NM Supreme Court rules fines to enforce health orders are legal - Albuquerque Journal

NM Supreme Court rules fines to enforce health orders are legal

Chief Justice Michael Vigil delivers the Supreme Court’s decision in a case over whether the governor can impose fines against businesses violating the state public health order. Matt Garcia, representing the governor, top left on the screen, Carter Harrison, representing the group opposing the governor, top right, and Justice Barbara Vigil appeared by video during the hearing in Santa Fe on Tuesday. (Eddie Moore/Albuquerque Journal)

Copyright © 2020 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – The state Supreme Court ruled unanimously Tuesday that Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham’s administration is empowered to impose hefty fines when businesses violate New Mexico’s public health orders.

But the court left undecided whether companies are entitled to compensation from the state if they are forced to close or operate at limited capacity – an issue that can be pursued in separate litigation.

The decision, nonetheless, upholds a key enforcement power that state health officials say is critical to limiting the transmission of COVID-19: the ability to impose civil penalties of up to $5,000 a day for violating health orders.

“The state shouldn’t have to fine anybody,” Lujan Grisham said on Twitter after the court decision. “Doing the right thing in a crisis shouldn’t be something we have to argue about. But anyone endangering the lives of New Mexicans will face the consequences.”

The lawsuit – filed in May and backed by the state Republican Party – comes as New Mexico health officials prohibit indoor dining at restaurants and impose other business restrictions intended to slow the spread of COVID-19. The disease has killed 658 state residents since March.

Republican leaders have lashed out at Lujan Grisham, a Democrat, describing her orders as heavy-handed regulations that stifle business activity.

New Mexico’s five Supreme Court justices heard oral arguments and announced their decision from the bench Tuesday after deliberating behind closed doors for about 90 minutes. Each justice concurred with the ruling.

Chief Justice Michael Vigil said it’s clear the state may issue civil administrative penalties – such as the proposed fines – for violations of the emergency orders.

“The Legislature has clearly given the governor that authority,” Vigil said.

But the justices, he added, declined to rule on a separate question – whether businesses are entitled to compensation for being forced to close or operate at limited capacity.

Other lawsuits are pending on that issue, and the justices questioned whether Tuesday’s case was the appropriate time to take up the matter.

The case began May 20 with a lawsuit filed by K-Bob’s Steakhouse in Clovis, Frontier Auto Inc., Body & Sol Fitness LLC, the Colfax Tavern & Diner, J. Jones Massage and others.

They said the state’s health orders dramatically reduced their revenue and made it difficult to survive – all while they faced “potentially ruinous financial penalties” if they violated the rules.

A group that has been protesting against the Governor closing New Mexico businesses protest outside the New Mexico Supreme Court building in Santa Fe, Tuesday August 4, 2020. Some attended a hearing regarding the closures. (Eddie Moore/Albuquerque Journal)

In Tuesday’s hearing, Carter Harrison IV, who represented the businesses, urged the court to find that Lujan Grisham’s administration had overstepped its authority by threatening massive fines. Instead, he said, the administration is limited by law to $100 citations, not the larger $5,000 penalty.

More broadly, Harrison said, the executive branch had gone too far in determining how businesses may operate without offering procedural protections to safeguard people’s rights.

“Fundamentally,” he said, “it’s the Legislature’s role to do this. It’s the Legislature that makes policy.”

House Minority Leader James Townsend, R-Artesia, said after the hearing that the court had undermined the authority of the legislative branch.

“The court has just given the Governor unfettered power to create law during a health crisis,” he said in a written statement.

During Tuesday’s hearing, Lujan Grisham attorney Matthew Garcia said the larger fines were critical to enforcing the public health orders and ensuring immediate compliance. Only 16 businesses, he said, had faced the $5,000 penalty.

“It’s really only for the most egregious offenders,” Garcia said.

The state Department of Health has issued a host of orders since March, including a ban on mass gatherings and a mask mandate.

Most businesses are permitted to operate at partial capacity, though bars remain closed entirely and restaurants are limited to takeout, delivery and limited outdoor seating.

Tuesday’s court hearing was held through a videoconferencing program. Four justices – all wearing masks – were present in the courtroom.

The fifth justice and both attorneys participated through a video link.

Courts have generally upheld the state’s authority to impose restrictions during the public health emergency. In July, for example, U.S. District Judge James O. Browning ruled in favor of the state’s right to limit the operating capacity of churches and other houses of worship, finding that it didn’t violate religious freedoms.

But other legal challenges are still pending, including a lawsuit filed by the New Mexico Restaurant Association, which is seeking to block the state’s ban on indoor dining at restaurants and breweries.

Home » Journal North » Journal North Recent News » NM Supreme Court rules fines to enforce health orders are legal

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Meet the former Alamogordo resident making a big impact ...
ABQnews Seeker
He grew up in New Mexico, ... He grew up in New Mexico, so it was no surprise Houston Astros prospect Quincy Hamilton looked at home in Isotopes Park this week.
Five factors to consider as United takes "professional approach" ...
ABQnews Seeker
Save the long-odds conversation for someone ... Save the long-odds conversation for someone else. United's players and coaches don't want to hear it.
UNM's Museum of Southwestern Biology to display collections at ...
ABQnews Seeker
From 4-9 p.m. Wednesday, June 14, ... From 4-9 p.m. Wednesday, June 14, the public is invited to "Evolution Revealed: An Open Collections Event."
Hundreds pack Santa Fe cathedral for Archbishop Sheehan’s funeral ...
ABQnews Seeker
Achbishop Emeritus Michael J. Sheehan died ... Achbishop Emeritus Michael J. Sheehan died June 3 at age 83. Here's how he was remembered.
Barelas Park reopens after nearly $2 million renovation
ABQnews Seeker
Barelas Park reopened to the public ... Barelas Park reopened to the public Wednesday with many new features.
New Mexico State Police officer accused of sexually assaulting ...
ABQnews Seeker
A State Police officer was arrested ... A State Police officer was arrested Friday in the alleged sexual assault of a 20-year-old woman while the two were on a New Mexico ...
Solomon Peña to remain in custody, judge rules
ABQnews Seeker
A judge said he could find ... A judge said he could find no conditions of release that would reasonably ensure the safety of the community, despite a defense attorney's contention ...
Proposed rule for public lands expected to have outsized ...
ABQnews Seeker
A coalition of conservation and outdoor ... A coalition of conservation and outdoor recreation enthusiasts is urging New Mexicans to support the proposal. Opponents, in turn, question whether the rule will ...
Green chile cheeseburger review: Griff's Hamburgers
ABQnews Seeker
The green chile cheeseburger tour heads ... The green chile cheeseburger tour heads to the International District.