Letter to the editor: Oppose state constitution change - Albuquerque Journal

Letter to the editor: Oppose state constitution change

Editor:

Toward the bottom of your ballot you will find Constitutional Amendment 1.

There are at least three good reasons to vote on it: The problem it seeks to fix has already been addressed, the amendment is being presented in a misleading manner and a mysterious political action committee (PAC) is spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to promote the amendment without disclosing the source of that dark money.

Recently, a PAC called the “Committee to Protect New Mexico Consumers” has sent out four slick and misleading mailers in support of Constitutional Amendment 1 at a cost of more than $264,000. The PAC was cited by the state Ethics Commission for failing to file required disclosures, and still adamantly refuses to disclose where all that money is coming from.

If this constitutional amendment is really so good for consumers, why are the people who are bankrolling it hiding their identities from the public? (In a recent Albuquerque Journal article, one of the PAC’s board members promised to reveal the donors…. after the election.)

Second, I join PRC Commissioner Steve Fischmann in objecting to the way Constitutional Amendment 1 appears on your ballot. The description of the amendment never indicates that the PRC is being converted from an elected commission to an appointed one; it fails to inform the public that if they vote in favor, they will give up their power to elect and hold accountable future PRC commissioners.

In 2011 Think New Mexico published a policy report recommending several reforms to the PRC. Based on the research in that report, Think New Mexico successfully advocated for the enactment of three constitutional amendments approved by the voters in 2012.

One amendment empowered the legislature to increase the qualifications of PRC commissioners. Prior to that reform, the only qualifications were that they had to be at least 18 years old, lived in New Mexico for at least a year and were not convicted felons.

Those minimal qualifications resulted in many commissioners who were not able to do the job well. So Think New Mexico’s constitutional amendment and the law enacted the following year to implement it required that PRC commissioners have at least 10 years of relevant work experience or education.

These reforms have had a very positive effect. Current commissioners include an environmental engineer, an attorney, a business executive and people with experience in state and federal government.

In northern New Mexico, there is an election for a PRC seat between a Democrat who is a civil engineer and a former mayor, and a Libertarian who has a PhD in physics and runs a green energy company. Contrary to the core argument of proponents of Constitutional Amendment 1, the PRC doesn’t lack for professional qualifications, and the criminal behavior it references has not been a problem since voters overwhelmingly passed the 2012 constitutional amendment.

The current system strikes a good balance by requiring commissioners to be qualified to do the job while still being accountable to the public that elects them. I encourage you to vote against Constitutional Amendment 1.

Fred Nathan Jr.

Santa Fe


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop

MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS

1
Finding redemption in prison
ABQnews Seeker
Los Lunas inmates provide compassion, hope ... Los Lunas inmates provide compassion, hope to peers
2
Investigation into officer's death a 'slap in the face,' ...
ABQnews Seeker
NMSP officer gunned down by federally-wanted ... NMSP officer gunned down by federally-wanted suspect during traffic stop on Feb. 4
3
'Honest' Martínez rises in ranks to House leadership
ABQnews Seeker
Lawmaker backs diverse legislation on education, ... Lawmaker backs diverse legislation on education, cannabis and tax rates
4
New approach to teaching race in school divides NM
ABQnews Seeker
Students would learn about social identity ... Students would learn about social identity under new plan
5
Lawsuit says Belen firefighter fired for reporting COVID-19 case
ABQnews Seeker
Man believes he was terminated for ... Man believes he was terminated for notifying human resources of sick co-worker
6
GOP leader has 'no regrets' for Trump certificate
ABQnews Seeker
Law enforcement is looking into an ... Law enforcement is looking into an election-related document
7
Attorneys say jail could not find inmates for hearings
ABQnews Seeker
Bernalillo County: No one has gotten ... Bernalillo County: No one has gotten lost in the detention system
8
NM's GOP files lawsuit over new congressional map
ABQnews Seeker
Suit asks judge to replace new ... Suit asks judge to replace new boundaries with a map proposed by the Citizen Redistricting Commit
9
APD investigates 2 homicides over several hours
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque Police Department's Homicide Unit is ... Albuquerque Police Department's Homicide Unit is investigating after a dead body was discovere ...
10
COVID tests out there ... somewhere
ABQnews Seeker
Testing shortages are unnerving the public Testing shortages are unnerving the public