Residents say ‘death map’ should spur EPA action - Albuquerque Journal

Residents say ‘death map’ should spur EPA action

Copyright © 2013 Albuquerque Journal

GRANTS – A federal agency needs to either move the tailings from an abandoned uranium mill near Milan or relocate the owners of about 75 nearby homes, the residents told a top U.S. Environmental Protection Agency official on Tuesday.

Residents told Ron Curry, EPA’s Region 6 administrator, that a cluster of cancer cases in subdivisions near the Homestake Mining Co. uranium mill show a need for immediate action by the agency.

They pointed to a draft EPA report published this month showing that residents near the mill face a cancer risk 18 times higher than that considered acceptable by the EPA.

Curry met with homeowners on Tuesday at the home of Jonnie and Milt Head, who live about 2,000 feet southwest of a mile-long tailings pile left by milling operations at the site from 1958 to 1990.

At least 20 cases of cancer, including four deaths, and five cases of thyroid disease have occurred among residents who live within a mile of the sprawling Superfund site about 4.5 miles north of Milan.

Residents showed Curry a “death map” showing illnesses clustered in a small area just south and west of the site.

 Ron Curry, is  the EPA Region 6 admin. who met with owners about contamination from the Homestake Uranium mill just north of Milan. In this photo he listens to a homeowner speak about their finding regarding the contamination of the nearby area.   In the photo, images of nearby residents allegedly who became ill are posted on an aerial map depicting the Homestake tailings pile and the surrounding community.  All the smaller arrows posted on the map indicate possible victims of complications due to some form of cancer.
Ron Curry, is the EPA Region 6 admin. who met with owners about contamination from the Homestake Uranium mill just north of Milan. In this photo he listens to a homeowner speak about their finding regarding the contamination of the nearby area. In the photo, images of nearby residents allegedly who became ill are posted on an aerial map depicting the Homestake tailings pile and the surrounding community. All the smaller arrows posted on the map indicate possible victims of complications due to some form of cancer.

Area resident Art Gebeau, a retired mining engineer, said the Homestake tailings ultimately threaten water supplies in Milan, Grants and other communities. Moving the tailings pile, which he estimated at 23 million tons of material, may be essential for protecting water supplies, he said.

“Even if you bought out all the people here, where would you stop?” Gebeau said.

Curry told about a dozen residents Tuesday that the EPA has taken actions in the past to help “fence-line communities” bordering industrial sites that include relocating residents and moving tailings piles.

Curry also said he is willing to negotiate with corporate entities that own the Homestake site to help finance a remedy once a course of action is identified.

“If we got a pathway to a solution that we think is scientifically sound, that we think is beneficial to the community, the EPA is not afraid to sit down with the businesses,” he said.

Curry agreed to discuss the proposals with EPA officials in Dallas within 60 days.

Jonnie Head said she and other residents focused attention for decades on groundwater contamination from the mill. But a cluster of cancer cases, and the new EPA report, shifted their attention to high levels of airborne radon tested in ambient air near the mill.

Candice Head-Dylla, 54, the daughter of Milt and Jonnie Head, said she believes a precancerous illness that required the removal of her thyroid five years ago is related to contamination from the Homestake mill. Head-Dylla grew up within sight of the giant tailings pile, which looms over area homes.

Residents are frustrated that officials took decades to alert them to the hazards of airborne radiation from the mill, she said.

“They have known about the (groundwater) contamination since 1961,” Head-Dylla said. “It took them until 1974 to tell us to quit drinking the water. Almost 40 years it took them to figure out that we were being exposed to radiation.”

In 1975, the EPA found elevated levels of pollutants in area wells and said the contamination came from the Homestake mill. Evidence of groundwater contamination was first observed in 1961, according to the EPA.

Under the terms of a 1983 consent decree with the EPA, Homestake hooked up homes to alternate water supplies and paid for their water use until 1995.

Jonnie Head said contamination from the mill now is showing up in a deeper aquifer she and other residents use to irrigate crops on their land.

A draft human risk assessment for the site published this month by the EPA found that residents within a few miles south and west of the site face a cancer risk 18 times the EPA’s “generally acceptable risk” range.

Cancer occurrences greater than one case per 10,000 people exceed the EPA’s generally acceptable range.

Most of the risk is due to inhalation of outdoor radon, a radioactive material, the report found.

More than a decade has passed since uranium ore was mined in New Mexico, but a Canada-based company and a Japanese partner proposed this year reopening a mine near Grants.

The Roca Honda uranium mine near Mount Taylor – idle for 23 years – is seeking a shift in its permit status to “active,” although it wouldn’t produce any uranium for years.

Rio Grande Resources Corp. applied in April to the New Mexico Mining and Minerals Division to revise the Mt. Taylor Mine’s permit by October 2014, when its current “standby” permit is scheduled to expire.

Jonnie Head said it would be a mistake to reopen the Roca Honda mine, located about 20 miles north of her home.

“Based on our experience with uranium mining, we don’t think uranium mining is a good idea to begin with” and would use large amounts of scarce water, she said.

Home » News » New Mexico News » Residents say ‘death map’ should spur EPA action

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories




Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages

 

Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
1
Doctors flee New Mexico – and more ...
ABQnews Seeker
The state's physician numbers are under ... The state's physician numbers are under national provider-to-population benchmarks
2
U.S. Fish and Wildlife counts, treats and gathers data ...
ABQnews Seeker
Annual count is part of federal ... Annual count is part of federal Wolf Recovery Plan
3
Untangling the policies and politics of New Mexico's medical ...
ABQnews Seeker
Legislature looking at changes to 2021 ... Legislature looking at changes to 2021 law designed to help doctors
4
Electric Playhouse places bet for second location on the ...
ABQnews Seeker
The ABQ-based company that focuses on ... The ABQ-based company that focuses on interactive and immersive play experiences is set to open its second location on the Las Vegas Strip by ...
5
Bill seeks to stanch rise of organized retail crime
ABQnews Seeker
'We can’t operate like this,' business ... 'We can’t operate like this,' business owner, robbery victim says. 'People have just had it.'
6
Three charged in large-scale drug operation in South Valley
ABQnews Seeker
Thursday raid of several homes and ... Thursday raid of several homes and a storage unit turns up drugs, guns and hundreds of thousands in cash
7
'It's been a great ride': Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive ...
ABQnews Seeker
Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive director is ... Longtime Balloon Fiesta executive director is retiring
8
No drama for birthday llama: ABQ llama celebrates 27th ...
ABQnews Seeker
'This llama is bringing everyone together,' ... 'This llama is bringing everyone together,' says family friend
9
New Mexico seems determined to extend class time. What ...
ABQnews Seeker
Three competing proposals are on the ... Three competing proposals are on the table