NM Supreme Court mulls pandemic compensation - Albuquerque Journal

NM Supreme Court mulls pandemic compensation

New Mexico Supreme Court Justice Shannon Bacon, shown on a video screen in the court’s chambers, asks a question during a Wednesday hearing on business compensation during the COVID-19 pandemic. The hearing was conducted entirely remotely and broadcast live online. (Eddie Moore/Journal)

Copyright © 2021 Albuquerque Journal

SANTA FE – The New Mexico Supreme Court did not issue an immediate ruling Wednesday on whether businesses affected by pandemic-related closures and restrictions imposed by Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham’s administration can recoup their losses.

After hearing arguments during an unprecedented entirely virtual hearing, the state’s highest court deliberated for more than an hour before its clerk announced no same-day opinion would be issued.

The case in question involves more than a dozen lawsuits that were filed in lower courts around New Mexico against the governor and top state health officials last year.

The plaintiffs, which include a Roswell musician, a Clovis liquor store and a Santa Fe oxygen bar, specifically claim the Lujan Grisham administration’s business restrictions imposed in response to the COVID-19 pandemic have had a significant financial impact.

The Governor’s Office had sought to have the lawsuits dismissed and requested the Supreme Court address the underlying legal issue.

Nicholas Sydow, who is Attorney General Hector Balderas’ civil appellate chief, represented the state in the case and argued Wednesday that public health orders are not grounds for compensation claims under New Mexico law and the state’s Constitution.

In addition, he said any such financial relief should be provided by the Legislature – not the courts.

“When the state regulates public health and safety, it’s not taking away existing property rights,” Sydow said. “It’s exercising the inherent authority to ensure that property is not used in a fashion that endangers the public.”

In contrast, the plaintiffs in the lawsuits have argued the state’s Public Health Emergency Response Act calls for state government to provide compensation for health facilities and other businesses it takes over during an emergency.

Attorney Blair Dunn, who’s representing the various plaintiffs, called the state’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic “draconian.”

He also said the science underpinning Lujan Grisham’s actions is debatable and should not be accepted as undisputed fact.

“The right to have property and have it not taken away by the government is a fundamental right in our Bill of Rights,” Dunn said Wednesday.

Lujan Grisham has acknowledged the economic damage inflicted by the pandemic, including a state unemployment rate that has been among the nation’s highest in recent months. But she has said the business restrictions are necessary to keep the virus from spreading rapidly and overwhelming New Mexico’s health care system.

The Supreme Court hearing occurred, for the first time in state history, with all justices and attorneys participating remotely via online technology.

Recently-appointed Supreme Court Justice Julie Vargas did not take part in the hearing, as retired Court of Appeals Judge Michael Bustamante joined the Supreme Court’s other four judges in hearing the case.

A ruling in the case could be released in the coming days.

Home » Journal North » Journal North Recent News » NM Supreme Court mulls pandemic compensation

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Meet the former Alamogordo resident making a big impact ...
ABQnews Seeker
Most people around Isotopes Park didn't ... Most people around Isotopes Park didn't even realize Quincy Hamilton, the 24-year-old outfielder who grew up in Alamogordo, was actually "from New Mexico" at ...
Five factors to consider as United takes "professional approach" ...
ABQnews Seeker
Save the long-odds conversation for someone ... Save the long-odds conversation for someone else. United's players and coaches don't want to hear it.
UNM's Museum of Southwestern Biology to display collections at ...
ABQnews Seeker
From 4-9 p.m. Wednesday, June 14, ... From 4-9 p.m. Wednesday, June 14, the public is invited to "Evolution Revealed: An Open Collections Event."
Hundreds pack Santa Fe cathedral for Archbishop Sheehan’s funeral ...
ABQnews Seeker
Achbishop Emeritus Michael J. Sheehan died ... Achbishop Emeritus Michael J. Sheehan died June 3 at age 83. Here's how he was remembered.
Barelas Park reopens after nearly $2 million renovation
ABQnews Seeker
Barelas Park reopened to the public ... Barelas Park reopened to the public Wednesday with many new features.
New Mexico State Police officer accused of sexually assaulting ...
ABQnews Seeker
A State Police officer was arrested ... A State Police officer was arrested Friday in the alleged sexual assault of a 20-year-old woman while the two were on a New Mexico ...
Solomon Peña to remain in custody, judge rules
ABQnews Seeker
A judge said he could find ... A judge said he could find no conditions of release that would reasonably ensure the safety of the community, despite a defense attorney's contention ...
Proposed rule for public lands expected to have outsized ...
ABQnews Seeker
A coalition of conservation and outdoor ... A coalition of conservation and outdoor recreation enthusiasts is urging New Mexicans to support the proposal. Opponents, in turn, question whether the rule will ...
Green chile cheeseburger review: Griff's Hamburgers
ABQnews Seeker
The green chile cheeseburger tour heads ... The green chile cheeseburger tour heads to the International District.