Renewables are not to blame for California blackouts - Albuquerque Journal

Renewables are not to blame for California blackouts

By STEFI WEISBURD

The Journal’s recent editorial using California’s blackouts to criticize our state’s progression toward carbon-free electricity production by 2045 does a great disservice to its readers by blaming the blackouts on California’s move toward renewables.

While the cause of the blackouts is still being investigated, the head of the California Independent System Operator, which controls the flow of most of California’s electricity, last week said the state’s added renewables had nothing to do with the blackouts.

California usually relies on 200 natural gas plants plus hydroelectric and other sources to supply electricity when the sun goes down. While the Journal argues for natural gas plants to increase reliability, it was actually several natural gas plants that tripped and went down unexpectedly, contributing to the drop in capacity. The cause of the plant shutdowns is not yet clear, although it is known that high ambient temperatures can cause a drop in gas plant efficiency.

Hydroelectric plants were operating below capacity that week because of low water levels, and the state was unable to purchase additional power from neighboring regions because these states were also suffering from high temperatures. The Journal also references California’s 2001 blackouts but fails to remind readers that these were caused entirely by Enron’s market manipulations and had nothing to do with any lack in the physical energy supply.

It is also worth noting that the peak demand in mid-August in California did not set a record. The grid there had handled more demand in the past without staging a blackout, and the blackouts were ordered this time when the operating reserves of power available to the utilities were around 8% – higher than the 3% guide usually used to trigger a blackout. This is another factor that has puzzled observers of the blackout decision.

The editorial quotes (California) Gov. (Gavin) Newsom saying he won’t sacrifice reliability. But his next sentence, which the Journal did not quote, was that California needs to meet this need for reliability in the face of record-breaking heat brought on by climate change by having a demand-response system. This means employing “smart grids” or automatic systems that better match demand to supply. …

It also means allowing a utility to buy energy from small plants – California only buys from big power generators – or even from customers who might have batteries in their house like a Tesla power wall. Parts of New Mexico’s grid are 100 years old. We could use a smart grid, too.

The Journal editors express doubts about future battery and energy storage development, which would provide power when solar cells predictably stop producing. I invite them to visit their neighbors – the national laboratories, New Mexico universities and entrepreneurs who are making great strides in this area every day. I invite them to support initiatives to modernize our aging power grid to make it smart and agile so it can automatically balance demand and supply and allow New Mexico, with its abundant sun and wind resources, to sell to other states.

Finally, the haze from Western fires that reduced solar cell output and the unprecedented heat that increased electricity demand while also reducing solar cell, hydroelectric and natural gas power plant efficiency are here to stay. It is only going to get hotter and drier and more prone to fires.

We cannot expect to air-condition our way comfortably into the future if we are powering those air conditioners with fossil fuel plants spewing carbon into the atmosphere, which is making the temperature even higher. Yes, editors, it is 100 degrees, and rising. But don’t blame renewables.

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Renewables are not to blame for California blackouts


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Lobo hoops notes: Schedule nearly complete, staff movement, Maluach ...
ABQnews Seeker
The Lobos's 2022-23 schedule is nearly ... The Lobos's 2022-23 schedule is nearly complete, UNM is getting a new video coordinator, former Lobo Makuach Maluach's new team...
2
Colón doesn't understand AG's role
From the newspaper
Lifelong prosecutor Torrez is better suited ... Lifelong prosecutor Torrez is better suited for the job
3
Crime crisis can't wait until the next legislative session
From the newspaper
As state representatives, the issue our ... As state representatives, the issue our constituents ask us about the most is what we are doing to f ...
4
Drop lies and hate, focus on solutions for better ...
From the newspaper
As the news broke last weekend ... As the news broke last weekend of a mass shooting in Buffalo, New York, we joined the nation in mour ...
5
Editorial: Make fire-ravaged NM whole
Editorials
The federal response to Gov. Michelle ... The federal response to Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham's request for disaster relief as a result ...
6
Costs of child care are subsidized for eligible families
From the newspaper
The newly expanded Child Care Assistance ... The newly expanded Child Care Assistance Program subsidizes the cost of child care for families at o ...
7
Journal Poll: Ronchetti enjoys big lead over GOP rivals ...
2022 election
Strong name recognition puts ex-meteorologist at ... Strong name recognition puts ex-meteorologist at top of primary pack
8
State removes breakthrough case data from COVID reports
ABQnews Seeker
Move comes as vaccinated people comprise ... Move comes as vaccinated people comprise greater share of infections
9
ABQ resident donates grand piano to Easter Island
ABQnews Seeker
Loralee Cooley gifts her beloved Steinway ... Loralee Cooley gifts her beloved Steinway to the School of Music and Arts of Rapa Nui