culture. ...