From My Book Shelf to Yours: Only white people can be considered racist - Albuquerque Journal

From My Book Shelf to Yours: Only white people can be considered racist

Maureen Cooke

Robin DiAngelo’s “White Fragility: Why It’s So Hard for White People to Talk About Racism” (2018) is not an easy book to read. No, “White Fragility” is a disturbing, difficult book, a book that challenges white complacency and redefines what it is to be racist.

To understand, and possibly appreciate, “White Fragility,” it’s necessary to understand how DiAngelo defines certain terms.

First, DiAngelo acknowledges there is no biological determinant of race. Rather, race can be seen as socially constructed, meaning that a person’s racial identity is defined by the society at large.

DiAngelo then argues that to be white in the United States is to be afforded privileges unavailable to people of color (POC), specifically black people.

This disparity in privilege, DiAngelo argues, is why only whites can be considered racist. She distinguishes between racial prejudice and racism.

For DiAngelo, racial prejudice is the conscious dislike of, and possible discrimination against, those of a different race, while racism refers to the privileges and benefits an individual accrues simply by being white. Such racism can be seen as systemic in that it permeates all aspects of American culture, from education to medical care to entertainment, and because only white Americans benefit from systemic racism, according to DiAngelo, only whites can be considered racist.

From my perspective, DiAngelo’s redefinition of racist detracts from her argument that white people need to overcome their fragility and start discussing and eliminating racial inequality.

Any attempt to redefine such a loaded term as “racist'” is bound to be met with resistance. If the point of “White Fragility” is to encourage whites, and as many as possible, to grapple with their own racism in an effort to ameliorate racial inequality, then it seems wise to use language that is less inflammatory.

Being told that because I am white, I benefit from systemic racism is much more inviting than being told that because I am white, I’m a racist.

I was first introduced to this redefinition of “racist” years ago, when I read Beverly Daniel Tatum’s “Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?” I had a problem with the redefinition then; I have more of a problem with it now.

In the aftermath of George Floyd’s killing, with the protests that are tearing the country apart, it seems to me that the language we use to initiate conversation and establish systemic change needs to be inclusive and not inflammatory.

DiAngelo argues that whites tend to have difficulty with intense emotions that may arise during discussions of race. I recognize that my objecting to the redefinition of racist could be construed as my having difficulty with intense emotion, and my objection could possibly be dismissed.

However, I’m a writer; I understand the connotation of language, and I am at a loss to understand why DiAngelo would use such an inflammatory word, even if she has attempted to redefine it.

Regardless of the inflammatory language, I recommend “White Fragility.” There are ideas in this book that need to be discussed, preconceptions that need to be challenged and injustices that need to be rectified.

(Maureen Cooke has been writing, editing and teaching others to write for the past 30 years. Currently, she’s working on a mystery novel and a memoir. She’s a member of the Corrales Writers’ Group.)


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

Ad Tango

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
New Mexico surpasses 5,000 COVID deaths
ABQnews Seeker
Number of deceased more than doubles ... Number of deceased more than doubles state fatalities for three wars combined
2
Widow speaks out after husband died of COVID-19
ABQnews Seeker
'I didn't want his death to ... 'I didn't want his death to be in vain'
3
'If only he'd gotten vaccinated, this wouldn't have happened'
ABQnews Seeker
Gloria Dominguez, sister of the late ... Gloria Dominguez, sister of the late Anselmo 'Sam' Gutierrez, says she'll miss the magic he made
4
'Rust' investigation reveals more details
ABQnews Seeker
Baldwin was practicing revolver cross draw ... Baldwin was practicing revolver cross draw when deadly shot was fired
5
Lujan Grisham calls for net-zero emissions by 2050
ABQnews Seeker
Governor wants climate standards defined in ... Governor wants climate standards defined in state law
6
BCSO: Inmate killed at Metropolitan Detention Center
ABQnews Seeker
  An inmate was killed during ...   An inmate was killed during a fight in a general population cell at the Metropolitan Detention Center on Monday evening, according to the ...
7
Homicide call-out Monday night
Uncategorized
Albuquerque police were dispatched to the ... Albuquerque police were dispatched to the area of 13th Street and Lead Avenue about 7 p.m. Monday in reference to a call of a ...
8
Inmate killed following altercation at MDC
ABQnews Seeker
An inmate was killed following an ... An inmate was killed following an altercation just after 5:30 p.m. in the general population cell at the Metropolitan Detention Center on Monday, according ...
9
Police make arrests in two 2018 homicides
ABQnews Seeker
Both suspects, a male, 20, and ... Both suspects, a male, 20, and a female, 40, are in custody
10
Exhaustion in the ICU: Doctors reflect on state's nearly ...
From the newspaper
New Mexicans urged to get vaccinated, ... New Mexicans urged to get vaccinated, wear masks indoors