AG backs plaintiff in UNM records case

Copyright © 2020 Albuquerque Journal

Daniel Libit

The New Mexico Attorney General’s Office in a recent court filing took issue with the University of New Mexico and its fundraising entities’ reason for withholding records from the public, calling it “erroneous and inconsistent with the law.”

The AG’s Office, as well as the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government, recently filed briefs in a lawsuit brought by an independent journalist trying to obtain records related to naming-rights deals and fundraising for UNM athletics.

The briefs were filed in a case before the state Court of Appeals combining two lawsuits that Daniel Libit, a journalist, has against UNM, the UNM Foundation and the UNM Lobo Club.

Attorneys for UNM and the UNM Foundation and Lobo Club, have argued, in part, that because the records Libit requested are being kept by the foundation and the club – private, nonprofit entities – the records are not subject to state open-records laws.

“From a policy perspective, appellants’ interpretation would permit and encourage public bodies to avoid transparency and accountability by utilizing the services of nonprofit organizations,” the AG’s Office said.

The appellants in the case are the UNM Foundation, the Lobo Club, the UNM Board of Regents and a university records custodian.

Officials for UNM and the foundation declined to comment on the recent court filings, saying it’s their practice not to comment on pending litigation.

FOG, in its brief, said the records being sought are especially important to the public because UNM athletics has been “beset with problems related to financial irregularities.”

FOG cited a state audit of UNM athletics finances that found years of financial missteps and perks given to employees and donors.

Libit, who operated the website, filed a lawsuit against UNM and the UNM Foundation in March 2017 in an effort to obtain records from the foundation. He argued that the two entities operate in such a close and intertwined effort that the foundation is subject to the Inspection of Records Act.

State District Judge Nancy Franchini ruled in 2019 that case that the foundation met all nine court-established criteria used to determine when a private body acts on behalf of a public agency and the requested records are subject to IPRA.

“The Foundation acts on behalf of the University in its fundraising efforts,” Franchini’s ruling says. “The University’s and the Foundation’s fundraising efforts are inherently public in nature.”

The foundation appealed the ruling, saying that it needed to protect donor privacy.

Share Your Story

Nativo Sponsored Content

taboola desktop


Transforming NM's Public Schools: Kurt Steinhaus rises from teacher ...
ABQnews Seeker
Challenges include pandemic, reducing the rate ... Challenges include pandemic, reducing the rate of dropouts
Transforming NM's public schools: PED's new chief outlines ...
ABQnews Seeker
PED's new chief outlines lofty goals, ... PED's new chief outlines lofty goals, vows to make this "the year of literacy"
New Mexico backs Texas in opposing nuclear fuel storage
ABQnews Seeker
Holtec facility seeking approval Holtec facility seeking approval
BLM moving back to DC, reversing Trump-era decision
ABQnews Seeker
  WASHINGTON -- Interior Secretary Deb ...   WASHINGTON -- Interior Secretary Deb Haaland is moving the national headquarters of the Bureau of Land Management back to the nation's capital after ...
Champion of the ABQ's West Side remembered
ABQnews Seeker
Community leader Dr. Joe Valles advocated ... Community leader Dr. Joe Valles advocated for smart development
Irrigation innovation
ABQnews Seeker
Drought tests centuries-old water traditions in ... Drought tests centuries-old water traditions in New Mexico
New state law banned a county's gas stations from ...
ABQnews Seeker
It was a 'no brainer,' one ... It was a 'no brainer,' one owner says.
UPDATE: APD says missing 4-year old found safe
ABQnews Seeker
Albuquerque police say they are no ... Albuquerque police say they are no longer looking for Catiana Zepeda, the 4-year-old whose mother was found dead on Friday in an apartment in ...
At Kirtland AFB, a scramble to enact vaccine policy
ABQnews Seeker
Details still being worked out Details still being worked out