Editorial: Archbishop's nuclear weapons view needs a homily on reality - Albuquerque Journal

Editorial: Archbishop’s nuclear weapons view needs a homily on reality

A world without nuclear weapons. For that matter a world without war – “a world grounded not in fear and distrust, but in mutual respect for the life and dignity of all.”

That idyllic goal for the planet Earth and the 7.6 billion people who inhabit it was front and center in the message from Archbishop of Santa Fe John Wester last week marking the 75th anniversary of the atomic bomb in Hiroshima that ushered in an age of nuclear weapons that endures to this day.

The U.S. Conference of Bishops, he said, reminds us that the United States has a responsibility to reverse the spread of nuclear, chemical and biological weapons and quotes Pope Francis as saying that money spent on such things in the name of national defense when millions live in inhumane conditions is “an affront crying out to heaven.”

His comments were in a program put together by peace activist Fr. John Dear, who says that unlike Pope John Paul II, Francis believes nuclear weapons can no longer be justified as a deterrent. “Deterrence has nothing to do with Jesus,” he said. You must love your enemy, and a nation that builds or maintains nuclear weapons is “all the same pure level of evil.”

While Wester acknowledges two of the nation’s pre-eminent nuclear weapons labs are located in New Mexico – he says the 20,000 plus employees at Sandia and Los Alamos should work on other, more morally acceptable, projects – he and Dear appear to be living in a world that sounds lovely but will never exist.

Neither Wester nor Dear appear to accept the premise there is any deterrent benefit to the nuclear arsenal – even though the horrors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki have kept a nuclear peace since 1945 even as nations like Pakistan and North Korea have developed nuclear weapons. And they don’t acknowledge that use of the weapons by President Truman saved hundreds of thousands of Allied soldiers, sailors and Marines and millions of Japanese because they forced Japan to surrender rather than fight to the last man.

Horrific? Yes. Estimates of the death toll from the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki range from 120,000 to 230,000. But war is horrific. World War II claimed 60 million lives.

In an interesting juxtaposition, the archdiocese vicar general took a more balanced approach in a piece he wrote for the August edition of the People of God newsletter for Catholics in the Archdiocese of Santa Fe. “Many criticize the U.S. use of the atomic bomb to end WWII, but war pursued in ANY manner is a horror,” the Very Rev. Glennon Jones writes. “It plagues humanity regardless.”

He argues firebombing in Japanese and German cities killed at least as many as the atomic bombs. And that bombing would have continued along with an invasion of Japan.

“Only the shock of the immense power contained in a single bomb – and the uncertainty about how many such bombs the U.S. possessed – convinced the Japanese emperor to break the ruling council’s deadlock in favor of surrender and peace.” Japan today is a key U.S. ally.

As for unilateral disarmament as some propose? While other nuclear-capable nations would not likely be impressed, Jones writes, “it’s entirely likely a worldwide nuclear free-for-all might ensue.” And as for pacifistic wholesale surrender to “save lives?” “It might do so for time but … history shows genocide becomes a real possibility when rulers weary of the powerless ruled.”

So much for loving your enemy.

The ideal, Jones writes, may be “No Nukes!”

“But until the day arrives in which such disarmament and its absolute verification is possible, the mission of the Los Alamos and Sandia labs is not only valid but essential in maintaining the (admittedly tense) nuclear restraint through the world,” Jones writes. “There is a vital difference, between the promotion of an ideal and being naively idealistic.”

To which we would add, “Amen.”

This editorial first appeared in the Albuquerque Journal. It was written by members of the editorial board and is unsigned as it represents the opinion of the newspaper rather than the writers.

Home » Opinion » Editorials » Editorial: Archbishop’s nuclear weapons view needs a homily on reality

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Editorial: NM can’t afford to go backward on government ...
From the Editorial Board: The Inspection ... From the Editorial Board: The Inspection of Public Records Act has a presumption that citizens are entitled to the greatest possible amount of information ...
Editorial: NM lands need a state 'legacy fund,' true ...
From the Editorial Board: A healthy ... From the Editorial Board: A healthy outdoors is a healthy part of New Mexico's fiscal landscape, so the chance to unlock federal matching funds ...
Editorial: Legislative package has sensible measures to address rampant ...
From the Editorial Board: When you ... From the Editorial Board: When you get a Democratic governor, Republican and Democratic lawmakers, the Albuquerque police chief, the district attorney and the attorney ...
Editorial: How useful is the Arnold tool?
From the Editorial Board: New Mexicans ... From the Editorial Board: New Mexicans still waiting for fair and uniform pretrial release determination system.
Editorial: More NM districts should follow APS, set student ...
From the Editorial Board: It's essential ... From the Editorial Board: It's essential for goals to last longer than board members or an administrator's tenure.
Editorial: Gun laws should enhance safety, target criminal acts
From the Editorial Board: Lawmakers should ... From the Editorial Board: Lawmakers should focus gun legislation on sensible steps that can make a difference without feeding the notion that the government ...
Editorial: ABQ needs to clean up its paths and ...
From the Editorial Board: Downtown, where ... From the Editorial Board: Downtown, where the city has invested money trying to make the area a liveable, attractive center of the city, the ...
Editorial: Better habits can help prevent traffic deaths
From the Editorial Board: While not ... From the Editorial Board: While not every crash is survivable, deadly accidents could be reduced by simple steps.
Editorial: AFR-APS teamwork could rescue NM workforce
From the Editorial Board: So here's ... From the Editorial Board: So here's to monitoring the AFR-APS ambassador program, and scaling it up to other careers and other districts — for ...